Zionism Is Not Racism
Act now

"Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026

Their second press conference, line by line

The day after the Board of Deputies of British Jews declared the Green Party a racist party, the motion's authors held a second press conference, streamed live by The Crispin Flintoff Show under the title "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'". Five speakers, six questions, 65 minutes. We listened to every one. Here is what was said, quoted exactly with the time in the stream, and what is wrong with it.

65
minutes, every one listened to
5
speakers, and six questions
20
quotations, each with its time

Criticising Israeli governments, the occupation of the West Bank or the conduct of the war in Gaza is not antisemitism, and nothing on this page says it is. What follows is about what the motion's authors say about Zionism, about Jews and about violence.

  1. The Talmud has "instructions on killing goys" and the Jewish religion has "racist tenets": one of the oldest libels against Jews, from a co-founder of the Jewish Network for Palestine, and the chair moved on.

  2. Israel's Jews should "come back home" to Europe, "where you are safe": said by the motion's lead sponsor to the seven million Jews of Israel, more than half of whom descend from the Jews of the Middle East and North Africa.

  3. The Holocaust is "wrongly called the Holocaust" and was "not the largest" genocide; those who disagree with the motion would "have a Nazi and a Jew and let them discuss who is probably in the right".

  4. "97% of Israeli Jews" want all Palestinians "to leave Palestine or be killed": no survey named, because none says it.

  5. The Prime Minister is "a liar" for saying Britain supports two states; Britain recognised the State of Palestine in September 2025. The speaker does not support two states either.

  6. The Board of Deputies, which had declared the party racist the day before by 118 votes to 1, speaks for "about 32%" of Jews, and parties need not "be really worried about" Jewish voters because of how they vote.

  7. Antisemitism is the fault of Britain's Jews and "the lobby", and "maybe that's what Israel wants". In 65 minutes, Hamas, 7 October and the hostages were not mentioned once.

What they said about Jews

6 quotations

What they say

The Jewish religion, like any other religion ... has in it, um, racist tenets. I think as a Jew, I need to say this because normally, um, we don't talk about that. We don't talk about the fact that the goy, meaning the non-Jew, is actually, um, a derogative term. And there are instructions on killing goys and so on in the Talmud, etc. So the Jewish religion is not sacred. It's not, um, it didn't arrive from a god.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 61:11 to 62:14)

What is wrong with it

That the Talmud instructs Jews to kill non-Jews is one of the oldest libels against Jews there is. It was the charge at the Disputation of Paris in 1240, after which cartloads of the Talmud were burned in the street, and it was a staple of Der Stürmer. "Goy" is the Hebrew word for a nation: in Genesis God promises Abraham that he will become "a great nation", "goy gadol". It is the word the Bible uses for Israel itself.

It was said by a co-founder of the Jewish Network for Palestine, at a press conference held by the authors of the Green Party's motion, to show that the party is not against Jews. The chair moved to the next question. The working definition of antisemitism the UK Government uses gives as its first example "making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such".

What they say

We were not the persecutors of the Jews and should not be made to pay a price for the crimes of Europe. Jews should feel safe where they were in Europe. If they're concerned about Jewish safety, you tell them come back home where you are safe, where you should feel safe.

Lubna Speitan at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 24:33 to 25:34)

What is wrong with it

More than half of Israel's Jews descend not from Europe but from the Jews of the Middle East and North Africa: some 850,000 left or were driven from Arab countries after 1948, and almost none remain. There is no Europe for them to "come back" to. For the rest, the place where they "should feel safe" is the continent where six million Jews were murdered within living memory.

Telling a people to go back where it came from is, by the definition of racism on this site's front page, the plainest example there is. It was said by the motion's lead sponsor, at the press conference held to show that the motion is not racist.

