
Roger Harmer is a Liberal Democrat councillor for Acocks Green ward on Birmingham City Council, in the West Midlands. Cllr Roger Harmer has not endorsed the campaign that Zionism is not racism yet.
At Birmingham City Council, November 2026
Asked to make Birmingham's Greens reject the motion, the Leader of the Council answers with the coalition agreement
At Birmingham City Council's full council meeting, Cllr Jex Parkin, the Reform UK group leader, asked Cllr Roger Harmer, the Liberal Democrat Leader of the Council, to make Birmingham's Green councillors publicly reject the Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion, as Sir Ed Davey has asked. Cllr Harmer first answered with the Fairer Birmingham Partnership Agreement. Here is the clip, with a transcript, and what was said next.
What is said, and what followed
"My party remains focused on delivering the commitments"
The first answer, in the clip, speaks of the coalition agreement and not of the motion. Cllr Parkin's reply: "he hasn't answered the question at all."
"I did say I disagree with that motion"
The clip ends before Cllr Harmer's second answer. The Birmingham Mail reported it on 7 November: "I think he should actually listen to my answer. I did say I disagree with that motion. But the Green Party has made clear that nothing in that motion will change their commitment to the Fairer Birmingham Partnership Agreement. Therefore it stands and we will continue in this administration to deliver it."
What Ed Davey asked
The Liberal Democrat leader's letter of 19 October asks Liberal Democrat leaders who work with Green councillors to put "a clear demand" to them: "publicly reject this motion, and commit to campaigning for its reversal." Birmingham's Green group has not said whether it backs or rejects the motion. In this campaign's view, the Leader of the Council saying the motion is wrong is welcome; the demand Ed Davey asked for has not been made in public.
Read the transcript
An automatic transcript of the clip, corrected for the name of the Fairer Birmingham Partnership Agreement and of Solihull. Cllr Harmer's first answer is cut short in the clip, and the clip ends before the second. The times are approximate, and the video is above so you can check every word against it.
0:00 Cllr Parkin: The deputy leader of your own party has condemned the Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion as both horrific and antisemitic. Sir Ed Davey has called upon Liberal Democrats governing with Greens in local government to insist that their Green Party partners publicly reject the motion and actively campaign for its reversal. So will you now do exactly as your party leader has asked, and make sure that Birmingham's Green councillors do exactly that?
0:28 Cllr Harmer: My party remains focused on delivering the commitments set out in the Fairer Birmingham Partnership Agreement, to improve the lives of people across our city. Our agreement is a local agreement between the Liberal Democrats and the Green Party ...
0:46 Cllr Parkin: Thank you, Lord Mayor. And you can tell he's a proper politician these days, because he hasn't answered the question at all. You can't hide behind the Fairer Birmingham Partnership Agreement. As a matter of fact, that motion passed at that Green Party conference, and the way that they intended to deliver it through local government, it's what they said they were going to do, directly contravenes the agreement that you are referring to. And let's be clear about this in local government: the Greens in Solihull, Broadland and Cherwell have already rejected or condemned this policy.
1:16 The Lord Mayor: Can you ask a question?
1:17 Cllr Parkin: I'm getting to the question. The Board of Deputies of British Jews voted 118 to 1 to declare the Green Party a racist party following the adoption ... So I'll get to the question. Why won't he condemn it? Has he not got the bottle, or does he simply not care about that motion? Thank you, Lord Mayor.
In the news
3 news stories naming Cllr Roger Harmer
- Birmingham's Liberal Democrat leader, pressed in the chamber by Reform: "I did say I disagree with that motion." The coalition with the Greens standsBirmingham Mail (Local Democracy Reporting Service)
- Three Birmingham MPs and four peers tell the council's Leader: make your Green cabinet members disown the motion, or end the power-sharing agreementAl Carns MP and Preet Kaur Gill MP, on Facebook
- Birmingham's Liberal Democrat leader stands by his Green coalition partners while Ed Davey calls the motion "dangerous and antisemitic"; the Conservatives call it "an impossible contradiction"ITV News Central
Says Zionism is racism, on the record
As reported by ITV News Central on 21 October 2026, Cllr Roger Harmer said:
“We made a local partnership agreement to work with other political groups to provide stability for Birmingham and improve services to our residents. The Liberal Democrats and our partners remain fully committed to that agreement.”
Leader of Birmingham City Council, which the Liberal Democrats run in partnership with the Green group and independents. Said two days after his party's leader, Sir Ed Davey, called the motion "dangerous and antisemitic", ruled out any national partnership with the Greens and asked Liberal Democrat council leaders to demand that their Green partners publicly reject the motion. At least two of Birmingham's Green councillors backed it. Whether Birmingham's Greens will be asked to reject it, he did not say. On 22 October 2026 three of Birmingham's Labour MPs, Al Carns, Jess Phillips and Preet Kaur Gill, with four peers, wrote to him asking him to seek a public statement from the Greens in his cabinet disowning the motion, or to end the power-sharing agreement at once; the letter is on this site at /letters/birmingham-mps-letter.
What Cllr Roger Harmer said, and why it is wrong
Two days earlier his own party's leader, Sir Ed Davey, had called the motion "dangerous and antisemitic", ruled out any national partnership with the Greens, and asked Liberal Democrat council leaders to demand that their Green partners publicly reject it. At least two of Birmingham's Green councillors backed the motion. Asked about them, the leader of the council spoke of stability and services, and did not say whether they would be asked to reject it.
Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, including many who are fierce critics of Israeli governments.
