Zionism Is Not Racism
Act now

"Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", October 2026

Their interview with The New Arab, line by line

The day after their second press conference, the motion's author and its principal backer sat down with The New Arab for an interview posted on YouTube under the title "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion". Two guests, one interviewer, 74 minutes. We listened to every one. Here is what was said, quoted exactly with the time in the video, and what is wrong with it.

74
minutes, every one listened to
2
guests: the motion's author and its principal backer
20
quotations, each with its time

Criticising Israeli governments, the occupation of the West Bank or the conduct of the war in Gaza is not antisemitism, and nothing on this page says it is. What follows is about what the motion's authors say about Zionism, about Jews and about violence.

  1. Zionism is to be made "illegal and impossible for groups of people to act as Zionists": a belief held by nine in ten British Jews, to be a crime.

  2. Israel "has no legal, moral, or ethical right to exist", from the motion's author; "the end of Zionism" is "to cleanse the land", from its principal backer.

  3. Israel's conduct is "even more terrifying" than the Holocaust, and "this we are told is Jewish"; Israel is "not human anymore" and its politicians "none of them are people".

  4. The motion's demands are "based on the demands of the thawabit", the programme Fatah, Hamas and Islamic Jihad affirm in common; one state is "the heart of it"; the Green Party is now "the first anti-Zionist mainstream political party".

  5. MPs who oppose the motion are "bought" by "the Zionist lobby"; the press will face "accountability for their crimes"; four of the party's five MPs "are in need of education on Zionism".

  6. Next: "the union movement, ... the students, ... local authorities". In 74 minutes, Hamas, 7 October and the hostages are not named once.

What they said about Jews, Israel and Zionism

7 quotations

What they say

The problem is not Netanyahu. The problem is not even Israel. The problem is Zionism, the apartheid, genocidal belief that Jews must live on their own. Now, actually, Jews lived for two millennia in the Arab world and in Europe, not on their own, but surrounded by non-Jews. And indeed, in Europe, the racism of the society in the 20th century has led to a genocide. In the Arab world, it was the opposite. ... So what we want is to end the colonial project because that is the nub of the question, to end Zionism, not just to end Israel, to end Zionism, to make it illegal and impossible for groups of people to act as Zionists.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 14:06 to 16:31)

What is wrong with it

Zionism is to be made "illegal", and "groups of people" who act on it are to be stopped. Nine in ten British Jews hold it, by the surveys. A belief held by most of one people in this country is to be a crime: a synagogue that prays for Israel, a youth movement that sends teenagers there, a community centre that raises money for it.

Jews in the Arab world: about 850,000 left or were driven from Arab countries after 1948, their property taken, and almost none remain. In Baghdad in June 1941, seven years before Israel existed, the Farhud killed about 180 Jews in two days. "It was the opposite" is not what happened to them.

What they say

This is not about the 50 fluffy shades of Zionism that they portray. This is about the reality of what Zionism is and what it does. ... And no one can claim self-determination as an occupying force or an oppressor on another man's land. This is not a right. Israel, let's be clear, has no legal, moral, or ethical right to exist. People do.

Lubna Speitan interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 25:36 to 26:38)

What is wrong with it

Israel was admitted to the United Nations on 11 May 1949 and is recognised by 165 of its other 192 members, the United Kingdom among them since 1950. "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor" is one of the examples in the working definition of antisemitism the UK Government uses.

The Green Party told the BBC on 25 October that its motion is not antisemitic. The motion's author says the country has no right to exist. The 114 Green councillors who signed the open letter in support of the motion signed under the name of a proposer who says this.

What they say

It's called Israel. It is Palestine. The country is Palestine. Israel is the racist state. We are living on Palestinian land. We have taken it. We have stolen it. We have conquered it unjustly, illegally, immorally. And we have to face this. And the only way to face it is to allow the end of Zionism to cleanse the land, to allow the Palestinians to return, to live like Jews, Christians, and Muslims lived for thousands of years. ... Most Zionists are Christians. We have to defeat the idea of Zionism within the West, not just in Israel.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 55:06 to 56:10)

What is wrong with it

"The end of Zionism" is "to cleanse the land". Of what is not said. Seven million Jews live in Israel; the motion's programme gives them no state, and at the second press conference the day before, the motion's lead sponsor told them to "come back home" to Europe.

The speaker was born stateless in a refugee camp in Italy to two survivors of Auschwitz, as the speaker says in this interview. The people the land is to be "cleansed" of are, for the most part, the children and grandchildren of people like the speaker's parents, and of the 850,000 Jews of the Arab world.

