Zionism Is Not Racism
Act now

"Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", October 2026

Their talk with Benjamin Moser, line by line

Greens for Palestine hosted the writer Benjamin Moser, author of "Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History", for 86 minutes, chaired by Kate Youssouf, a criminal defence lawyer and elected member of the Green Party's International Committee, who introduced it as part of the party's work on its policy. We listened to all of it. Here is what was said, quoted exactly with the time in the video, and why it is wrong. Much of it is not a matter of opinion: it is simply untrue, and we have checked it.

86
minutes, every one listened to
26
quotations, each with its time
14
claims of fact, checked: wrong
0
times the chair questioned any of it

Benjamin Moser is entitled to his views, and Jews who oppose Zionism are as Jewish as any other Jews. Criticising Israeli governments, the occupation or the conduct of the war in Gaza is not antisemitism, and nothing on this page says it is. What follows is about what was said, at a Green Party event, about Jews, about Zionists and about the facts.

  1. "In the case of the Jews ... they have a lot of money, so they're very good at producing propaganda. They're very good at bribing politicians." The chair moved on.

  2. Anti-Zionism, in his own definition, is thinking Israel "shouldn't be there"; Zionism is "a lie" and "a great con job".

  3. Zionists "will stop at nothing. There's no lie too big ... no kindergarten they won't bomb."

  4. Israel is "inherently racist ... inherently genocidal", "we should get rid of it", and the argument over the motion is a "smokescreen" for "the real question": "Does Israel have a right to exist?"

  5. Zionists and Nazis "got along just fine", the Holocaust is the Zionists' "biggest trump card", and comparing Israel to the Nazis goes to "who Zionists are".

  6. Fourteen claims of fact, from who issued the Balfour Declaration to whether Jews were ever banned from Jerusalem, from the size of Palestine's Jewish population to what Mandela said: every one of them wrong. They are set out below, with the facts.

  7. The chair called it "enlightening" and "validating", and the Green Party's work to "center Jewish voices".

The facts he got wrong

14 claims of fact, each checked

A talk billed as history, from a prize-winning writer. These are not matters of opinion. Each is a claim of fact made in the video, and each is wrong. The time of each is on its full entry below.

  1. He said

    The Balfour Declaration came "from the Prime Minister, David Lloyd George", and Palestine was assigned to Britain "in 1919 ... under the Treaties of Versailles".

    The fact

    It was a letter from Arthur Balfour, the Foreign Secretary, to Lord Rothschild. The Mandate was allotted at San Remo in 1920 and approved by the League of Nations in 1922. In full

  2. He said

    Jews "were never banned from Palestine at any time in history" and "never prohibited from going to Jerusalem".

    The fact

    Hadrian banned Jews from Jerusalem after 135, the Crusaders from 1099, and Jordan from the Old City from 1948 to 1967. Britain capped Jewish immigration in 1939 as Jews fled Hitler. In full

  3. He said

    Jews "never immigrated to Palestine" and were "3 to 5 percent of the population".

    The fact

    Jews immigrated in every century. The British census of 1922 counted them at 11 per cent of the population, the census of 1931 at 17 per cent. In full

  4. He said

    Zionism is "a Christian idea originally. It's not a Jewish idea", with no root in Jewish tradition.

    The fact

    The return to Zion is in the Jewish prayers said three times a day. Rabbis Alkalai and Kalischer were calling for Jews to return in the 1840s to 1860s, before Herzl. In full

  5. He said

    "Next year in Jerusalem" was understood "for literally centuries" to mean heaven, not Jerusalem.

    The fact

    The daily prayers ask for the return to Zion and the rebuilding of Jerusalem, and Jews travelled and settled there whenever they could. In full

  6. He said

    The Jews "were a religion, just like the Catholics", not a people.

    The fact

    Jews have called themselves a people for three thousand years. English law, up to the Supreme Court in 2009, holds them an ethnic group as well as a faith. In full

  7. He said

    Israel's Jews are "a population of European descent" imported into "the non-white world".

    The fact

    More than half of Israel's Jews descend from the Jews of the Middle East and North Africa, not Europe. In full

  8. He said

    "Israel doesn't have borders ... It's never been able to have a boundary."

