"Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026
Their press conference, line by line
Twelve days after the motion passed, its authors held a press conference, streamed live by The Crispin Flintoff Show. Five speakers, nine questions, 48 minutes. We listened to every one. Here is what was said, quoted exactly with the time in the stream, and why it is wrong.
48
minutes, every one listened to
5
speakers, and nine questions
11
quotations, each with its time
47 minutes, minute by minute
Every quotation at the moment it was said. Press one to read it, and its time to watch it.
Criticising Israeli governments, the occupation of the West Bank or the conduct of the war in Gaza is not antisemitism, and nothing on this page says it is. What follows is about what the motion's authors say about Zionism, about Jews and about violence.
Zionists "persecute the messenger" and make their critics lose "their reputation, and in some cases their lives". No case was named.
2
Jews in Israel are "usurpers" who might as well be "people from Chad"; "if you're not a Jew, you have no rights" there.
3
"Israelis don't hide that they're racist", and British nationals who served in Israel's army are a "threat ... to our collective safety".
4
Zionism "means only one thing ... genocide and death", and is "sociopathic".
5
The Irgun did not exist in 1924; the Jabotinsky they quoted swore to "equal rights" and "never to eject anyone".
6
A "Zionist lobby" is "the main beast in the British political scene": said from the floor, and the chair closed with thanks.
7
No tribunal has ruled that Zionism is racist, whatever the chair agreed to; the MPs are "one amongst 220,000"; and in 48 minutes about the war, Hamas, 7 October and the hostages were never mentioned.
01
What they said about Jews
5 quotations
What they say
GKDr Ghada Karmiwriter and academic05:33
If there is anything that is archetypally typical of Zionism, it's the way that Zionists persecute the messenger. They're not interested in the message. They never answer the message, only the messenger. They have to lose their reputation, and in some cases their lives.
Antisemitic
Dr Ghada Karmi at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 05:33 to 06:36)
What is wrong with it
Antisemitic. It says Zionists, as a group, destroy the reputations of their critics and, "in some cases", their lives, with no case named: a hidden hand that punishes anyone who speaks.
Why is this antisemitic?
Jews secretly controlling governments, police, banks or the press is the oldest antisemitic conspiracy theory there is. Putting "Zionists" or "the lobby" where the older word was does not change what it is.
The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective, such as, especially but not exclusively, "the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions"."
No name, no case, no evidence: Zionists, as a group, are said to destroy the reputations of their critics and, "in some cases", to have them killed. A hidden hand that punishes anyone who speaks against it is the shape of every conspiracy theory about Jews there has been, with "Zionists" in the place of the older word.
It was offered as the reason the motion has been criticised at all: by four of the party's five MPs, by the Prime Minister, by the Chief Rabbi, by the Board of Deputies and by the Equality and Human Rights Commission. None of them, on this account, has an argument to answer. They are "persecuting the messenger".
It could be, I don't know, people from Chad who decided that they need an extra territory, and then they set themselves up, and they expelled the native population. So you're not talking about Jews. You'll be talking about usurpers and people who ethnic cleansers.
AntisemiticFactually wrong
Dr Ghada Karmi at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 07:45 to 08:48)
What is wrong with it
Antisemitic. It calls the Jews of Israel "usurpers" who might as well be "people from Chad": Jews as strangers with no tie to the land, who took what was not theirs.
Why is this antisemitic?
The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."
Jews are named for Judea, Hebrew is the language of the land, and a Jewish community has lived in Jerusalem, Hebron, Safed and Tiberias without a break for two thousand years.
Factually wrong. Jews have lived in the land continuously, and more than half of Israel's Jews descend from the Jews of Arab countries and Iran, not Europe.
Jews are not strangers to the land who might as well have come from Chad. They are named for Judea. Hebrew is its language. Jerusalem has had a Jewish community without a break for two thousand years, as have Hebron, Safed and Tiberias. And more than half of Israel's Jews descend not from Europe but from the 850,000 Jews driven out of Arab countries and Iran after 1948.
"Usurpers" and "ethnic cleansers" is the name given here to the seven million Jews of the one Jewish state. The working definition of antisemitism adopted by the UK Government gives as an example "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."
If you're not a Jew, you have no rights to the homeland that is now called Israel because you're not a Jew.
Factually wrong
Dr Ghada Karmi at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 10:00)
What is wrong with it
Factually wrong. One in five of Israel's citizens is an Arab. They vote, sit in the Knesset and on the Supreme Court, and an Arab party was in the governing coalition of 2021 to 2022.
Around two million of Israel's citizens, one in five, are Arabs. They vote, sit in the Knesset and on the Supreme Court, run hospitals and lead political parties; an Arab party sat in the governing coalition of 2021 to 2022. Arabic is an official language of the state.
There is much to criticise in how Israel treats its Arab citizens, and the occupation of the West Bank is a separate matter. But "no rights ... because you're not a Jew" is false, and it is said in order to make Israel's existence, not any policy of its governments, the crime.
What they say
YEYara El-Issa, Palestinian Youth Movement13:45
Israelis don't hide that they're racist. … The UK government continues to welcome back British nationals that openly served in the Israeli military and killed Palestinians, dismissing the threat that they posed to our collective safety.