A council partnership is a choice, renewed every day it continues. Birmingham's Jewish residents are entitled to know whether the Green councillors who help run their city will say the belief of most British Jews is not racism, and whether their council's leader will ask them to. Stability is not an answer to that question.
At a glance
- Party
- Liberal Democrats
- Council
- Birmingham
- Ward
- Acocks Green
- County
- West Midlands county
- Region
- West Midlands
- The campaign
- Says Zionism is racism
- Official page
- Birmingham website
Questions and answers
Who is Roger Harmer?
Roger Harmer is a Liberal Democrat councillor for Acocks Green ward on Birmingham City Council, in the West Midlands. Listed as Liberal Democrats.
Has Cllr Roger Harmer endorsed the campaign that Zionism is not racism?
Not yet. Councillors and MPs of every party in England and Wales are being asked to put their names to one sentence: "Zionism is not racism. I call on the Green Party to reverse its "Zionism is Racism" motion." Not having signed it does not mean someone supports the Green Party's motion: they may not have been asked yet.
What is the Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion?
On 4 October 2026 the Green Party of England and Wales passed a motion declaring that "Zionism is racism". It brands as racism the belief, held by most British Jews, that the Jewish people have the right to a homeland of their own, and binds the party to treat that belief "as any other form of racism". Councillors and MPs of every other party are being asked to say, in public, that Zionism is not racism.
Who are the other councillors for Acocks Green?
Cllr Penny Wagg (Liberal Democrat). Each has a page saying where they stand.
How can I ask Cllr Roger Harmer to endorse it?
Use the button on this page: it opens a short email to Cllr Roger Harmer in your own email app, with the link to sign. Nothing is sent until you press send.
Other councillors on Birmingham City Council
- 1 endorsed
- 17 spoke out against the motion
- 2 Green, backed the motion
- 2 say Zionism is racism
- 19 Green councillors in all
Cllr Danny CarterEndorsed
Cllr Adam HiggsSpoke out
Cllr Alex YipSpoke out
Cllr Anja PawsonSpoke out
Cllr David PearsSpoke out
Cllr Deirdre AldenSpoke out
Cllr Gareth MooreSpoke out
Cllr Harry ParmarSpoke out
Cllr Jex ParkinSpoke out
Cllr John CooperSpoke out
Cllr John PerksSpoke out
Cllr Ken WoodSpoke out
Cllr Matt BennettSpoke out
Cllr Meirion JenkinsSpoke out
Cllr Raaj ShamjiSpoke out
Cllr Richard ParkinSpoke out
Cllr Robert AldenSpoke out
Cllr Timothy HuxtableSpoke out
Cllr Duncan AliGreenBacked the motion
Cllr Kamel HawwashGreenBacked the motion
Cllr Ali KaziGreenSays Zionism is racism
Cllr Mansoor QureshiGreenSays Zionism is racism
Cllr Atikur RahmanGreen
Cllr Chris GarghanGreen
Cllr Corinne FowlerGreen
Cllr Ed FreshwaterGreen
Cllr Hamzah SheikhGreen
Cllr Haroon SalimGreen
Cllr Jane BastonGreen
Cllr Joe PeacockGreen
Cllr Jordan PhillipGreen
Cllr Julien PritchardGreen
Cllr Kevin CarmodyGreen
Cllr Raheem HumphreysGreen
Cllr Rob GrantGreen
Cllr Roxanne GreenGreen
Cllr Siobhan Harper-NunesGreen
Cllr Abdul Shumon
Cllr Adnan Hussain
Cllr Amar Khan
Cllr Anthony Ward
Cllr Arshid Mahmood
Cllr Baber Baz
Cllr Bushra Bi
Cllr Charlie Latchford
Cllr Cherie Waddingham
Cllr Christopher Steele
Cllr Darren Colling
Cllr Deborah Harries
Cllr Diane Donaldson
Cllr Eddie Freeman
Cllr Gemma Guttridge
Cllr George Hall
Cllr Glyn Marston
Cllr Graham Green
Cllr Harris Khaliq
Cllr Izzy Knowles
Cllr James Hinton
Cllr Jamil Khan
Cllr Jess Ankrett
Cllr John Lambert
Cllr Majid Mahmood
Cllr Manni Butt
Cllr Mansuur Ahmed
Cllr Marcus Bernasconi
Cllr Martin Brooks
Cllr Martin McAuley
Cllr Martin Smith
Cllr Mick Brown
Cllr Mohammed Saeed
Cllr Morriam Jan
Cllr Mumtaz Hussain
Cllr Nagu Penakacherla
Cllr Narinder Kooner
Cllr Nicky Brennan
Cllr Nosheen Khalid
Cllr Penny Wagg
Cllr Philip Mills
Cllr Rachel Conaghan
Cllr Raihaan Abbas
Cllr Rajbir Singh
Cllr Randeep Kular
Cllr Rashad Mahmood
Cllr Rasheda Begum
Cllr Ray Goodwin
Cllr Rebecca Waters
Cllr Rinkal Shergill
Cllr Saddak Miah
Cllr Sam Forsyth
Cllr Sarina Younas
Cllr Shafique Shah
Cllr Shaukat Ali Khan
Cllr Shaukat Mahmood
Cllr Shehryar Kayani
Cllr Shuranjeet SinghCllr Siobhan Harper-Nunes
Cllr Su Brooks
Cllr Sue Willetts
Cllr Taj Uddin
Cllr Zaker Choudhry
From the public record: the council's published details, and endorsements made on this site. Something wrong? Tell us.