    The fact

    Its borders with Egypt and Jordan are fixed by treaty, and its line with Lebanon was marked by the United Nations in 2000. In full

  9. He said

    "Zionism cannot make peace", and Camp David "has nothing to do with Palestine".

    The fact

    Israel has made peace with Egypt and Jordan and normalised relations with three more Arab states. The first Camp David framework was about Palestinian self-government. In full

  10. He said

    Mandela, Tutu and Tambo "have said that actually South Africa never came close to Israel in terms of apartheid".

    The fact

    There is no record of Mandela saying it: the "Mandela memo" is a satire by Arjan El Fassed. Tutu drew a comparison, which is not the same thing. In full

  11. He said

    "It was Churchill who said that we were going to create a little Jewish Ulster."

    The fact

    It was Sir Ronald Storrs, the Military Governor of Jerusalem, in his memoir Orientations (1937). In full

  12. He said

    "You can't sell a book in the U.K." by Sally Rooney.

    The fact

    Her books were never withdrawn from sale. The question raised was whether her stated funding of Palestine Action, proscribed under the Terrorism Act, was an offence. In full

  13. He said

    "The first biography of a woman writer in English ... was, I think, in 1971. It was a book about Virginia Woolf."

    The fact

    Elizabeth Gaskell's Life of Charlotte Brontë was published in 1857. Quentin Bell's Virginia Woolf came out in 1972. In full

  14. He said

    The chair: "the Orthodox community, actually have rejected Zionism".

    The fact

    In the 2015 City University survey, 93 per cent of British Jews said Israel is part of their Jewish identity, the religious most of all. The men at the marches are Neturei Karta, a sect of a few hundred. In full

What was said about Jews and Zionists

5 quotations

What they say

But in the case of the Jews, they scream at you, and they call you a racist, and they call you an anti-Semite, and they call you a self-hating Jew. And at the same time, they have a lot of money, so they're very good at producing propaganda. They're very good at bribing politicians.

Antisemitic

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 19:56 to 20:24)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. Jews, or the Zionists who are most of them, said to have "a lot of money" with which they produce propaganda and bribe politicians.

Why is this antisemitic?

Jews secretly controlling governments, police, banks or the press is the oldest antisemitic conspiracy theory there is. Putting "Zionists" or "the lobby" where the older word was does not change what it is.

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective, such as, especially but not exclusively, "the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions"."

Rich, in charge of the propaganda and buying the politicians: the oldest charge against Jews, said here of "they" in a sentence that begins "in the case of the Jews". Whether "they" means Jews or Zionists, more than eight in ten British Jews say Israel plays an important part in their Jewish identity, so it lands on most of Britain's Jews either way.

It was said at a Green Party event, chaired by an elected member of the party's International Committee, before an audience the chair said came from across the world. She did not question it, and moved on to the next question.

What they say

they will stop at nothing. There's no lie too big. There's no bomb that, you know, there's no kindergarten they won't bomb. There's no hospital they won't bomb. And then they'll lie about it.

Antisemitic

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 1:16:38)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. A whole group, the Zionists, who in Britain are most of its Jews, said to lie without limit and to stop at nothing, kindergartens and hospitals included.

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective, such as, especially but not exclusively, "the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions"."

"They" are "these people", the Zionists of the answer before it: not the Israeli government, not its army, but the people who hold the belief, who in Britain are most of its Jews. A whole group is said to lie without limit and to want children and the sick bombed.

Criticising the conduct of the war in Gaza is legitimate, and nothing here says otherwise. Saying that the people who believe in a Jewish state will "stop at nothing" is a statement about those people, not about any policy.

What they say

the Jewish people were not a people like the Bulgarians or the Hungarians. Those are political peoples. Those are linguistic peoples. ... They were a religion, just like the Catholics are a religion, but the Catholics can also be English, or they can be French, or they can be Italian.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 15:17)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Jews have called themselves a people for three thousand years, and English law, up to the Supreme Court in 2009, holds that they are an ethnic group as well as a faith.

