Zionism Is Not Racism
Act now

Greens for Palestine, event by event

Everything they have done, in order

From their first statement for the motion in February to their second press conference in October: every webinar, stream, statement and publication of the group that wrote the Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion, dated, with its sharpest lines, and each one a click from the page where every claim in it is quoted exactly and answered. The two press conferences were streamed live by The Crispin Flintoff Show.

24
events, statements and publications
20
of them answered on this site, line by line
171
quotations, every one sourced

Greens for Palestine, line by line Everything wrong with them, in one list The people behind the motion

13 February 2026: "In Support of Motion A105: Zionism Is Racism"19 February 2026: "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105"9 March 2026: "Greens for Palestine Statement on Al-Aqsa and Why Anti-Zionist Motions Matter"22 March 2026: "All Zionism is Racism: 'Cultural', 'non-Statist', 'Sense of Homeland', or Otherwise"30 April 2026: "Rebuttal: Zionism is and has always been Racism"1 July 2026: "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism"4 August 2026: "When We Say Occupation, We Mean the Whole Thing"4 August 2026: Their stream for the motion22 September 2026: The Green Party's own pre-conference workshop on the motion4 October 2026: "Zionism is Racism Motion: Why it Matters", 48 pages4 October 2026: The Green Party conference passes the motionOctober 2026: "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser"12 October 2026: Members plot to have Caroline Lucas thrown out of the party13 October 2026: The motion's co-proposer on Dr Shola Mos-Shogbamimu's livestream16 October 2026: Their press conference: "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke"17 October 2026: The Mail on Sunday names who is behind the motion19 October 2026: 60 Green councillors sign an open letter supporting the motion22 October 2026: The party's deputy leader filmed joining the chant "From the river to the sea" at a Greens for Palestine rally24 October 2026: Their open letter reaches 100 Green councillors26 October 2026: Their second press conference: "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'"30 October 2026: Greens for Palestine: "We won't compromise on our Member-Led Democracy"2 November 2026: Greens for Palestine on Sheffield: Labour's "allegiance to “Israel” matters more to them than running Sheffield Council". "Zionism is Racism. Hold the line."October 2026: The motion's author and its principal backer, interviewed by The New Arab: Zionism is to be made "illegal", Israel "has no legal, moral, or ethical right to exist", and "the end of Zionism" is "to cleanse the land"3 November 2026: Greens for Palestine, with Cllr Mark Adderley: the Green Party "doesn't have a 'Friends of Israel' group", so "perhaps that's why we're the only party willing to oppose genocide"
  1. Webinar A webinar hosted by Tony Greenstein, sponsored by Greens for Palestine

    "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism"

    Seven weeks after the party expelled its host for antisemitism, Greens for Palestine put their name to his webinar and kept it there.

    • "There is no criticism you can make of Israel that is anti-Semitic"
    • Israel "bears a very great similarity to Nazi Germany"
    • Antisemitism is "so much glitter ... not real"

    The full analysis, line by line

  2. Streamed live Streamed live by Greens for Palestine, with Lubna Speitan, Dr Ghada Karmi and Dr Ramzy Baroud

    Their stream for the motion

    Its proposer says what the motion means: "all available means", and both definitions of antisemitism rejected.

    • The IHRA and JDA definitions exist "to protect a racist state"
    • Israel's founders "should never have defined themselves as Jews"
    • "We will use arms"

    The full analysis, line by line

  3. Green Party event Microsoft Teams, run by the party's Standing Orders Committee; the proposer did not attend

    The Green Party's own pre-conference workshop on the motion

    A member introduced the motion in the proposer's place; a sitting Green councillor chaired; a Jewish member proposed a safeguard for Jewish members, and the room voted it down.

    • Two-state supporters and members of Zionist synagogue bodies: "perhaps you are" racists
    • A safeguard for Jewish members' synagogue membership voted down, 24 to 67
    • 13 quotations from the recording, answered

    The full analysis, line by line

  4. Publication Handed to delegates at the Green Party conference

    "Zionism is Racism Motion: Why it Matters", 48 pages

    The booklet written to win the vote. Every claim in it is quoted with its page number and answered, and the booklet itself is here to download.