What they say

When they killed all those millions ... they knew that this is a crime. They knew that it is illegal. They knew that it is immoral. So they hid it ... Now look at what is happening now. The IDF is doing it in the day of light. ... The Nazis did terrible things. Sure, they didn't do this. ... So I think some of those characteristics of this genocide are even more terrifying than what happened in the Second World War. The numbers are different, but the characteristics, the open sadism, the brutality, the inventive murderousness, they are really terrifying. And this we are told is Jewish. This is done by Jews as part of their belief system.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 18:27 to 20:40)

What is wrong with it

"Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis" is an example of antisemitism in the working definition the UK Government uses. Here the comparison runs further: Israel's conduct is "even more terrifying" than the murder of six million Jews, among them, as the speaker says later, 105 members of the speaker's own family.

Who "we are told" this by is not said. The last sentence is the motion's own move, made aloud: what Israel does is made the "belief system" of Jews, and the belief is then declared racism.

What they say

Zionism is a settler colonial movement in Palestine, which is actually genocidal against the Palestinians. That's all it is. You don't need to be a university researcher to find out what Zionism is. It doesn't actually liberate Jews because it makes them into genociders and murderers. It doesn't give them safety. Look at where are Jews killed in terrifying numbers. They are killed by people who resist their oppression, who resist the genocide.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 21:17 to 22:18)

What is wrong with it

The place where Jews were last "killed in terrifying numbers" is southern Israel on 7 October 2023: around 1,200 people murdered in their homes, at a music festival and on the roads, and 251 taken hostage. Here they were killed by "people who resist their oppression". In 74 minutes, Hamas, 7 October and the hostages are not named once.

The interviewer had just put it to the speaker that there is "no one solid definition" of Zionism. Here is the speaker's: a movement "which is actually genocidal". "That's all it is." Zionism, in the words of this campaign, is the belief that the Jewish people have the right to live as a nation in the Jewish homeland. Nine in ten British Jews hold it.

What they say

And I know that most human beings think that Israel is not human anymore. It doesn't belong to the club of humanity. ... So for those Israelis that are going to election now to vote between murderers, to select which murderer is going to run the country, I think we can say none of them are people.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 64:11 to 65:12, and 72:29 to 73:33)

What is wrong with it

A country that is "not human", outside "the club of humanity", whose candidates are "none of them ... people". No survey of "most human beings" exists. Putting a people outside humanity is the language that precedes every crime the speaker invokes elsewhere in the interview.

Israel's Arab citizens, one in five of the population, vote in the same elections and sit in the same parliament. They are "not human" on this account too.

What they say

And if there are Zionists watching this, we urge them to consider the guilt that they might well be feeling when they start to unravel the reality of what Zionism is and to listen to that voice and join the anti-Zionist movement.

Lubna Speitan interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 70:29 to 71:32)

What is wrong with it

Nine in ten British Jews, by the surveys, are the "Zionists" being addressed, and are invited to feel guilt. It is the motion's stance toward Jews in one sentence: not an argument about a state, but a demand that a people repent of what it believes.

What the "anti-Zionist movement" would have them join is set out in the same interview: one state in place of Israel, Zionism made illegal, the land "cleansed".

The motion: where it comes from, and what it means

5 quotations

What they say

When I read the policy, it actually stated that it was down to Israelis and Palestinians to decide, which I felt was quite an insult to the injury when you consider we are now expected to negotiate the terms of our oppression or liberation with our oppressors. So I reverted ultimately back to the thawabit, which is what all Palestinian factions had agreed again for a fully liberated Palestine. And the demands of the motion are based on the demands of the thawabit, the Palestinian constants.

Lubna Speitan interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 3:06 to 4:13)

What is wrong with it

The motion's author says where its demands come from: the "thawabit", the national constants that the Palestinian factions affirm in common. The National Conciliation Document of 2006, the fullest statement of them, was agreed by Fatah, Hamas, Islamic Jihad and the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. Hamas has been proscribed in full in the United Kingdom since 2021.

That Israelis and Palestinians should decide their future together was the Green Party's policy until 4 October, and, by this account, "an insult". The motion replaced it with one state "in all of historic Palestine", with no say for the seven million Jews who live there.