Jews have called themselves a people, Am Yisrael, the people of Israel, for three thousand years, and many Jews today are Jewish without being religious at all. English law agrees: the courts, up to the Supreme Court in 2009, hold that Jews are an ethnic group as well as a faith, and the Equality Act 2010 protects them as both.

Whether Jews are a people is for Jews to say. Telling them they are only a "church", so that a people's claim to self-determination can be set aside, is the same move as the motion's own: defining Jewish identity for Jews.

What they say

it's actually a Christian idea originally. It's not a Jewish idea. ... it's part of this kind of Christian apocalyptic fantasy about the end of days and the second coming of Christ and all this kind of stuff that no Jewish person could possibly think had any root in our tradition or our religion.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 3:40 to 4:24)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. The return to Zion is in Jewish prayers said three times a day, and rabbis were calling for Jews to settle the land in the 1840s, before Herzl.

The return to Zion is in the Jewish prayers said three times a day, in the grace after meals and at the end of every Passover Seder, and has been for two thousand years. Jews fasted for Jerusalem every Tisha B'Av, and Jewish communities lived on in Jerusalem, Hebron, Safed and Tiberias throughout.

Rabbis Yehuda Alkalai and Zvi Hirsch Kalischer were calling for Jews to return and settle the land in the 1840s to 1860s, and the Jewish "Lovers of Zion" were founding villages there in the 1880s, before Herzl. Christian "restorationists" existed too, but Zionism was not theirs to start.

What they say

you've got to admire the chutzpah, as the Jews say, the nerve of saying that anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism. ... It's like saying, "Is the earth flat?" Like, let's have a debate about that. Well, you know, let's not have a debate about that.

Misleading

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 21:30)

What is wrong with it

Misleading. The definition of antisemitism adopted by the UK Government names denying the Jewish people self-determination as an example; that is not a flat-earth question.

Why is this misleading?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

Whether a given piece of anti-Zionism is antisemitic depends on what it says. The working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives as an example denying the Jewish people the right to self-determination, "e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor". That is the motion's claim, and in this talk it was said in terms.

The flat earth is a settled question of fact. This is a question on which the Government, the main parties, the Chief Rabbi, the Board of Deputies and the great majority of British Jews have given an answer. Declaring it beyond debate is a way not to hear them.

Israel's right to exist

8 quotations

What they say

Israel did all sorts of things that we didn't like, but so did every other country. I mean, so did the UK, so did the U.S., so did Germany. I mean, everybody did stuff, but that wasn't the same as thinking Germany shouldn't be there, you know, which is basically the anti-Zionist position.

Antisemitic

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 5:03)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. Anti-Zionism defined, by the guest, as thinking Israel "shouldn't be there": the one state in the world whose existence is the question.

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

His own definition of the word in the motion: anti-Zionism is thinking the country "shouldn't be there". The Green Party says its motion is about an ideology, not about Israel's existence. Its guest, at its own event, says the ideology is exactly that.

What they say

It was about opposing something that was fundamentally racist, fundamentally illegitimate, fundamentally cruel, and expansionist. ... this is just wrong. It's always been wrong. We should get rid of it. ... it was always not only inherently racist, but inherently genocidal in my view.

Antisemitic

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 8:08 and 52:35)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. Calls the one Jewish state "inherently racist" and "inherently genocidal" and says "we should get rid of it".

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

The "it" is Israel, a country of ten million people, seven million of them Jews, and the only place on earth where Jews are not a minority. "We should get rid of it" is not a call to change a government or a policy. It is a call to end the state, and it was made at an event held to discuss the Green Party's motion, introduced with "since we're in a Green Party forum here".

The working definition of antisemitism adopted by the UK Government gives as an example "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor." It is hard to put that more plainly than "inherently racist ... we should get rid of it".

What they say

this Green Party thing now, what the opponents of the Palestinian people are trying to impose on us is a debate about whether you're allowed to use this word or whether this is the right phrasing ... They're trying to create a smokescreen so that you don't ask the real question. And the real question is, is Israel legitimate? Does Israel have a right to exist?

Antisemitic

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 53:36 to 54:37)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. Says the real question raised by the motion is whether Israel has a right to exist, the question the Green Party says the motion is not about.