    • Zionism "will be treated as any other form of racism" inside the party
    • Liberation "by all available means, including armed struggle"
    • The word "antisemitism" is a "misnomer"

    The full analysis, line by line

  5. Streamed live "Zionist Outrage at Green Party Vote", Dr Shola Speaks, YouTube

    The motion's co-proposer on Dr Shola Mos-Shogbamimu's livestream

    Lubna Speitan, the motion's co-proposer, was the guest. "The greatest threat to Jewish people is Zionism. That is the biggest threat to Jews." The quotations are from a transcript of the stream that has not been checked against the video.

    Watch it for yourself

  6. Streamed live The Crispin Flintoff Show, streamed live, 48 minutes

    Their press conference: "Palestinians ignored on Zionism. It's time they spoke"

    Twelve days after the vote, the motion's authors held a press conference. Five speakers, nine questions. Every claim, quoted with the time in the stream, is answered.

    • Zionists "persecute the messenger" and critics lose "their lives"
    • Jews in Israel are "usurpers" who might as well be "people from Chad"
    • British Jews who served in Israel's army are a "threat ... to our collective safety"
    • "The Zionist lobby" is "the main beast in the British political scene"

    The full analysis, line by line Watch it for yourself

  7. Open letter Posted by Greens for Palestine on Instagram, as ten slides

    Their open letter reaches 100 Green councillors

    Greens for Palestine posted the open letter headed "100 Green councillors have signed this open letter in support of an anti-Zionist Green Party". The 100th name on the form's list of signatories is Cllr Ifhat Shaheen (Stoke Newington, Hackney). Five days after it was first shared with 60 names, it had 100; by 29 October it had 110. Every signatory is on the register on this site.

    The full analysis, line by line

  8. Streamed live The Crispin Flintoff Show, streamed live, 65 minutes, the day after the Board of Deputies declared the party racist

    Their second press conference: "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'"

    Five speakers, six questions. A Jewish speaker said the Talmud instructs Jews to kill non-Jews; the motion's lead sponsor told Israel's Jews to go back to Europe; Hamas, 7 October and the hostages were not mentioned once.

    • The Jewish religion has "racist tenets" and the Talmud has "instructions on killing goys"
    • Israel's Jews should "come back home" to Europe, "where you are safe"
    • The Holocaust is "wrongly called the Holocaust" and was "not the largest" genocide
    • The Prime Minister is "a liar" for backing two states

    The full analysis, line by line Watch it for yourself

  9. Statement on their website Posted by Greens for Palestine as three images

    Greens for Palestine: "We won't compromise on our Member-Led Democracy"

    Greens for Palestine said the motion has a "definitive democratic mandate", called it the motion "that a clear majority of this party are in support of", and said its opponents "in their desperation are seeking to subvert the Green Party's member-led democracy because they fear a loss of control". The conference vote was 1,022 to 813, in a party of about 220,000 members. The statement says the motion was "endorsed by 40+ organisations", among them Friends of Al Aqsa and Neturei Karta (spelled in it "Neuturei Karta").

    • People "are no longer afraid to advocate for a completely free Palestine, from the river to the sea"
    • "Unlike other parties with their prohibitive delegate systems and their powerful Friends of Israel groups, members decide policy in the Green Party"
    • A "media establishment that has spent the last three years covering for genocide"

    The source

  10. Statement on their website Posted by Greens for Palestine as an image

    Greens for Palestine on Sheffield: Labour's "allegiance to “Israel” matters more to them than running Sheffield Council". "Zionism is Racism. Hold the line."