What they say

Not only Jews died in the Holocaust, um, more non-Jews died in the Holocaust. Uh, now the calculations are that between 17 and 18 million people died in what is wrongly called the Holocaust, but, uh, it is one of the largest genocides, not the largest.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 46:16 to 47:32)

What is wrong with it

The Holocaust is the name for the murder of six million Jews by Nazi Germany and those who helped it. The Nazis also murdered millions of others, Roma, Soviet prisoners of war, Poles, disabled people and more, and historians name those crimes and count them. Adding every Nazi killing together to say the Holocaust is "wrongly called" that, and ranking it "not the largest", is not history. The working definition of antisemitism counts denying "the fact, scope, mechanisms ... or intentionality" of the genocide of the Jews among its examples.

The same speaker had, fourteen minutes earlier, likened those who disagree with the motion to people who would "have a Nazi and a Jew and let them discuss who is probably in the right".

What they say

Or, you know, somebody's saying, you know, the Nazis had their views, and I respect this. Um, so let's, let's have a Nazi and a Jew and let them discuss who is, uh, probably in the right. This is what Shami Chakrabarti is doing. This is what, uh, leader of the Labour Party is doing. This is what actually some of the MPs in the Green Party are doing.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 31:16 to 33:18)

What is wrong with it

Said of a peer who had remarked that Zionism "is seen by many people in different ways", of the Prime Minister, and of the Green Party's own MPs who opposed the motion. To hold that the Jewish people may have a homeland, or to allow that others hold it, is likened to taking the Nazis' side.

The belief in question is held by most British Jews. Four of the party's five MPs spoke against the motion. On this account they are the Nazi in the room.

What they say

It is a democracy because 97% of Israeli Jews have supported the genocide. So this is a democratic genocide. This is a popular genocide. Nobody's against it. ... The only thing they agree on by 97% is that all Palestinians should leave Palestine or be killed.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 33:19 to 34:23)

What is wrong with it

No survey was named, and none says it. A figure invented on the spot attributes to 97 per cent of a country's Jews the wish that another people "leave ... or be killed". He went on to call the country "a Jewish Zionist apartheid genocidal democracy" and "democracy of the master race".

Israel's Arab citizens, one in five of the population, vote in the same elections, sit in the same parliament and on its Supreme Court, as the speaker himself noted a moment later.

What they say

This support of the genocide from the largest Jewish organization in Britain is terrifying because for people who are not sophisticated politically, they will understand that Judaism is supporting genocide. ... this will lead and already does to a growth of antisemitism. ... And looking at the power that Israel, the the lobby, and Jewish organizations which are Zionists in Britain, in the US, in, um, France, etc., have ... Maybe that's what Israel wants, but do the Jews of Britain want it?

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 62:14 to 63:38)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitism is laid at the door of Britain's Jews and their elected body: it is their conduct that makes the "not sophisticated" hate them. Then "the power" of "the lobby, and Jewish organizations" in three countries, and the suggestion that Israel wants Jews to be hated. The working definition's examples include "accusing Jews as a people of being responsible for real or imagined wrongdoing" and "the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions".

At the first press conference "the Zionist lobby" was "the main beast in the British political scene". It was said from the floor and let stand. This time it came from the panel.

Two states, and the Prime Minister

4 quotations

What they say

Israel has made the two-state solution impossible. I don't support it. It is not just. ... So, Andy Burnham, you are a liar. If you wanted if the British wanted to support a two-state solution, they would have done it in 1947. They would have done it in 1918, actually. They never supported it. They supported a Jewish genocidal state from the beginning.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 35:24 to 37:26)

What is wrong with it

The United Kingdom recognised the State of Palestine on 21 September 2025, and a two-state solution is its policy. In the United Nations vote of 29 November 1947 that created a Jewish state and an Arab state side by side, Britain abstained. "Never supported it" is false.

The rest is the plain answer to the question this campaign puts to every MP and councillor. The co-founder of the Jewish Network for Palestine does not support two states. The motion backs "a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine". MPs who answer that they support two states, as many on this site have, are answering him.