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

The Green Party has told its members that the motion is about an ideology and not about Israel's existence. Here, at a Green Party event, the guest says the opposite: the argument about the motion is a "smokescreen", and "the real question" is whether Israel has a right to exist.

The "feelings" waved away are those of British Jews, who have told the party through the Board of Deputies, the Chief Rabbi and their own local communities that the motion targets them. The party's own anti-racism says the people on the receiving end are the first judges of what they experience.

What they say

The story of Zionism is a lie, and everything about it is a lie. ... Zionism is a great con job

Misleading

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 12:05 and 23:17)

What is wrong with it

Misleading. The belief of most British Jews called "a lie" from beginning to end and "a great con job".

Not a mistaken belief, or one he disagrees with: "a lie", "everything about it", and "a con job". Most British Jews hold the belief so described. On this account they are either the conned or the con men.

What they say

a settler colony is basically when you import a population of European descent into a part of the non-white world ... It says these are foreigners who either came from Europe or they came with the backing of Europe to settle in a non-white country and to take it over and to ethnically cleanse and commit genocide against it.

Factually wrongAntisemitic

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 55:47 and 59:06)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. More than half of Israel's Jews descend from Jews of the Middle East and North Africa, not Europe.

Antisemitic. Calls the Jews of Israel "foreigners", which denies the Jewish people's tie to the land and their right to a state there.

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

More than half of Israel's Jews descend not from Europe but from the 850,000 Jews who were driven out of, or fled, Arab countries and Iran after 1948, and from Jews who never left the land. Earlier in the same talk he describes Arab Jews being "dragged into Israel": they cannot be both.

Jews are not foreigners to the land they are named for. Calling the Jews of Israel "foreigners", whatever their origins, is how the right of the Jewish people to a state of their own is denied.

What they say

they're quite explicit in saying, "Okay, yes, there are people there, but we're going to get rid of them. We're going to ethnically cleanse them." The word they used was transfer. ... this is why Zionism was always racist and always exclusionary

Misleading

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 32:22)

What is wrong with it

Misleading. Transfer was debated after the British Peel Commission proposed it in 1937; the movement accepted the 1947 partition with some 400,000 Arab citizens in the Jewish state, and the Arabs who remained in 1949 got the vote.

Transfer was discussed by some Zionist leaders after the British Peel Commission proposed it in 1937; it was never the movement's declared aim. The movement accepted the UN partition plan of 1947, under which the Jewish state would have had some 400,000 Arab citizens, and Israel's Declaration of Independence promised "complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants". The 160,000 Arabs who remained in 1949 became citizens with the vote.

What they say

Camp David is a peace treaty between Israel and Egypt. It has nothing to do with Palestine. ... Zionism cannot make peace. It constitutionally can't make peace. It is going to go on with its violence and mayhem until either it destroys the entire Arab world ... Or it's going to get destroyed.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 1:17:44 to 1:18:42)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Israel has made peace with Egypt and Jordan and normalised relations with the UAE, Bahrain and Morocco; the 1978 Camp David Accords included a framework for Palestinian self-government.

Israel has made peace with Egypt (1979) and Jordan (1994), and normalised relations with the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and Morocco (2020). It gave all of Sinai back to Egypt, and withdrew from Gaza in 2005. A movement that "cannot make peace" has made it, and kept it, with the two Arab neighbours it fought most.

And the 1978 Camp David Accords had two parts. The first, "A Framework for Peace in the Middle East", was about the Palestinians: self-government in the West Bank and Gaza. The choice offered for the one Jewish state, destroy "the entire Arab world" or "get destroyed", leaves no room for its Jews to live in peace.

What they say

Israel doesn't have borders. This is quite strange, actually. ... It's never been able to have a boundary.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 58:01)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Israel's borders with Egypt and Jordan are fixed by treaty, and the line with Lebanon was marked by the UN in 2000.

Israel's borders with Egypt and Jordan are fixed by its peace treaties of 1979 and 1994 and recognised by the world. Its line with Lebanon was marked by the United Nations in 2000. What is unsettled is the border with a Palestinian state, which is a matter for negotiation, and the Golan Heights.