    On the day Sheffield Labour published its account of why it ended the joint administration with the Greens, Greens for Palestine posted a graphic in answer. It says Sheffield Labour "have made clear that allegiance to “Israel” matters more to them than running Sheffield Council or honouring the votes of their constituents", that "rather than work with the Greens and their principled stance on Palestinian liberation, Sheffield Labour have thrown a tantrum and sacrificed the council coalition to cover for genocide, ethnic cleansing and apartheid", and names Cllr Mark Rusling, "a local councillor who saw fit to take a friendly trip to “Israel” to speak on a panel, sharing said panel with individuals and organisations who have spent the last three years denying the ongoing genocide in Gaza". It stands "in solidarity with all Sheffield Green councillors and members as they are subjected to the selfish hysterics of the genocide-assisting Labour Party", and ends: "Make no mistake Labour are sacrificing your services for Zionism. Zionism is Racism. Hold the line." Israel is set in quotation marks each time it is named. The statement does not mention Sheffield's Jewish residents, whose fears Cllr Belbin's account describes, nor Labour's two points: that not all Zionists are racists, and that self-determination is the right of the peoples of Palestine and Israel.

    • Labour's "allegiance to “Israel” matters more to them than running Sheffield Council"
    • Labour "sacrificed the council coalition to cover for genocide, ethnic cleansing and apartheid"
    • Cllr Mark Rusling "saw fit to take a friendly trip to “Israel” to speak on a panel"
    • "The selfish hysterics of the genocide-assisting Labour Party"
    • "Zionism is Racism. Hold the line."

    The source

  11. Streamed live The New Arab, on YouTube, 74 minutes, recorded the day after their second press conference

    The motion's author and its principal backer, interviewed by The New Arab: Zionism is to be made "illegal", Israel "has no legal, moral, or ethical right to exist", and "the end of Zionism" is "to cleanse the land"

    Lubna Speitan and Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner, for 74 minutes. Zionism is to be made "illegal and impossible for groups of people to act as Zionists"; Israel "has no legal, moral, or ethical right to exist"; "the end of Zionism" is "to cleanse the land"; the motion's demands are "based on the demands of the thawabit", the programme Fatah, Hamas and Islamic Jihad affirm in common; next come "the union movement, ... the students, ... local authorities". Hamas, 7 October and the hostages are not named once.

    • Zionism is to be made "illegal and impossible for groups of people to act as Zionists"
    • Israel "has no legal, moral, or ethical right to exist"
    • "The end of Zionism" is "to cleanse the land"
    • Israel's conduct is "even more terrifying" than the Holocaust, and "this we are told is Jewish"
    • MPs who oppose the motion are "bought" by "the Zionist lobby"

    The full analysis, line by line Watch it for yourself

  12. Statement on their website Posted by Greens for Palestine and Cllr Mark Adderley on Instagram, as an image of their post on X

    Greens for Palestine, with Cllr Mark Adderley: the Green Party "doesn't have a 'Friends of Israel' group", so "perhaps that's why we're the only party willing to oppose genocide"

    The morning after Labour confirmed it had left power-sharing with the Greens on eleven councils, Greens for Palestine posted on Instagram, jointly with Cllr Mark Adderley, the Green councillor for Crystal Palace and Upper Norwood on Croydon Council who backs the motion, an image of their post on X: "The Green Party doesn't have a 'Friends of Israel' group. We're the only major party that doesn't. Perhaps that's why we're the only party that willing to oppose settler colonialism. Perhaps that's why we're the only party willing to oppose genocide." It ends with the link to join the Green Party. The post quotes Labour Friends of Israel marking the Balfour Declaration of 2 November 1917, "the British government's support for the establishment of a Jewish national homeland". Labour, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats each have a Friends of Israel group; Labour and the Liberal Democrats each have a Friends of Palestine group too. The Green Party has Jewish Greens, whose chair called on Zack Polanski to resign over the motion. Having no group of friends of the Jewish state is offered, in a party's name, as the reason it alone opposes genocide, and as a reason to join.

    • "The Green Party doesn't have a 'Friends of Israel' group. We're the only major party that doesn't."
    • "Perhaps that's why we're the only party willing to oppose genocide."
    • Posted with the link to join the Green Party, the morning after Labour left eleven councils

    The source

Taken together

Nine months, one message

From February to October the group that wrote the motion said the same things in every room it was given: that the basic idea of a Jewish home is racism, that Jews in Israel are usurpers who can go back to Europe, that armed struggle is lawful, and, at the end, that the Talmud instructs Jews to kill non-Jews. In all of it, Hamas, 7 October and the hostages were not mentioned once. Every claim is answered, in their own words, on the pages above.