The accountability register · the racist motion

Cllr Douglas Johnson Silent
Not in the racist motion's printed lists of supporters. Has not signed the pledge against it. Has not left the party over it. No public position on the racist motion recorded. A Green councillor who says nothing while the party calls most British Jews racists is, in this campaign's view, complicit in it: silence is not neutral, and until they say otherwise the motion speaks for them.
Cllr Johnson: say where you stand with one email from your council address, no code. against@zionismisracism.co.uk if you are against the motion, for@zionismisracism.co.uk if you support it. Either is published here in your name, with a statement in your own words if you add one.
On the amber list
Cllr Douglas Johnson signed the Palestine Solidarity Campaign's "Councillor Pledge for Palestine" (its list), which asks councillors to "stand up to Israel for its crimes of genocide and apartheid" and to divest council pension funds. They have not signed the pledge that Zionism is not racism.
Signing the pledge, or its first step, takes them off the amber list.
What Sheffield Green Party (council group leader Cllr Angela Argenzio) have said
Cllr Johnson's local party published a statement on 16 October 2026: Statement from the Sheffield Green group on Labour's ultimatum.
“Yesterday, on Andy Burnham's orders, Sheffield’s Labour Group Leader sent me a letter claiming Labour will end our joint administration of City Council unless I condemn my own party's democratically decided national positions and block some of our Green councillors from chairing committees.”
“Decisions about how our council is run should be made here in Sheffield, not dictated from Westminster. Does Mr Burnham not trust his local councillors to make good decisions about who should run their local areas?”
“The accusation that the Sheffield Green Party is antisemitic is unfounded. We do not, and will not, conflate either Zionism and Judaism, nor anti-Zionism with antisemitism.”
“The people of this city trust us to deliver for them with fairness and inclusivity and will see right through Burnham's political games.”
These are the local party's words, not Cllr Johnson's own: the statement names no councillor. Read the statement in full.
Why this is wrong
Condemn "my own party's democratically decided national positions".
A vote does not make a position right. The motion says Zionism, the belief of most British Jews that the Jewish people have a homeland, "will be treated as any other form of racism" (page 6). Four of the party's five MPs have rejected it, and so have Green councillors across the country, among them the Green leaders of Bristol, Cornwall and Norwich. Asking a council leader whether she stands by it is not asking her to betray democracy. It is asking her the question those Greens have already answered.
Block "some of our Green councillors from chairing committees".
We have not seen Labour's letter. But two Sheffield Green councillors, Alexi Dimond and Maroof Raouf, are named in the motion's printed lists of supporters: Cllr Dimond in both the spring and autumn versions, Cllr Raouf in the autumn version that passed. Those lists are the party's own papers. Whether councillors who put their names to a motion that calls the belief of most British Jews racism should chair committees in a city with Jewish residents is a fair question for a coalition partner to ask. And it did not start in Westminster: The Star reported that Sheffield's own Labour leader, Cllr Fran Belbin, called the motion "shameful and antisemitic".
Decisions "should be made here in Sheffield, not dictated from Westminster".
Then make it in Sheffield. The question is not about buses or council tax. It is whether the group that runs the city stands by a motion that Jewish residents read as calling them racist. Labour groups in Lambeth and Hastings have put the same question to their Green councillors in public. Jewish residents of Sheffield are not asking for a ruling from London. They are asking whether their councillors agree with it.
"The accusation that the Sheffield Green Party is antisemitic is unfounded. We do not conflate Zionism and Judaism, nor anti-Zionism with antisemitism."
The question is about the motion, not about every Green in Sheffield. Whatever its authors intend, a motion that makes the belief of most British Jews racism lands on Jews. Its own definition objects to "the continuity" of a Jewish state, and the working definition of antisemitism adopted by the UK Government gives, as an example, "claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor". The Prime Minister has called the motion antisemitic, and the party has been referred to the Equality and Human Rights Commission over it. If the Sheffield Greens do not hold the motion's view, one sentence says so: Zionism is not racism.
"We've built a productive relationship with Sheffield Labour to deliver for the people of this city."
Nobody disputes the record on buses, adult social care and renewable energy. But a good record on one thing does not answer a question about another. The answer to Labour's ultimatum is one sentence, and it does not need a coalition meeting to say it.