Zionists and the Nazis

2 quotations

What they say

The other one that you're absolutely not allowed to mention is any connection between the Zionists and the Nazis or any comparison between Israeli actions and the actions of the Nazis during the Second World War. Why is this prohibited? Is it because it's not true or because it is true and it goes to the very basic core of what Zionism is and who Zionists are? ... the Zionist leadership and the Nazi leadership actually did, they got along just fine, at least for quite a while.

AntisemiticMisleading

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 1:10:18 and 1:11:53)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. Says comparing Israel with the Nazis goes to "who Zionists are", and that the Zionist and Nazi leaderships "got along just fine".

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis."

Misleading. The 1933 Haavara agreement was an emergency deal to get some 60,000 German Jews out; the Nazis went on to murder Zionists with every other Jew.

In 1933 the Zionist movement in Germany made the Haavara ("transfer") agreement with the new Nazi government, so that some 60,000 German Jews could get to Palestine with part of their property. It was an emergency deal to get Jews out of a country that meant them harm, and many Zionists, Jabotinsky among them, fought it bitterly. The Nazis went on to murder six million Jews, Zionists among them. "Got along just fine" is not history.

And the comparison he says is forbidden is one the working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, names as an example: "Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis." Here it is not even Israeli policy but "who Zionists are".

What they say

the Zionists, who despite having this quite sordid history with the Nazis, decided that the Holocaust was their biggest trump card. This was really the thing that they could use to legitimize this illegitimate state.

MisleadingAntisemitic

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 1:15:27)

What is wrong with it

Misleading. The Jewish claim to a home in the land was recognised by the League of Nations in 1922, two decades before the Holocaust.

Antisemitic. Casts the memory of the six million as a Jewish "trump card".

The case for a Jewish home in its ancestral land was made, and recognised, long before the Holocaust: in the Balfour Declaration of 1917, and in the League of Nations Mandate of 1922, which recognised "the historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine". The Holocaust did not invent it. It showed what happens to a people with nowhere to go.

Saying that Jews use the murder of six million of their own as a "trump card" casts the Holocaust's memory as a Jewish trick, and is the kind of claim the working definition of antisemitism has in mind.

The history he told

9 quotations

What they say

Now, Jews were never prohibited from going to Jerusalem. ... I mean, Jews were never, were never banned from Palestine at any time in history.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 16:20 to 17:23)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Hadrian banned Jews from Jerusalem after 135, the Crusaders in 1099, Jordan from the Old City from 1948 to 1967, and Britain capped Jewish immigration in 1939 as Jews fled Hitler.

After the Bar Kokhba revolt of 132 to 135, the Roman emperor Hadrian banned Jews from Jerusalem, renamed it Aelia Capitolina, and renamed the province Syria Palaestina. The Crusaders massacred the Jews of Jerusalem in 1099 and barred Jews from living there. Between 1948 and 1967 Jordan barred Jews from the Old City and the Western Wall.

And as Jews fled Hitler, Britain's White Paper of 1939 limited Jewish immigration to Palestine to 75,000 over five years. Ships of refugees were turned away.

What they say

Jews immigrated to everywhere in the world. They never immigrated to Palestine. It was only 3 to 5 percent of the population. ... Palestine, which was a country that had never harmed the Jews in any way and where they were 3 to 5 percent of the population

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 16:20 and 53:36)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Jews immigrated to the land in every century, and the British censuses counted them at 11 per cent of the population in 1922 and 17 per cent in 1931.

Jews immigrated to the land in every century: the exiles from Spain who made Safed a centre of Jewish learning in the 1500s, the Hasidim of 1777, the students of the Vilna Gaon from 1808, and the farming villages founded from 1882. By 1880 some 25,000 Jews lived there.

The British census of 1922 counted 83,790 Jews, 11 per cent of the population; the census of 1931 counted 174,610, 17 per cent. "3 to 5 percent" was last true in the middle of the nineteenth century.