What they say

So when this started, I wanted to know that one state is in the heart of it. And Lubna has made sure that this is really the heart of the movement. And indeed, our leader, Zack Polanski, pointed out that that's a reason why he is not supporting the motion. Very mistakenly, of course, but people do believe that there is a two-state solution. I mean, after all those decades, how can you believe that? Israel has made it totally impossible.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 6:01 to 7:03)

What is wrong with it

One state in place of Israel is "the heart" of the motion, by its principal backer. Green groups that have told their councils the motion is about an ideology and not about Israel's existence are contradicted by the people who wrote it.

The party's leader is "mistaken" to support two states. So, by this account, are the UK Government, which recognised the State of Palestine on 21 September 2025 as one of two states, and the United Nations.

What they say

So again, the people understood that many of the amendments that were put were not well-intentioned. And democracy decided. People understood enough. And that's what mattered and that's what counted.

Lubna Speitan interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 34:30 to 35:12)

What is wrong with it

The amendments the party's leader asked for, in the interviewer's words a moment earlier, were "one to explicitly safeguard Jewish members" and one to keep the party's support for two states. At the party's own workshop on 22 September, a Jewish member asked that synagogue membership be protected; members voted it down, 24 to 67. The motion's author calls such amendments "not well-intentioned".

"Democracy decided" by 1,022 votes to 813, in a party that says it has about 220,000 members: under half of one per cent of them.

What they say

We've now become the first anti-Zionist mainstream political party who supports a single democratic Palestinian state and all the rest of the demands in the motion, which was brilliant. ... But I knew at that point, "Okay, now this is time to prepare for battle because this is when the attacks are going to come in and this is where the real work begins."

Lubna Speitan interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 35:26 to 36:19)

What is wrong with it

The Green Party is now "the first anti-Zionist mainstream political party", and anti-Zionist here means "a single democratic Palestinian state": one state, in place of Israel. The party's leader has twice declined on the BBC to say whether Zionism is racism, and the party's statement of 2 November in its deputy leader's name does not mention the motion. The motion's author is clearer about what the party now is than the party.

What they say

I actually initially signed up to Your Party. I think many did. ... And then when this was put forward, I thought, well, Your Party hasn't really come into any sort of fruition at the moment. Let me see at least what we can build in here. ... I'd bring it to any party. I mean, it needs to go global. This is for every party. It's not a Green Party motion. This is a motion to be brought and supported by every principled anti-racist organization, political party, trade union, and so on.

Lubna Speitan interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 2:51 to 3:06, and 33:26 to 34:20)

What is wrong with it

The motion's author first signed up to Your Party, joined the Greens when that party "hasn't really come into any sort of fruition", and says the motion "is not a Green Party motion": it is for "every party" and every trade union. The Green Party was the vehicle to hand.

Green councillors who have told their councils that the motion is the settled, member-led will of their party are told here by its author that the party was incidental to it.

Those who disagree

6 quotations

What they say

And let's remember that what those people who take umbrage from our motion are people who are supporting one state in Palestine. They support a Zionist, genocidal, racist, apartheid state in the whole of Palestine that is getting rid of the Palestinians, that it is killing the Palestinians in the worst genocide of living memory.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 13:00 to 14:06)

What is wrong with it

Those who have objected to the motion include the Prime Minister, who called it antisemitic; the Chief Rabbi; the Board of Deputies, by 118 votes to 1; four of the Green Party's five MPs; and more than a hundred Green councillors, on the record on this site. By this account every one of them supports "the worst genocide of living memory".

Living memory includes the Holocaust: its survivors are alive today, and the speaker's own parents, as the speaker says later, survived Auschwitz. Many of the motion's opponents support two states, the opposite of "one state in Palestine"; the speaker had said seven minutes earlier that two states are "totally impossible".

What they say

And when you have the Zionist lobby funding MPs who then, of course, have no right to take any moral high ground to speak on us when they're funded over 230, whatever it is, thousand, they're bought, they're compromised. And we need to understand, okay, and they need to understand that just as you came, you can go.

Lubna Speitan interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 32:29 to 33:22)

What is wrong with it

MPs who oppose the motion are "bought" and "compromised" by "the Zionist lobby". No MP is named and no donation is identified; "230, whatever it is, thousand" is the whole of the evidence. The working definition of antisemitism counts "the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions" among its examples.

MPs' donations are declared in the Register of Members' Financial Interests, which anyone can read. The MPs who have said Zionism is not racism are on this site by name, with what they said.

What they say

Accountability is a really major part of this. There is no peace without justice. And that includes holding to account the mainstream media, which they will face. Their time will come where they are facing accountability for their crimes and their participation in genocide.