What they say

No form of Zionism recognizes Palestinian rights. ... And we're told here to consider the feelings, and this is, let's be clear, not about the feelings of Jews, but the feelings of Zionists.

Lubna Speitan at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 21:25 to 22:27)

What is wrong with it

Israel's government signed the Oslo Accords with the Palestine Liberation Organisation in 1993, recognising it and Palestinian self-government. The Board of Deputies of British Jews supports a two-state solution. Dozens of the MPs on this site's register have answered the one question by saying so in their own words.

"Not ... Jews, but ... Zionists" is the distinction the whole motion rests on, and surveys of British Jews show that it is a distinction without a difference: the great majority hold the belief the motion condemns. A rule that applies to "Zionists" applies to most Jews.

What they say

So Andy Burnham stands up in Parliament and says the motion is antisemitic. So basically what he's saying is all Jews think the same way. And I would say to you, Andy Burnham, that is racist against Jews. And as always, they don't say why. Why is it antisemitic? They never give a reason.

Jonathan Fluxman at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 16:20 to 17:37)

What is wrong with it

The Prime Minister said the motion is antisemitic. He said nothing about how Jews think. The reasons are given, by him and by others, and they are on this site: the motion brands the belief of most British Jews as racism, orders that it be "treated as any other form of racism" inside the party, backs one state in all of historic Palestine, and rejects the definitions Jews use to name the racism aimed at them.

The day before this press conference, the Board of Deputies of British Jews, whose deputies are elected by synagogues and communal bodies across the country, declared the Green Party a racist party by 118 votes to 1. The two Jewish speakers on this panel describe their own organisations as "the two anti-Zionist Jewish organizations in Britain", and one said of synagogues: "I don't think Jonathan and myself are meeting in a synagogue."

What they say

I was, uh, brought up in South Africa. We talked about apartheid and nobody had this hysterical reaction as it says racist against white South Africans. It was a political ideology. Everybody recognized it as that.

Jonathan Fluxman at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 17:37 to 18:40)

What is wrong with it

Apartheid was a system of laws by which a government ruled a majority it had disenfranchised. Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people may live as a nation in their homeland, held by nine in ten British Jews. Ending apartheid did not end South Africa. The motion's "single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine" ends Israel.

That is why the two are not received alike. Nobody proposed that South Africa cease to exist, and nobody told white South Africans to go back to Europe. At this press conference, Israel's Jews were told exactly that.

The law, as they would have it

5 quotations

What they say

The rogue and racist IHRA definition that's not there in place to protect Jews from discrimination for being Jewish, but to protect a racist settler colony, Israel. ... It is a political definition designed to protect, uh, and shield a racist state from those criticisms, which in itself is anti-Palestinian racism.

Lubna Speitan at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 20:21 to 21:24)

What is wrong with it

The working definition is adopted by the UK Government, by Labour, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats, by most councils in England and Wales and by dozens of countries. Its text says that "criticism of Israel similar to that leveled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic".

What it does list as examples was on display at this press conference: a libel about the Talmud, the minimising of the Holocaust, a comparison of the motion's critics to Nazis, and Jews blamed for the antisemitism aimed at them. The motion rejects the definition as "weaponised". This is what it would leave Jewish members with no agreed words for.

What they say

It's vital that we hold them to account, that we eradicate these non-legally binding definitions ... and what we should be seeing in any institution that truly values equal rights is to do away with these non-legally binding definitions, is to implement the Equality Act 2010, which is legally binding.

Lubna Speitan at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 28:49 to 29:50)

What is wrong with it

Under the Equality Act 2010 Jewish people are an ethnic group, protected from discrimination and harassment because of it. In 2020 the Equality and Human Rights Commission found the Labour Party responsible for unlawful harassment and discrimination against Jewish members. On 7 October 2026 the Green Party was referred to the Commission over this motion.