The motion, line by line The Star: Sheffield Greens hit back at Labour ultimatum
In the news · Jewish News · 2 November 2026
Labour ends the joint administration: "Our trust in Sheffield Greens is completely broken"
Jewish News reported that Sheffield's Labour leader, Cllr Fran Belbin, confirmed the end of the council's power-sharing agreement with the Greens, with a Labour minority administration to be put forward at Wednesday's full council meeting. She said: "Our trust in Sheffield Greens is completely broken. Their refusal to stand up for Jewish citizens with whom some of their councillors disagree, the public interviews with Cllrs Dimond and Raouf, and their ongoing misrepresentation of Sheffield Labour's views and stated positions have all contributed to that breakdown of trust."
The Green group leader, Cllr Angela Argenzio, was quoted: "If Labour chooses to destabilise Sheffield City Council over this, Labour owns the consequences." These are Cllr Belbin's and Cllr Argenzio's words; this page records only what the councillor named on it has said.
In the news · Sheffield Labour · 2 November 2026
Labour's leader publishes the full account: "The trust is broken", and a Labour minority administration goes to full council on 4 November
Sheffield Labour published a statement by the council leader, Cllr Fran Belbin, on why Labour is ending the joint administration with the Greens, with the letters exchanged. It says the majority of Sheffield Green councillors did not support the motion, that the Green leader, Cllr Argenzio, "like Zack Polanski, avoided the vote", and that "three of their councillors, including two committee chairs, have very publicly supported it: Cllrs Dimond, Raouf and Ahmed". Labour's "bottom line" was two points, "that not all Zionists are racists and that self-determination is the right of the peoples of Palestine and Israel"; Cllr Belbin "would have settled for the first".
"Our trust in Sheffield Greens is completely broken," the statement says. "Zionism actually takes many forms, including secular, socialist and anti-racist, and the majority of our Jewish population are vehemently opposed to Israel's actions in Gaza." These are Cllr Belbin's words; this page records only what the councillor named on it has said. The statement is reproduced in full on this site's news page.
In the news · Sheffield Green Councillor Group, on Facebook · 2 November 2026
The Green group answers Labour: the ultimatum "came from Labour HQ in London" and "the door remains open"; the statement does not mention the motion
The Sheffield Green Councillor Group answered Labour's account on Facebook the same day. "Labour's ultimatum was never really about the conduct of Green Councillors in Sheffield, who are wholeheartedly committed to this city. It came from Labour HQ in London and is a really troubling attack on local democracy." It says Greens won more votes than any other party in Sheffield in May, that "the door remains open", and that "Labour owns the consequences".
It ends: "We do not, and will not, conflate Zionism with Judaism, or anti-Zionism with antisemitism. We are an anti-racist party and we stand with all of Sheffield's communities, as we always have." The statement does not name the motion or say whether the group supports or rejects it. It is the group's statement; this page records only what the councillor named on it has said.
Read the story in Sheffield Green Councillor Group, on Facebook
In the news · Cllr Mark Rusling, on Facebook · 2 November 2026
Labour's Cllr Rusling sets out seven reasons: the local Greens "have chosen the most extreme path within their party"
Cllr Mark Rusling, Labour councillor for Shiregreen and Brightside, posted seven reasons for ending the joint administration. "The Green Party now deems anybody who thinks that there should be a Jewish state to be racist," he wrote, and of the Sheffield group: "the local party have rejected that and have chosen an approach which is far more extreme than their sister parties across the country." Of its leader's line that "Jewish people should not be persecuted": "a truly incredible statement".
"At no point have the Sheffield Green Party addressed our concerns: ensuring the safety of the Sheffield Jewish community, understanding that their approach fails to recognise the real racists and supporting self-determination." These are Cllr Rusling's words; this page records only what the councillor named on it has said.
In the news · The Star, Sheffield · 28 October 2026
The Green group's joint statement: the motion "has caused some concern"; it does not say whether they support it
The Star reported that Sheffield's Green councillors released a joint statement on 27 October, the day Labour's council leader, Cllr Fran Belbin, said she had been speaking to Jewish communities who are "deeply afraid of rising antisemitism and the impact of crass over-simplification of complex issues".
The councillors wrote: "We acknowledge that our party's motion on Zionism has caused some concern and we recognise that this is a deeply sensitive issue. We take those concerns seriously." They wrote: "We reject anti-Jewish racism and prejudice. This has been and will always be the case. We believe that Jewish people should not be persecuted," and that they are "in dialogue with Jewish individuals, groups and community leaders in Sheffield". The statement does not say whether they support the motion or reject it, which is the condition Labour set on 15 October for the joint administration to continue.