Lubna Speitan interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 45:04 to 45:58)

What is wrong with it

Said to a journalist, of other journalists. The interviewer had just raised The Telegraph's report of 6 October on the motion's author; the answer is that the press will face "accountability for their crimes". The report, and what it said, is on this site.

Journalists join MPs, the Prime Minister, the party's own MPs and the Board of Deputies as, on this account, participants in genocide for disagreeing.

What they say

In our own party, we've seen four out of the five MPs are in need of education on Zionism. We will provide it willingly. And they will change. They will change because they're not stupid. They are just unprepared and not knowledgeable. Zack himself has learned quite a lot of things since he has been attacked so brutally with antisemitic memes and antisemitic caricatures and so on.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 66:12 to 67:16)

What is wrong with it

Four of the Green Party's five MPs said the motion was wrong: Siân Berry, Carla Denyer, Ellie Chowns and Adrian Ramsay. They are to be given "education on Zionism" until "they will change". Their words are on this site.

The party's leader, who is Jewish, was attacked with "antisemitic memes", the speaker says, and from that "has learned quite a lot of things". The leader did not vote on the motion and has twice declined on the BBC to say whether Zionism is racism.

What they say

But some of those parties, the strongest ones in Germany and in Austria, have pushed the other parties to call us antisemitic for passing this motion and to censure us. ... Though if you look at the Green parties in Austria and in Germany, there is nothing green about them. There is nothing democratic about them. And there's everything Zionist about them.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 59:50 to 60:56)

What is wrong with it

By the speaker's own account, the Green Party's sister parties in Europe have called the motion antisemitic and moved to censure the party for it. The answer given is that Germany's and Austria's Greens have "nothing democratic about them" and are "Zionist". Germany's Greens sat in its federal government until May 2025.

That is the pattern of the whole interview: the Prime Minister, the party's MPs, its European sisters, the Board of Deputies and the press are each in turn Zionist, bought, or in need of education.

What they say

The leadership of the West are standing firm in their opposition to freedom for Palestinians, to rights for Palestinians. This is totally wrong. We have to get rid of this government. We have to get rid of any government. ... We need Germany to lose the government that thinks that Israel is doing the dirty job for the West. We need this everywhere in Europe.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 41:10 to 42:11)

What is wrong with it

Britain's government recognised the State of Palestine on 21 September 2025 and supports two states. On this account it must go, with Germany's and "any government": not for opposing a Palestinian state, which it does not, but for not opposing Israel's existence.

The history, and what comes next

2 quotations

What they say

In 1975, the UN passed a resolution called Zionism is Racism. And it was there until the '90s when the US, now that the Soviet Union didn't exist anymore and couldn't stand in the way, the United States and Israel basically bamboozled the UN into removing it. And this is the world we have lived in since, a world of lies.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 36:22 to 37:42)

What is wrong with it

Resolution 3379 was revoked on 16 December 1991 by 111 votes to 25, with 13 abstentions. The 111 included the United Kingdom, every member of the European Community, the Soviet Union itself, which existed for another ten days, and most of Africa, Asia and Latin America. The 25 who voted to keep it included Iran, Iraq, Libya, Syria, Cuba and North Korea. Nobody was "bamboozled"; the world changed its mind.

The Green Party's motion restores, for one British party, a line the United Nations withdrew 35 years ago.

What they say

Now we have to go to A, to the union movement, to the students, to people in the streets, to local authorities. There are all these circles of influence, circles of community that we need to export this message. We need to walk all the way to the UN.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner interviewed by The New Arab, "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 39:54 to 41:10)

What is wrong with it

"Local authorities" are on the list. Green groups on eleven councils were asked by Labour to repudiate the motion and did not; by 2 November Labour had left power-sharing with every one of them. The motion's backers say they mean to bring it to councils next.

This site asks every councillor, of every party, one question: is Zionism racism? The answers so far are on the register, by council.

Taken together

What it adds up to

Asked to introduce the people behind the motion, the two of them set out what it is for: one state in place of Israel, "the heart of it"; Zionism made "illegal"; the land "cleansed"; and, next, "the union movement, ... the students, ... local authorities". Every Green councillor who tells their council the motion is about an ideology and not about Jews, Israel or its existence is contradicted here by the people who wrote it.

Zionism is not racism. Green councillors can say so by signing the pledge; councillors and MPs of every other party, by adding their name.

Green councillors: sign the pledge Other councillors and MPs: add your name

Quotations are from an automated transcript of the video "Meet the people behind the UK Greens' 'Zionism is racism' motion" (The New Arab, YouTube, October 2026), with the time in the video. They are quoted for the purpose of criticism and review.