AntisemiticAntisemitic
Yara El-Issa, Palestinian Youth Movement at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 13:45 to 14:51)
What is wrong with it
Antisemitic. It says British nationals who served in Israel's army are a "threat ... to our collective safety": British Jews made dangerous because of a war abroad.
Why is this antisemitic?
The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the state of Israel."
Almost every British citizen who serves in Israel's armed forces is a British Jew. To mark them out as a danger to the public, as a class, is to hold British Jews responsible for Israel.
Antisemitic. It says "Israelis don't hide that they're racist": a whole nation of ten million people, Jews and Arabs, branded with one word.
Why is this antisemitic?
The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective, such as, especially but not exclusively, "the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions"."
A whole nation of ten million people, Jews and Arabs, is branded racist in one sentence. That is what the word racism describes.
British citizens who serve in Israel's armed forces are, almost without exception, British Jews. To call them, as a class, a "threat ... to our collective safety" is to mark out Jewish neighbours in Britain as dangerous because of a war abroad: the logic by which British Jews are made to answer for Israel, and by which synagogues need guards. The same speaker called Israel "the Zionist entity", the phrase of those who will not say its name.
What they say
AAAhmed AlNaouq, journalist20:20
Because a group of people in Central Europe decided that my country, they decided that my country is theirs … Zionism is genocidal. Zionism is sociopathic. … Zionism means only one thing. And it means one thing to the people that it was manifested at. Zionism means genocide and death.
Factually wrong
Ahmed AlNaouq, journalist at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 20:20 to 22:20)
What is wrong with it
Factually wrong. Israel's Jews are not "a group of people in Central Europe": about half descend from the Jews of the Middle East and North Africa. And to most British Jews, Zionism means that the Jewish people have a home, not "genocide and death".
Ahmed AlNaouq told the room that 21 members of his family were killed in Gaza in October 2023, 14 of them children. Nothing on this page makes light of that.
But "a group of people in Central Europe" is not who Israel's Jews are: half of them descend from the Jews of Iraq, Yemen, Morocco, Iran, Egypt and the rest of the Middle East and North Africa. And to say Zionism "means only one thing ... genocide and death" is to tell most British Jews, for whom it means that the Jewish people have a home, that what they believe is a programme of death. "Sociopathic" is a word for a person. Applied to a people's national movement it is dehumanising.
02
The history they told
2 quotations
What they say
LSLubna Speitan, the motion's proposer02:21
weaponizing Jewish historical trauma made in Europe against us. We Palestinians were not the persecutors of Jews, yet we have been forced to pay a price for crimes we did not commit.
Factually wrong
Lubna Speitan, the motion's proposer at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 02:21)
What is wrong with it
Factually wrong. "We Palestinians were not the persecutors of Jews" is not history: Jews were murdered in Hebron in 1929, the Mufti of Jerusalem met Hitler in 1941, and the Farhud, Aden and the expulsions followed.
Jewish "trauma" was not "made in Europe" alone. In Hebron in August 1929, 67 Jews were murdered by their Arab neighbours and the rest of the oldest Jewish community in the land was driven out. In Baghdad in June 1941, the Farhud killed around 180 Jews. In Aden in December 1947, 82. The Palestinian national leader of the 1930s and 1940s, Haj Amin al-Husseini, the Mufti of Jerusalem, spent the war in Berlin, met Hitler in November 1941 and recruited for the SS.
Nobody holds today's Palestinians responsible for any of that, and the motion's authors should not want to be judged by it. But "we were not the persecutors of Jews" is not history. And the murder of six million, called a weapon "against us", is Jewish history treated as a trick rather than a reason.
What they say
AAAdnan Al-Sabah, One Democratic State Campaign25:41
"I am prepared to take an oath binding ourselves and our descendants … That we shall never do anything contrary to the principle of equal rights, and that we shall never try to eject anyone." … 1924, the Zionist leaders, the Irgun terrorist organization, assassinated one of the prominent Zionist leaders … His name was Jacob D. Hahn.
Factually wrong
Adnan Al-Sabah, One Democratic State Campaign at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 25:41 to 27:42)
What is wrong with it
Factually wrong. Jacob Israël de Haan was shot in 1924 by members of the Haganah, not the Irgun, which did not exist until 1931, and he was then the spokesman of Jerusalem's anti-Zionist ultra-Orthodox community. The Jabotinsky passage he read swears to "equal rights" and never to "eject anyone".
The words he reads from Jabotinsky's "The Iron Wall" of 1923 are an oath never to act against equal rights and never to expel anyone: the opposite of the "exclusion and/or domination" that the motion says is what Zionism is for. He read out the refutation of his own motion and did not notice.
The history is wrong too. Jacob Israël de Haan was shot in Jerusalem in June 1924 by members of the Haganah. The Irgun did not exist until 1931. Nor was de Haan "one of the prominent Zionist leaders" of the day: by then he was the spokesman of Jerusalem's anti-Zionist ultra-Orthodox community.
