Birmingham Mail (Local Democracy Reporting Service)
At a full meeting of Birmingham City Council, Cllr Jex Parkin, leader of the Reform UK group, asked Cllr Roger Harmer, the Liberal Democrat Leader of the Council, to do what Sir Ed Davey had asked of Liberal Democrats governing with Greens: "insist that their Green Party partners publicly reject the motion and actively campaign for its reversal".
What was reported
Will you now do as exactly as your party leader has asked and make sure that Birmingham's Green councillors do exactly that? Cllr Harmer answered that the Fairer Birmingham Partnership Agreement, which binds the Liberal Democrats, the Greens and independents in the administration, is not a merger of political parties and each party continues to hold and express its own national policies and positions, and that no alternative administration could be credibly formed.
Cllr Harmer disagrees with the motion, the report says, and is firmly committed to a two-state solution: But be in no doubt, Birmingham Greens also remain firmly committed to the FBPA and will not seek to change any aspect of it as a result of the motion passed. Cllr Parkin: Why won't he condemn it? Has he not got the bottle or does he simply not care about that motion?
“But be in no doubt, Birmingham Greens also remain firmly committed to the FBPA and will not seek to change any aspect of it as a result of the motion passed.”
Cllr Harmer: I think he should actually listen to my answer. I did say I disagree with that motion. Birmingham Green Party's statement, issued in October, says its councillors stand against rising antisemitism and that Jewish residents have an absolute right to feel safe and valued in a city they helped to build.
It does not say whether the group backs the motion or rejects it.
"Why won't he condemn it?" Cllr Parkin asks Birmingham's Leader to do what Ed Davey asked of Liberal Democrats who govern with Greens
At Birmingham City Council's full council meeting, Cllr Jex Parkin, the Reform UK group leader, asked the Liberal Democrat Leader of the Council, Cllr Roger Harmer, to make Birmingham's Green councillors publicly reject the Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion, as Sir Ed Davey has asked of Liberal Democrats who govern with Greens. Here is the clip, with a transcript, and the facts around it.
Birmingham City Council, full council, as shared on Facebook (1 min 39 s). Shown in full for reporting and comment.
What is said, and the facts around it
1
"Sir Ed Davey has called upon Liberal Democrats governing with Greens"
He has. In his letter of 19 October to the Board of Deputies and the Jewish Leadership Council, the Liberal Democrat leader wrote that where Liberal Democrat council groups work with Green councillors, "we are asking their leaders to put a clear demand to those Green Party councillors: publicly reject this motion, and commit to campaigning for its reversal."
2
"The Greens in Solihull, Broadland and Cherwell"
This site records each. Solihull's Green group leader wrote on 27 October, "I disagree with it", in a statement all Solihull's Green councillors endorsed. Cherwell's Green group "publicly rejected" the motion and said it would "support efforts to have that policy reversed". Broadland's four Green councillors were given a deadline by their Labour partners to denounce it. Birmingham's Green group has not said whether it backs or rejects the motion, and four of its councillors have backed it in public.
3
"The Board of Deputies of British Jews voted 118 to 1"
On 25 October the Board voted by 118 to 1 that the Green Party had "become a racist party", and called on other parties to enter into no coalition or pact with the Greens unless the Green leadership in that place rejects the policy.
4
"Why won't he condemn it?"
The clip ends before Cllr Harmer's second answer. The Birmingham Mail reported it on 7 November: "I think he should actually listen to my answer. I did say I disagree with that motion. But the Green Party has made clear that nothing in that motion will change their commitment to the Fairer Birmingham Partnership Agreement. Therefore it stands and we will continue in this administration to deliver it."
Read the transcript
An automatic transcript of the clip, corrected for the name of the Fairer Birmingham Partnership Agreement and of Solihull. Cllr Harmer's first answer is cut short in the clip, and the clip ends before the second. The times are approximate, and the video is above so you can check every word against it.
0:00Cllr Parkin: The deputy leader of your own party has condemned the Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion as both horrific and antisemitic. Sir Ed Davey has called upon Liberal Democrats governing with Greens in local government to insist that their Green Party partners publicly reject the motion and actively campaign for its reversal. So will you now do exactly as your party leader has asked, and make sure that Birmingham's Green councillors do exactly that?
0:28Cllr Harmer: My party remains focused on delivering the commitments set out in the Fairer Birmingham Partnership Agreement, to improve the lives of people across our city. Our agreement is a local agreement between the Liberal Democrats and the Green Party ...
0:46Cllr Parkin: Thank you, Lord Mayor. And you can tell he's a proper politician these days, because he hasn't answered the question at all. You can't hide behind the Fairer Birmingham Partnership Agreement. As a matter of fact, that motion passed at that Green Party conference, and the way that they intended to deliver it through local government, it's what they said they were going to do, directly contravenes the agreement that you are referring to. And let's be clear about this in local government: the Greens in Solihull, Broadland and Cherwell have already rejected or condemned this policy.
1:16The Lord Mayor: Can you ask a question?
1:17Cllr Parkin: I'm getting to the question. The Board of Deputies of British Jews voted 118 to 1 to declare the Green Party a racist party following the adoption ... So I'll get to the question. Why won't he condemn it? Has he not got the bottle, or does he simply not care about that motion? Thank you, Lord Mayor.
A summary by the Zionism Is Not Racism campaign of what Birmingham Mail (Local Democracy Reporting Service) published, with the quotations as published there.