- When
- 4 November 2026
- Where
- Sheffield City Council
- Party
- Labour
- Source
- Cllr Fran Belbin, on Facebook
Cllr Fran Belbin, the Labour Leader of Sheffield City Council, posted a statement on Facebook on 4 November.
What was reported
Last night, Sheffield Greens issued a new statement which addressed some of the things we have been asking for,
it says. By confirming that Zionism is not inherently racist, and that they believe in self determination for all peoples, we are content that the Sheffield Greens have distanced themselves from the most divisive elements of their party conference motion.
After genuinely constructive discussions
, she writes, I believe there is now a basis on which Labour and the Greens can continue to work together in Sheffield
, with a fuller joint statement in the coming days
.
“a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital, equal rights for all, and the right of return for Palestinians and their descendants.”
The statement is reproduced in full below. The Liberal Democrat group leader, Cllr Martin Smith, had said earlier in the day: This is an extraordinary U-turn and a shameful abandonment of principle by Labour. Just days ago, Labour were telling us that trust with the Greens was completely broken and that they could no longer work together. Now they've decided to carry on as if nothing happened.
Set against the record, Cllr Belbin's statement contradicts it in five places.
First, the Sheffield Greens' statement of the night before, published by Sheffield Green Party on Facebook on 3 November and carried in full on this site, does not contain the words Zionism is not inherently racist
, or self determination
, or any sentence about Zionism at all. It says Labour's Cllr Mark Rusling is plainly lying
, that Labour has created chaos
and political games
, that a complaint has been lodged against Cllr Rusling with the council's Monitoring Officer, and that at conference members voted for a motion calling for the establishment of a state where people of all faiths and ethnicities, including Jews, Muslims and Christians can live together
.
The Star (Rose Mason, Local Democracy Reporting Service) reported later on 4 November what the new statement
was: a comment on Facebook. It's Our City!, the group that campaigned to move the council to a committee system, tagged Cllr Belbin in a post on the Tuesday evening; Cllr Belbin replied that she would be happy to discuss her concerns if the Greens were; and the Green group's deputy leader, Cllr Alexi Dimond, answered: We do recognise there is a diversity of beliefs among people who identify as Zionists, and accept that some people who identify as Zionists disagree with the ideology of political Zionism as practiced by the Israeli state and are not racist.
He suggested a meeting at 10.30 the next morning. That comment is the whole of it, as far as has been published: not a statement by the Green group, not the words Zionism is not inherently racist
, and not the sentence Labour asked for. It says that some Zionists, those who disagree with the ideology of political Zionism as practiced by the Israeli state
, are not racist, which leaves the rest, the nine in ten British Jews who believe Israel should exist, where the motion put them.
And it comes from the councillor who said on video on 26 October: Nobody can say that that is not racist, and that is not racism.
Second, on 2 November Cllr Belbin's bottom line was two points, that not all Zionists are racists and that self-determination is the right of the peoples of Palestine and Israel
. Self determination for all peoples
does not name Israel, and the motion the Sheffield Greens have not rejected calls for a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine
, which leaves no Israel to determine anything.
Third, Zionism is not inherently racist
is the opposite of what the party's policy says and what Sheffield's Green councillors have said: the motion declares the Green Party an anti-Zionist party
; Cllr Raouf said on 21 October, Zionism is racism, that is Green Party policy as of now
; Cllrs Dimond, Raouf and Ahmed signed the open letter supporting it; and a statement by a council group does not change the party's policy, which stands.
Fourth, on 2 November Cllr Belbin wrote that our trust in Sheffield Greens is completely broken
; the Greens answered by calling her councillor a liar and lodging a complaint against him; and on 4 November the discussions were genuinely constructive
.
Fifth, the Sheffield Green Party statement describes the motion as calling for a state where people of all faiths and ethnicities, including Jews, Muslims and Christians can live together in freedom, equality and peace
. Resolution 3 of the motion, which it does not quote, reads: a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital, equal rights for all, and the right of return for Palestinians and their descendants.
Cllr Belbin's statement in full
As Leader, my priority is to bring people together to do what is right for Sheffield.
Over the last few weeks I have been very clear about my concerns over the Green Party conference motion on "Zionism is Racism", and about the impact this has had on communities in our city.
But where progress is made, it is important to recognise it. Last night, Sheffield Greens issued a new statement which addressed some of the things we have been asking for.
By confirming that Zionism is not inherently racist, and that they believe in self determination for all peoples, we are content that the Sheffield Greens have distanced themselves from the most divisive elements of their party conference motion which was causing such concern to our communities, most notably our Jewish residents.
Today, we have had genuinely constructive discussions about how we move forward.
Those discussions have made significant progress. As a result, I believe there is now a basis on which Labour and the Greens can continue to work together in Sheffield.
We will issue a fuller joint statement in the coming days following further discussions.
The council I lead will continue to oppose racism in all its forms, and deliver change that residents can see and feel, in their pocket, in their neighbourhoods, and in the opportunities for them to thrive.