In this campaign's view the Act is the motion's problem, not its remedy: a party that declares the core belief of most British Jews to be racism, and orders that those who hold it be treated as racists, is the thing the Act exists to stop.

What they say

Questioner: "Zionism ... is considered racist." The chair: "Of course. Yes." Lubna Speitan: "It's now, um, following the Miller case, uh, protected philosophical belief under the Equality Act 2010 ... we are encouraging people who have been targeted for their anti-Zionist beliefs to take action, to take legal action, to sue their employers."

The chair, and Lubna Speitan at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 43:31 to 44:51)

What is wrong with it

No court or tribunal has ruled that Zionism is racist. The Bristol employment tribunal of February 2024 found that David Miller's anti-Zionist belief was protected under the Equality Act, as a belief; it made no finding that Zionism is racism, and Zionism, as a belief held by most British Jews, is capable of the same protection.

The chair of the first press conference agreed to the same claim on 16 October. It is now the second time the motion's authors have let "a court decided Zionism is racist" stand.

What they say

The Terrorism Act, why I think everyone should repeal that, this is a state apparatus. This is not something designed to protect us from terrorism, but it is designed to label those that this state deems as an enemy or those that are resisting oppression as terrorists. ... from the the South Africans to the Congolese to the Irish, even the Jews who fought in the Warsaw ghettos. They were all vilified and accused of being terrorists. ... the finger pretty much points at our government right now.

Lubna Speitan at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 63:45 to 65:08)

What is wrong with it

The Terrorism Act 2000 is the law under which Hamas is proscribed in full, since 2021, and Palestine Action since 2025. The motion calls for Palestine Action to be taken off the list. The "resistance" the Act is said to vilify was not named, and in 65 minutes neither were Hamas, 7 October or the hostages.

The Jews who fought in the Warsaw Ghetto in 1943 rose against the SS from inside a ghetto whose people were being sent to Treblinka. Whoever was being likened to them went unnamed.

What they say

We need full diplomatic severance of all ties, economic ties, academic ties, cultural ties, a full boycott. ... When you have, you know, British citizens here who could be our neighbors going and joining the Israeli occupation forces, massacring and raping and destroying our homeland and our people, there has to be accountability.

Lubna Speitan at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 27:36 to 28:49)

What is wrong with it

The second press conference in ten days at which British citizens who have served in Israel's army, most of them British Jews, were singled out: on 16 October they were "a threat ... to our collective safety"; here, "massacring and raping", with "accountability" to follow. No person and no case was named.

A full boycott, divestment and sanctions against one state, and one only, is the policy of no major party in Britain. The Green Party has told the BBC that it does not discriminate against people who hold Zionist views.

The party, the Board and the voters

5 quotations

What they say

Either what's been done to our family members has been done because the people doing it are born evil, because what has been done to our family members is evil. ... So either what's being done to them is because these people are a certain way, or it's because they've been indoctrinated by a political ideology. Your choice. Your choice. There isn't another way.

Kieran Andrieu at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 37:34 to 40:44)

What is wrong with it

A choice of two answers, built so that the only one that is not racist is the motion: either Jews are born evil or Zionism is. A war, how it has been fought, the decisions of a government, the part played by Hamas, which started it on 7 October 2023 and has never been mentioned at either press conference, are all left out of the question.

There is a third way, and it is the ordinary one: to judge governments by what they do, and not to make a people, or the belief most of them hold, the culprit.

What they say

There's actually no evidence that they that this had any negative effect. ... 48% according to UGov last year were anti-Israel. 75% of the country thinks it's a genocide. 90% of Labour voters think it's a genocide. So the idea that this would have had a negative effect is not borne on the evidence.

The chair at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 51:48 to 52:50)

What is wrong with it

Zack Polanski lost the Holborn and St Pancras by-election on 9 October 2026, five days after his party declared Zionism racism, by 12,292 votes to 8,928. The winner said the motion had been "brought up to me by people literally at the school gates". No source was given for any of the figures quoted.

