Zionism Is Not Racism
Act now

Birmingham · Letter, 22 October 2026

Letter from Al Carns MP, Jess Phillips MP, Preet Kaur Gill MP and four peers to the Leader of Birmingham City Council

The Birmingham MPs Al Carns, Jess Phillips and Preet Kaur Gill, with Baroness Morris of Yardley, Lord Rooker, Lord McCabe and Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, wrote this letter to a Green councillor on Birmingham Council about the Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion on 22 October 2026, asking whether any of the council's Green councillors voted for or endorse it. It is reproduced here in full, in the Leader's words. Posted on Facebook by Al Carns MP and Preet Kaur Gill MP on 23 October 2026, with the letter dated 22 October 2026.

Dear Cllr Roger Harmer,,

We are writing to express our serious concern about the current administration of Birmingham City Council following the Green Party's vote to accept the Zionism is Racism motion at its party conference.

The Green Party's adoption of the motion is an abhorrent step. It has no place in British political life and will do nothing to help the Palestinian or Israeli people. The motion echoes anti-Jewish movements from the Soviet Union, the National Front and terrorist groups Hamas and Hezbollah. It is itself racist, discriminatory and extremist.

Worse still, the Green Party chose to reject an amendment that stated the motion should not be used to “pressure, proscribe or discipline members based on affiliations with Jewish community institutions”. This is a frightening step that will label Jewish people who attend synagogue to pray as “racist”.

Zionism is simply the belief that Jews should have a homeland, nothing more or less. It was an ideology born out of centuries of persecution. The state of Israel was formed following the horrors of the Nazi Holocaust. Zionism is a view shared by the majority of Jewish people worldwide.

Like any diverse group, those who consider themselves Zionists may disagree profoundly about Israel, her actions and even her borders. But they fundamentally agree in Israel's right to exist. The Green Party's stance forms part of an ongoing attack on the safety and wellbeing of British Jews. The motion it has adopted is itself a racist attack on Jewish life in Britain. Which is why it was welcome to see senior Liberal Democrats issue statements strongly condemning the Green Party following the vote.

But in Birmingham, the Lib Dem run council remains in a power sharing agreement with the Greens. Your cabinet member for Children and Young Families, Cllr Kamel Hawwash, was one of the Green politicians to previously vote in favour of the racist motion.

This is an intolerable state of affairs, not least because Birmingham City Council voted to adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance definition of antisemitism in 2017 and is a city with a proud track record when it comes to fighting racism.

In light of the appalling direction of the Green Party, we today urge you to seek a public statement from the Greens in your cabinet that they disown the motion. If they are unwilling to do so, then we ask that you show moral fibre and bring your power sharing agreement with the Greens in Birmingham to an immediate end. We urge you to do this in the interests of defending the city's democracy from extremists and racists. It is the right thing to do.

Thank you for considering our letter.

We await your response with urgency.

Kind Regards,
Al Carns DSO OBE MC MP, MP for Birmingham Selly Oak
Jess Phillips, MP for Birmingham Yardley
Preet Kaur Gill MP, MP for Birmingham Edgbaston
The Rt Hon. the Baroness Morris of Yardley
The Rt Hon. the Lord Rooker
The Lord McCabe
The Rt Hon. the Lord Hunt of Kings Heath OBE

The letter as it was published, in 2 images. Swipe, or use the arrows.
  1. The open letter, as published, 1 of 2
  2. The open letter, as published, 2 of 2
1 / 2

The Green councillors on Birmingham

Ask them to answer the Leader of the council, and to call for the motion to be reversed.

Email the Green councillors on Birmingham Where each of them stands

Keep going

What Jewish communities say Is Zionism racism? The motion, line by line