"Sheffield first, not Israel-Palestine": Cllr Jack Byrom asks how much weight the council's ethical procurement policy will carry in its banking tender
From Cllr Jack Byrom, on Facebook
When
19 November 2026
Where
Sheffield City Council
Party
Reform UK
Source
Cllr Jack Byrom, on Facebook
Cllr Jack Byrom, the Reform UK councillor for Richmond ward on Sheffield City Council, posted a clip from this week's Finance Committee, where the council's banking contract with Barclays was discussed again.
What happened
For some time now, prominent pro-Palestinian activists have regularly attended these committee meetings to demand that the council sever ties with Barclays due to the bank's alleged links with the Israeli government, he wrote.
The council has confirmed it is going out to tender on the contract and will be incorporating its new ethical procurement policy, he wrote, which includes clauses on profiting from unlawful armed conflict, unlawful occupation/exploitation of contested territory. In the committee he asked: What weighting will be given to this ethical procurement policy?
“For some time now, prominent pro-Palestinian activists have regularly attended these committee meetings to demand that the council sever ties with Barclays due to the bank's alleged links with the Israeli government,”
The officers gave no figure. Jane Wilby said the weighting is deliberately not in there, because actually we want time to work that through; a second officer said it wouldn't be proper to include a percentage at this time, and that the council would get the best deal for the city while complying with its policies and the law.
Cllr Byrom wrote: In my view, the council has bowed to pressure from these protesters. Once again, the council is prioritising issues in the Middle East over focusing on what is best for the people of Sheffield and ensuring we get the best value and service for local taxpayers. He said he would keep a very close eye on the tender process and was determined to get a clear answer on exactly how much weight this new policy will be given.
At Sheffield City Council's Finance Committee, November 2026
"What weighting will be given to this ethical procurement policy?" Cllr Byrom on the council's banking contract
At Sheffield City Council's Finance Committee this week, Cllr Jack Byrom, the Reform UK councillor for Richmond, asked how much weight the council's new ethical procurement policy will carry when it puts its banking contract, now held by Barclays, out to tender. Here is the clip as he posted it on 19 November, with a transcript, and the facts around it.
Sheffield City Council, Finance Committee webcast, as posted on Facebook by Cllr Jack Byrom, 19 November 2026 (1 min 59 s). Shown in full for reporting and comment.
What is said, and the facts around it
1
"What weighting will be given to this ethical procurement policy?"
Cllr Byrom says he has asked before. The council is going out to tender on its banking contract, he wrote, and "will be incorporating its new ethical procurement policy", which includes clauses on "profiting from unlawful armed conflict, unlawful occupation/exploitation of contested territory".
2
"We deliberately haven't put that in"
The officers did not give a figure. Jane Wilby told the committee the paper asks only for permission to approach the market, and that the weighting is "deliberately not in there, because actually we want time to work that through", looking at what other councils have done. A second officer said it "wouldn't be proper to include a percentage at this time".
3
"The best deal for the city"
Both officers said the tender must give value for taxpayers' money while "complying with the policies that we currently have, as well as the legislation". How the two are balanced has not been decided, and Cllr Byrom says he will keep asking.
4
Why it is being asked
In his post Cllr Byrom writes that pro-Palestinian activists "have regularly attended these committee meetings to demand that the council sever ties with Barclays due to the bank's alleged links with the Israeli government", and that in his view "the council has bowed to pressure from these protesters". That is his view. The council has not said the policy is aimed at any bank or any country.
Read the transcript
An automatic transcript of the clip, corrected for names and spelling, with the speakers as the webcast's own captions name them. The second officer is not captioned in the clip. The times are approximate, and a half-finished sentence is marked with dots. The video is above, so you can check every word against it.
0:00Cllr Byrom: Thank you, Chair. I think members already know my views on this issue, and I think we all know why it is being brought to this committee. Procurement should always be driven by what's best for Sheffield and its taxpayers. I won't get into what's happened with the council over recent weeks, but I know I have asked this previously: what weighting will be given to this ethical procurement policy?
0:24Cllr Elle Dodd, in the chair: Do you want to answer that question directly, or do you want me to take some more questions?
0:28Jane Wilby: I'm happy to start giving a response. ... There's probably a multi-part response that Glenn can offer you on how the ethical procurement policy will be reflected in the procurement. So what I would say is ... the point of this paper is to say: permission to go and approach the market and determine the best procurement strategy for the council, as you rightly say, to provide the best services for taxpayers' money, providing value for money.
0:59Jane Wilby: So we deliberately haven't put that in. Further work will now take place to understand what we think that is, as part of the quality part of the evaluation criteria. So that's deliberately not in there, because actually we want time to work that through. We can look at other councils and what they've done and what they've deemed as appropriate and how that's come forward. Clearly it interfaces with the ethical procurement policy, which Glenn's done quite a lot of work on.
1:25A council officer: I'd just like to add, in terms of the percentage, actually Jane is right, that it wouldn't be proper to include a percentage at this time. However, what you need to ensure is that the percentage that we do use for quality over price, or the ratio between the two, needs to be conventional. In terms of getting the best deal for the city, that's what we will do, also adhering to the policies and complying with the policies that we currently have, as well as the legislation. So we will definitely ensure that whatever ratio is used will work for us ...