What they say

There's a prayer at the end of the Passover Seder that says, "Next year in Jerusalem." And this is something that everybody for literally centuries understood very clearly does not refer to the actual municipality of Jerusalem. It refers to basically to heaven.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 15:17 to 16:20)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Jewish prayer asks three times a day for the return to Zion and the rebuilding of Jerusalem, a place, not only heaven, and Jews travelled and settled there whenever they could.

Jewish prayer asks, three times a day, "May our eyes behold your return to Zion in mercy", and asks God to "rebuild Jerusalem". Jews fasted for the city's fall, left a corner of their homes unplastered in mourning for it, and travelled and settled there whenever they could, from the poet Judah Halevi in the twelfth century to the hundreds who followed the Vilna Gaon's students in the nineteenth. The longing was for a place, not only for heaven.

What they say

the movement in 1917 gets this declaration in Whitehall in Britain from the Prime Minister, David Lloyd George, called the Balfour Declaration ... And in 1919, it's assigned to the British Empire under the Treaties of Versailles.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 34:10 to 36:00)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. The Balfour Declaration was a letter from Arthur Balfour, the Foreign Secretary, to Lord Rothschild; the Mandate was allotted at San Remo in 1920 and approved by the League of Nations in 1922, not at Versailles in 1919.

The Balfour Declaration of 2 November 1917 was a letter from Arthur Balfour, the Foreign Secretary, to Lord Rothschild, approved by the War Cabinet: that is why it carries his name. Lloyd George was Prime Minister; he did not issue it.

Palestine was not assigned to Britain at Versailles in 1919. The Mandate was allotted to Britain at the San Remo conference in April 1920 and approved by the Council of the League of Nations in July 1922. Its text recognised "the historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine".

What they say

guess who helped get the Jews out of the Arab world? And not just helped them by providing a free bus ticket, but actually by bombing Jewish and Western institutions in order to create widespread panic among the Jews of the Arab world to force them to immigrate to the Israeli state. Well, I mean, I think I've kind of given it away there. But of course, it was the Zionists.

Misleading

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 48:34)

What is wrong with it

Misleading. Who bombed Baghdad in 1950 and 1951 is disputed, not "of course"; what is not disputed is the Farhud, Iraq's death penalty for Zionism, and the seizure of Jewish property.

Who planted the bombs in Baghdad in 1950 and 1951 is disputed: Iraq convicted and hanged two members of a Zionist underground, Israel has always denied it, and historians are divided. It is not "of course".

What is not disputed is why some 850,000 Jews left the Arab world. In Baghdad's Farhud of 1941 about 180 Jews were murdered. In 1948 Iraq made Zionism a crime punishable by death and hanged a leading Jewish businessman; in 1950 it let Jews leave only if they gave up their citizenship, and in 1951 it froze their property. There were pogroms in Aden and Aleppo in 1947 and in Libya in 1945 and 1948, and Egypt expelled thousands of Jews in 1956. Blaming their flight on the Zionists erases what was done to them.

What they say

Some of the most eminent South African leaders, including Nelson Mandela and Desmond Tutu and Oliver Tambo, have said that actually South Africa never came close to Israel in terms of apartheid.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 52:35)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. There is no record of Mandela saying it: the "Mandela memo" is a satire by Arjan El Fassed. Tutu drew a comparison; he did not say South Africa "never came close".

There is no record of Nelson Mandela saying anything of the kind. The "memo" from Mandela about Israel that has gone round the internet since 2001 was written by Arjan El Fassed, a Dutch-Palestinian activist, who has said it was satire. Desmond Tutu wrote in 2002 that what he saw "reminded me so much of what happened to us black people in South Africa"; that is a comparison, not a statement that South Africa "never came close".

Inside Israel, Arab citizens vote, sit in parliament and on the Supreme Court, and serve as doctors, judges and ministers. Whatever view anyone takes of the occupation, that is not South African apartheid.

What they say

I think it was Churchill who said that we were going to create a little Jewish ulster in the heart of the Arab world.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 1:01:49)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. The "little loyal Jewish Ulster" line is Sir Ronald Storrs's, in his memoir Orientations (1937), not Churchill's.

