Zionism Is Not Racism
Open the letter in my email app

The question, answered

Is Zionism racism?

No. Zionism is the belief that Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to a homeland of their own. Calling that belief racism singles out one people, the Jews, for a rule applied to no one else. That is itself a form of racism, and UK law recognises Jews as an ethnic group protected from it.

Venn diagram titled Criticism of Israel, anti-Zionism and antisemitism: how they relate. Left circle, criticism of Israel, not antisemitic: criticism of the Israeli government, its policies or actions; support for Palestinian rights, statehood and self-determination; opposing a particular war, settlement, law or minister; backing any peace both peoples agree to. Overlap, anti-Zionism, which denies Jews what every other people has: says the Jewish people alone have no right to a homeland; calls the existence of Israel a racist endeavour, the IHRA definition's own example of antisemitism; calls Zionism, the belief of most British Jews, racism; holds Israel to a standard applied to no other country; uses tropes such as Zionist control in the context of Israel; cites the few Jews who agree as if that settled it, when a minority saying something is fine does not make it fine. Right circle, antisemitism, not about Zionism: prejudice, hatred or discrimination against Jews as Jews; harmful stereotypes about Jewish power, money or control; hostility to Jewish people, communities or religious practice; exists whatever a person's views on Israel. Below the circles, a band: the Green Party's motion falls in the overlap. Zionism is Racism, E02, passed 4 October 2026. It declares Zionism racism, saying the belief of most British Jews will be treated as any other form of racism, and commits the party to oppose and campaign against it, a campaign against Jewish identity, not criticism of a government. It sets one rule for Jews: the French, the Irish and the Palestinians claim the same right to a homeland and nobody calls them racist for it. It takes away the words Jews use to name antisemitism, rejecting the IHRA definition and the Jerusalem Declaration as weaponised. It revives a line the world abandoned: the UN called Zionism racism in 1975 and revoked that in 1991, and four of the party's five MPs and Green councillors across the country have rejected the motion. Key takeaways: criticism of Israel is not antisemitic; anti-Zionism is not the same thing, it denies the Jewish people alone the right to self-determination, which the IHRA definition names as antisemitism; nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the Jewish people's ancestral homeland, and calling that belief racism says it of them.
Criticism of Israel, anti-Zionism and antisemitism, drawn apart, and where the Green Party's motion falls. Zionism here means what it means to most British Jews: the belief that the Jewish people, like every other people, have the right to a homeland of their own. Download the graphic to share it.

You can't be anti-racist and antisemitic.

Zionism is anti-racism.

The Board of Deputies of British Jews and the Jewish Leadership Council

What Zionism is

Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like every other people, have the right to a homeland of their own, in the land where Jews have lived for some 3,000 years. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find. Most Jewish patients, and Israeli patients, are Zionists in exactly the sense the motion condemns.

What racism is

Racism is treating people worse because of their race, ethnicity or national origin, or holding one group to a standard applied to no one else. A motion that treats the belief of most British Jews "as any other form of racism" does exactly that.

Why calling Zionism racism is antisemitism

Good Medical Practice, the GMC's standard for every doctor, requires doctors to treat patients fairly and with respect whatever their beliefs, and not to let their personal views affect the care they give. It also says that what doctors say in public, including online, can affect the trust patients place in the profession. In our view the threat to Jewish and Israeli patients is clear, and it is present now. A doctor who has called for what most of them believe to be burned to the ground, who says she has yet to see a Zionist act with kindness, who wrote that "pro-genociders" should not feel safe anywhere, who used a slur for them, and who put her name to a policy that treats their belief as racism cannot expect them to trust her with their care. She sees patients every working day while the GMC's investigation runs, and she has not said they will be treated like any other. The case in full is set out in the next section. Nobody alleges that Dr Jones has mistreated a patient, and no finding has been made against her: the GMC decides, not this campaign. The concern is that her Jewish and Israeli patients can no longer be confident she will not, and that confidence is what the standards exist to protect.

What the law says

The GMC decides whether a doctor is fit to practise, and NHS England keeps the Medical Performers List of GPs allowed to work in the NHS. As a councillor she is also bound by Lewisham's Member Code of Conduct, which requires members to "promote equality and not discriminate unlawfully against any person, and treat all people with respect", and to "ensure that their comments and behaviour do not overstep the line of acceptability". Complaints under it go to the Council's Monitoring Officer, to whom the letter is addressed as well.

The terms defined

Zionism
Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like every other people, have the right to a homeland of their own, in the land where Jews have lived for some 3,000 years.
Anti-Zionism
Opposition to the existence of a Jewish state. It differs from criticism of an Israeli government, which Zionists make too; anti-Zionism denies to Jews the national self-determination every other people is allowed.
Antisemitism
Hostility to, prejudice against or discrimination against Jews as Jews. The IHRA working definition, adopted by the UK Government, gives as one example "denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g. by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor".
Racism
Racism is treating people worse because of their race, ethnicity or national origin, or holding one group to a standard applied to no one else.
The "Zionism is Racism" motion
A policy motion of the Green Party of England and Wales conference, numbered E02 on the final agenda. It declares the party anti-Zionist and orders that Zionism be treated as any other form of racism.

Sources

What you can do

Type your name, tick a box if you are her patient or live in Lewisham, and the letter opens in your own email app, ready to send. You can change any of it first. It goes to the GMC and to Lewisham's Monitoring Officer, copied to NHS England. Nothing is sent to us except a copy for the count. Send it once, in your own name, and only if you share the concern: it is your letter.

Open the letter in my email app