What they say

Zack respects the vote. The people are allowed to have a difference of opinion. ... he has suggested that he still supports the, uh, the baseline motion, but he'd like to introduce amendments. Those amendments couldn't constitutionally cannot be introduced until 2028 ... a democratic vote in 2030. ... he has the vast majority of support from the membership, including, uh, our organization.

The chair at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 53:27 to 54:29)

What is wrong with it

The questioner had put it that Zack Polanski said he would have voted against the motion because of the rejected amendments. He did not stay to vote. On the motion's authors' own account, the policy cannot even be amended before 2028 or voted on before 2030, and the leader has their support.

The Green Party told the BBC on 25 October that it rejected the Board of Deputies' "characterisation of this motion and our party". The motion's authors, the next day, called the Board "our old friends" and Zionism "a dying ideology".

What they say

Yeah. Our old friends, the Board of Deputies. ... And, uh, in in the in the current period, every single time there is any criticism of Israel, they they they call it antisemitic. ... The encouraging thing is that there are cracks appearing in the Board of Deputies. ... The days of Zionism are numbered. It's a dying ideology.

Jonathan Fluxman at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 56:57 to 59:02)

What is wrong with it

The Board's deputies are elected every three years by more than 180 synagogues and communal organisations. In 2025, 36 of them signed a letter to the Financial Times criticising Israel's conduct of the war; five were suspended over a press release about it and the rest reprimanded, and the Board carried on with them inside it. That is the "crack". With that debate inside it, the Board voted 118 to 1 that the Green Party has become a racist party.

That the Board advised Jews to stay away from Cable Street in 1936 is true, and ninety years old. What it decided on 25 October 2026 was decided by the people British Jews elect.

What they say

I think the Board of Deputies represents about 32% of Jews, uh, because they represent 32% of the synagogues. ... You probably would know that most Jews vote, uh, for the Conservative Party and have done so for a very long time. So, um, I don't think that Labour, for that matter, or the Green Party, obviously, should be really worried about them because they are not going to vote for anything progressive.

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner at their second press conference, "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'", 26 October 2026, streamed by The Crispin Flintoff Show (automated transcript of the stream, 59:04 to 61:11)

What is wrong with it

The Board of Deputies is elected from top to bottom. Each deputy is elected by the members of the synagogue or communal organisation they sit for, in elections held every three years, and the deputies in turn elect the Board's President and officers by ballot. Nobody on it is appointed. The motion it condemned was carried at a party conference by, in the words of the Green MP Ellie Chowns on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, "a vote of just 0.4% of our members".

No source was given for "32%", and the Board's deputies come from synagogues of every denomination, Orthodox, Masorti, Reform and Liberal, and from the community's charities, students and regional councils. A speaker who says he does not go to synagogue is telling the elected body of those who do how few it speaks for.

The second sentence is advice to a political party: it need not worry about Jewish voters, because of how they vote. In this campaign's view no party should take advice to write off an ethnic minority, and the Green Party has said it does not.

Taken together

What it adds up to

The Green Party told the BBC on 25 October that it rejected the Board of Deputies' description of its motion. The next day, at the press conference its authors held to answer the Board, a Jewish speaker said the Talmud instructs Jews to kill non-Jews, the motion's lead sponsor told Israel's Jews to go back to Europe, and the Holocaust was "wrongly called the Holocaust". The chair moved on each time. That is what "Jews and Palestinians united" behind this motion sounds like.

Zionism is not racism. Green councillors can say so by signing the pledge; councillors and MPs of every other party, by adding their name.

Green councillors: sign the pledge Other councillors and MPs: add your name

Quotations are from an automated transcript of the stream "Jews and Palestinians united behind 'Zionism is Racism'" (The Crispin Flintoff Show, YouTube, 26 October 2026), with the time in the stream. They are quoted for the purpose of criticism and review.