03
From the floor, and let stand
1 quotation
What they say
APA panellist answering the first question31:18
They cannot accept anything that appears very critical of the state of Israel. … Why is Israel so special that it must be protected at every level, including at government level … the main beast in the British political scene, which is the Zionist movement and the Zionist lobby.
Antisemitic
a panellist answering the first question at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 31:18), and an audience member who was given the floor at 44:50, after which the chair closed the conference with thanks
What is wrong with it
Antisemitic. It calls "the Zionist lobby" the "main beast in the British political scene" and says the "ruling elite" protects Israel "at every level": Jews controlling government.
Why is this antisemitic?
Jews secretly controlling governments, police, banks or the press is the oldest antisemitic conspiracy theory there is. Putting "Zionists" or "the lobby" where the older word was does not change what it is.
The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective, such as, especially but not exclusively, "the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions"."
Nobody on the panel objected, and the chair closed the conference with thanks.
Britain's "ruling elite" does Israel's bidding "at every level"; a "Zionist lobby" is "the main beast in the British political scene". This is the myth of hidden Jewish power over governments in its modern dress, with "Zionist" where "Jewish" used to be. The working definition names it: "the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions."
The government said to protect Israel "at every level" suspended arms export licences to it in September 2024 and recognised the State of Palestine in September 2025. The "lobby" remark came from the floor, from a man who said he was not a Green Party member; nobody on the panel demurred, and the chair thanked everyone and closed the conference.
LSThe chair, asked whether the David Miller ruling established "that Zionism is a racist and supremacist ideology"36:30
Well, yes. I mean, that sets a huge and fundamental precedent for us across the movement. It has called it what it is … definitions like the IHRA, which again is arguably racist against Palestinians.
Factually wrong
the chair, asked whether the David Miller ruling established "that Zionism is a racist and supremacist ideology" at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 36:30)
What is wrong with it
Factually wrong. No tribunal has ruled that Zionism is racist. The Bristol tribunal found that David Miller's belief was protected under the Equality Act and that he had been dismissed unfairly; it made no finding on whether the belief is true.
The facts
The test the tribunal applied asks whether a belief is genuinely held and worthy of respect in a democratic society, not whether it is true. A belief can be protected by the Equality Act and still be wrong, and the tribunal did not say this one was right.
No tribunal has ruled that Zionism is racist. In February 2024 an employment tribunal in Bristol found that David Miller's anti-Zionist beliefs were a protected philosophical belief under the Equality Act 2010 and that his university had dismissed him unfairly for holding them. The test it applied asks whether a belief is genuinely held and worthy of respect in a democratic society, not whether it is true. A belief can be protected and wrong.
The IHRA working definition, "arguably racist against Palestinians" here, has been adopted by the UK Government, the Labour, Conservative and Liberal Democrat parties, the Welsh and Scottish governments and hundreds of councils. It says in terms that "criticism of Israel similar to that leveled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic."
LSThe chair, asked whether they would stay in the party if the motion were amended34:34
This won with the largest mandate in Green Party history. … We are a member-led party. We have about 220,000 members, 230,000. The MPs have an opinion, and that's one amongst 220,000. … If there's any kind of amendments that are introduced, that couldn't constitutionally be introduced until 2028.
Misleading
the chair, asked whether they would stay in the party if the motion were amended at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 34:34 to 35:39)
What is wrong with it
Misleading. "The largest mandate in Green Party history" was 1,022 votes to 813, under half of one per cent of the membership.
The "largest mandate in Green Party history" was 1,022 votes to 813 at a conference, under half of one per cent of the membership they cite. Four of the party's five MPs, its only voice in Parliament, are "one amongst 220,000". And by their own account the party cannot change its mind until 2028: every Green councillor is to carry this for two years.
the struggle to achieve that liberation by all available means under international law is legitimate
Misleading
Lubna Speitan, the motion's proposer at their press conference, "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke", 16 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 01:17)
What is wrong with it
Misleading. A press conference about the causes of a war that never names the day it began, 7 October 2023, or the hostages, tells only part of the story.
Forty-eight minutes, five speakers and nine questions. The words Hamas, hostage and 7 October were not spoken once. The war the speakers described began on 7 October 2023 with the murder of around 1,200 people in Israel and the taking of 251 hostages; that day is absent, as it is from all 48 pages of their booklet. "All available means" is the phrase used in its place.
The losses the speakers described are real, and nothing here minimises them. A press conference about the causes of a war that cannot name the day it began is not telling the whole story.
Taken together
What it adds up to
The Green Party told its members that the motion is about an ideology, not Jews. At the press conference held to defend it, Jews in Israel were called usurpers, British Jews who served in Israel's army a threat to public safety, and the "Zionist lobby" the main beast of British politics, with nobody on the panel demurring. That is what the motion sounds like when its authors speak for 48 minutes.
Zionism is not racism. Green councillors can say so by signing the pledge; councillors and MPs of every other party, by adding their name.
Quotations are from an automated transcript of the livestream of the press conference "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke" (The Crispin Flintoff Show, 16 October 2026), with the time in the stream. They are quoted for criticism and review.