It was not Churchill. The line is Sir Ronald Storrs's, the British Military Governor of Jerusalem, in his memoir Orientations (1937): a Jewish home would form for England "a little loyal Jewish Ulster" in a sea of potentially hostile Arabism. It was a British official describing British interest, not the purpose of the Jews who lived there.

What they say

you can't sell a book in the U.K. by a woman who writes about basically, like, you know, millennial Irish people in, you know, dating each other, that you can't sell that because you think that this author has views that you don't like.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 1:08:32)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Sally Rooney's books were never withdrawn from sale in Britain; the question raised was her stated funding of Palestine Action, proscribed under the Terrorism Act.

Sally Rooney's novels were not withdrawn from sale in Britain. In October 2025 she said she would give royalties to Palestine Action, which Parliament had proscribed under the Terrorism Act; the question raised was whether funding it was an offence, not whether her books could be sold.

What they say

The first biography of a woman writer in English, I believe this is true, was, I think, in 1971. It was a book about Virginia Woolf.

Factually wrong

Benjamin Moser, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 9:55)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Elizabeth Gaskell's Life of Charlotte Brontë was published in 1857; Quentin Bell's Virginia Woolf in 1972.

Elizabeth Gaskell's "The Life of Charlotte Brontë" was published in 1857. Quentin Bell's biography of Virginia Woolf, presumably the book meant, came out in 1972. A literary historian, telling a Green Party audience about history, got the history of his own subject wrong by more than a century.

What the chair said

2 quotations

What they say

what we see is that some of the most religious Jews, the Orthodox community, actually have rejected Zionism. We see Orthodox Jews at Palestinian liberation demonstrations very, very habitually, and they are actually some of the most staunch supporters of Palestinian liberation.

Factually wrong

Kate Youssouf, the chair, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 17:30)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Neturei Karta at the marches is a sect of a few hundred; in the 2015 City University survey, 93 per cent of British Jews said Israel is part of their Jewish identity, most of all among the religious.

The men in black hats at the marches are Neturei Karta, a sect of a few hundred in Britain. "The Orthodox community" is the opposite of what she says: in the 2015 City University survey of British Jews, 93 per cent said Israel plays a part in their Jewish identity, and attachment to Israel was strongest among the religious. The chair of a Green Party policy group told its audience that the most observant Jews reject Zionism.

What they say

Today's conversation is just one of the ways in which the Green Party of England and Wales is working to center Jewish and Palestinian voices in conversations about issues in the regions of Israel and Palestine, particularly as the party continues to develop its policies pertinent to those areas. ... I have found what you have said not only enlightening, but validating.

Misleading

Kate Youssouf, the chair, who introduced herself as an elected member of the Green Party's International Committee and chair of its International Policy Working Group, "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser", on YouTube, October 2026 (automated transcript of the video, 0:00 and 1:24:25)

What is wrong with it

Misleading. Introduced as the Green Party centring "Jewish voices", the talk heard one Jewish voice, and the chair let every claim above stand.

The chair introduced the talk as the Green Party's own work on its policy, not a fringe event. In 86 minutes the one Jewish voice "centred" was a guest who says Israel should be got rid of; the more than eight in ten British Jews for whom Israel is an important part of their Jewish identity were not heard from, and were described.

Jews being rich and bribing politicians, Zionists stopping at nothing, Zionists and Nazis getting along "just fine": none of it was questioned by the chair. Her verdict at the end was "enlightening" and "validating". The party says the motion is not about Jews. This is what its own forum sounded like.

Taken together

What it adds up to

The Green Party says the motion is about an ideology, not about Jews and not about Israel's existence. At a Green Party event about it, chaired by a member of the party's own International Committee, Jews were said to have the money to buy politicians, Zionists to stop at nothing, and the real question to be whether Israel should exist at all. Nobody on the call said a word against it.

Zionism is not racism. Green councillors can say so by signing the pledge; councillors and MPs of every other party, by adding their name.

Green councillors: sign the pledge Other councillors and MPs: add your name

Quotations are from an automated transcript of the video "Greens For Palestine: In Conversation with Benjamin Moser" (YouTube, October 2026), with the time in the video. They are quoted for criticism and review.