In the news · The Star, Sheffield · 26 October 2026
Ten days on, the Green group has still not rejected the motion
The Star reported that, ten days after the Green group refused Labour's ultimatum, neither party had said whether their joint administration of Sheffield City Council would continue. Labour's condition, set by the council leader Cllr Fran Belbin on 15 October, is that the Greens "publicly reject" the motion.
If the arrangement ends, Labour could run the council as a minority, and Green councillors could lose the chairs of the housing and adult health and social care committees. An update was expected "in the next couple of days".
In the news · The Star, Sheffield · 16 October 2026
The Green group refuses Labour's ultimatum to reject the motion
The Star reported that Sheffield's Labour leader, Cllr Fran Belbin, called the motion "shameful and antisemitic" and said the joint Labour and Green administration would not continue unless the Greens publicly rejected it.
The Green group's leader, Cllr Angela Argenzio, answered with an open letter. She did not reject the motion. She wrote that "you know that the Green Councillors are not antisemitic" and that "conflating Zionism with Judaism is itself antisemitic", and warned: "If Labour chooses to destabilise Sheffield City Council over this, Labour owns the consequences."
The Star also reported that the Prime Minister, Labour's chair Bridget Phillipson and the South Yorkshire Mayor, Oliver Coppard, have said Labour will not work with the Greens while they hold the position.
In the news · The Guardian · 15 October 2026
Labour tells its groups to end local agreements with Greens who do not reject the motion; this council is on the Guardian's list
The Guardian reported that Labour's chair, Bridget Phillipson, told Labour groups sharing power with the Greens to review their agreements and end them unless their Green partners reject the motion. Greens would be asked "to make clear that they reject this position and to call on their national leadership to reconsider"; where they cannot, "Labour will bring any such local arrangement to an end."
The Guardian listed this council among the 18 affected. A Green Party spokesperson answered that "trying to tell local parties what to do and who they can work with is undemocratic."
On 4 October 2026 the Green Party of England and Wales declared that Zionism is racism, in its racist motion. Councillor Douglas Johnson has taken no public position on it: their name is not in the motion's printed lists of supporters, they have not signed the councillors' pledge against it, and they have not left the party over it.
Zionism is not racism. It is the belief that Jews have a right to a homeland in their ancestral land, held by most British Jews. A councillor whose party has declared that belief racism owes the Jewish residents of City ward, Sheffield an answer: do they support the motion, will they call publicly for it to be reversed, and will they resign if the party keeps it?
Cllr Johnson, is this you? Put your position on the record in a minute: sign the pledge with your council email, and this page stops asking people to email you the same day.
Email Cllr Johnson
A ready-written email, worded differently every time, asking Cllr Johnson where they stand on the “Zionism is Racism” motion and to join the four MPs in speaking out: reverse it or resign. It goes straight to their council address, with Zack Polanski, the Green Party leader copied in. You see every word before you send it from your own email app.
Your email to Cllr Douglas Johnson
No name added, so remember to replace "[Your name]" at the bottom of the message with your own name before you send.
- To
- CC
-
Zack Polanski, the Green Party leader, so the party sees it too.
- BCC
-
Our stats mailbox. It counts emails and discards them. How we handle this.
Nothing opening? Press "Copy everything" and paste it into a new email.
Share this page
The other Green councillors on Sheffield
Email the Green councillors on Sheffield
- Cllr Alexi Dimond, Gleadless Valley backed the motion
- Cllr Angela Argenzio, Broomhill and Sharrow Vale
- Cllr Brian Holmshaw, Broomhill and Sharrow Vale
- Cllr Christine Gilligan Kubo, Hillsborough
- Cllr Lynsey Angell, Nether Edge and Sharrow
- Cllr Maia Salman-Lord, City
- Cllr Maleiki Haybe, Broomhill and Sharrow Vale
- Cllr Marieanne Elliot, Gleadless Valley
- Cllr Maroof Raouf, Nether Edge and Sharrow backed the motion
- Cllr Mustafa Ahmed, Burngreave
- Cllr Paul Turpin, Gleadless Valley
- Cllr Peter Gilbert, Ecclesall
- Cllr Richard Tinsley, Hillsborough
- Cllr Ruth Abbey, Manor Castle
- Cllr Ruth Mersereau, City
- Cllr Tessa Lupton, Ecclesall
- Cllr Toby Mallinson, Hillsborough
- Cllr Tom Atkin-Withers, Graves Park
Keep going
Every Green councillor's position Every Green councillor, by council Email more Green councillors These councillors say Zionism is racism
