Zionism Is Not Racism
Act now

The accountability register · the racist motion

Councillor Esther Lie

Cllr Esther Lie Stands by the motion

Crofton Park ward, Lewisham

Stands by the racist motion, in their own words, in Open letter from Green councillors (below). Has not signed the pledge against it.

Defends the racist motion, on the record

As reported by Open letter from Green councillors on 24 October 2026, Cllr Esther Lie said:

“We are Green councillors who support the "Zionism is Racism" motion passed at the Green Party conference on 4th October 2026.”

Signed the open letter of Green councillors who support the motion (named among its signatories by 24 October 2026).

What Cllr Lie said, and why it is wrong

The open letter is answered line by line on the main site, with every claim in it set against the motion's own text and the public record: the open letter, answered.

Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, including many who are fierce critics of Israeli governments.

The letter's signatories say the motion has been described in ways they do not recognise. The motion is 22 pages long and anyone can read it. It declares Zionism racism, to be treated "as any other form of racism"; commits the party to "oppose and campaign against" it; rejects both the IHRA definition of antisemitism and the Jerusalem Declaration; and calls for "a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine". The description that fits is the one in its own words.

Everything Cllr Lie has said, with every source, and why they are wrong: their page on zionismisracism.co.uk

Put this on your website

Paste this code into your website, blog or newsletter page. It stays up to date by itself and links back here. Add ?theme=light to the address for a white background.

On the amber list

Cllr Esther Lie signed the Palestine Solidarity Campaign's "Councillor Pledge for Palestine" (its list), which asks councillors to "stand up to Israel for its crimes of genocide and apartheid" and to divest council pension funds. They have not signed the pledge that Zionism is not racism.

Signing the pledge, or its first step, takes them off the amber list.

In the news · The Mayor of Lewisham, on Facebook · 19 October 2026

The Green Mayor of Lewisham, on video: the motion "at its core" was "articulating the political ideology that underpins" what he calls "a racist system of apartheid, occupation, displacement, and genocide"

In a three-minute video posted on 19 October 2026, Liam Shrivastava, the Mayor of Lewisham, said he had replied to Lewisham Labour and the borough's three Labour MPs. He repeated that "this motion will not be used against our local Jewish communities or Jewish party members", and that he "did not vote on this motion and hold[s] some concerns over its wording".

He then said: "at its core the motion was articulating the political ideology that underpins the Palestinian people's oppression: a racist system of apartheid, occupation, displacement, and genocide." In his letter of 16 October the motion "describes" that ideology; here the ideology, Zionism, is "a racist system". He did not say the motion was wrong.

Most of the video is about Labour. He said the Attorney General, Ellie Reeves, is responsible for the Government's legal advice on arms sales to Israel, that Lewisham Labour disciplined "councillors like me for speaking out", and that he would "take no moral lectures" from it. He ended: "Stop arming Israel. End the genocide. And free Palestine." These are the Mayor's words, not those of any one councillor on this page.

Read the story in The Mayor of Lewisham, on Facebook

In the news · The Mayor of Lewisham · 16 October 2026

The Green Mayor of Lewisham: the motion "at its core" describes "the political ideology which underpins the Palestinian people's oppression"

Liam Shrivastava, the Mayor of Lewisham, replied to letters from Labour MPs and the Labour council leader about the motion. He wrote that he did not vote on it and has "concerns over elements of its content and wording", but that "at its core, this motion describes the political ideology which underpins the Palestinian people's oppression".

He wrote that there were "a variety of different views within the Green Group", and that "this motion will not be used against our local Jewish communities or Jewish party members". These are the Mayor's words, not those of any one councillor on this page.

On 4 October 2026 the Green Party of England and Wales declared that Zionism is racism, in its racist motion. Councillor Esther Lie stands by it, in their own words, quoted above. Their position is clear, and this site records it.

Zionism is not racism. It is the belief that Jews have a right to a homeland in their ancestral land, held by most British Jews. A councillor who calls that belief racism has told the Jewish residents of Lewisham what they think of them.

Lie stands by the motion

Cllr Esther Lie has made their position clear. Their page on zionismisracism.co.uk sets out everything they have said, with every source, and offers an email telling them why the motion is wrong.

Cllr Lie on zionismisracism.co.uk The accountability register

Share this page

A ready-made image with Lie's name, ward and their position. Post it, or send the link.

Share image: Cllr Esther Lie, Crofton Park ward, Lewisham

Every button carries a line about where they stand.

Download for Instagram

The other Green councillors on Lewisham

Email the Green councillors on Lewisham

Keep going

Every Green councillor's position Every Green councillor, by council Email more Green councillors These councillors say Zionism is racism