- When
- 3 November 2026
- Where
- Sheffield City Council
- Party
- Green Party
- Source
- Sheffield Green Party, on Facebook
Sheffield Green Party posted on Facebook today, the day The Star printed Cllr Mark Rusling's "seven reasons" for Labour ending the joint administration.
What happened
Labour Councillor Mark Rusling has claimed that the Green Party 'voted for the elimination of Israel by violent means.' We want to be clear, this is completely untrue. Mark is plainly lying here,
it says. There have been no calls for violence, military action or the violent removal of any state from the Green Party.
At conference, it says, members voted for a motion calling for the establishment of a state where people of all faiths and ethnicities, including Jews, Muslims and Christians can live together in freedom, equality and peace.
The party says a complaint has been lodged with the council's Monitoring Officer, urges Cllr Rusling to apologise for lying
, and asks The Star for a correction.
“the Green Party supports the establishment of a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital, equal rights for all, and the right of return for Palestinians and their descendants.”
This site carries the motion, Zionism is Racism
, clause by clause, and has checked the post against it. Resolution 3 of the motion reads: the Green Party supports the establishment of a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital, equal rights for all, and the right of return for Palestinians and their descendants.
The words faiths
, Jews
, Muslims
, Christians
, freedom
and peace
are not in that resolution. Palestinian
, all of historic Palestine
and the right of return for Palestinians and their descendants
are, and the post leaves them out. A single Palestinian state in all of historic Palestine is a state in place of Israel.
The motion does not use the word elimination
, and the party is right that it does not. On violent means
, Resolution 4 reads: The Green Party affirms the Palestinian people's inalienable right to self-determination, including the right of the Palestinian people to resistance and liberation from Israeli occupation, domination and subjugation, and acknowledges that the struggle to achieve that liberation by all available means under international law is legitimate.
The motion's own briefing paper, section 9, quotes the UN General Assembly resolution it rests on, which speaks of liberation by all available means, including armed struggle
, and says: This legal principle underpins this motion's affirmation of Palestinian rights.
The motion's proposer, Lubna Speitan, told Greens for Palestine's stream on 4 August: a right of all oppressed people to resist their oppressors by all available means. And some may have argued, bringing this to the Green Party, where they consider nonviolence. I mean, we've done nonviolence for decades.
So the motion resolves on one Palestinian state in all of historic Palestine, and affirms the struggle for it by all available means
, which its own briefing paper spells out as including armed struggle. Cllr Rusling's sentence is his summary of those two resolutions.
The post in full
You may have seen on Facebook and in the press today that Labour Councillor Mark Rusling has claimed that the Green Party “voted for the elimination of Israel by violent means.” We want to be clear, this is completely untrue. Mark is plainly lying here.
There have been no calls for violence, military action or the violent removal of any state from the Green Party.
This is a desperate attempt by Labour to distract from the chaos they have created on Sheffield City Council, which will harm ordinary Sheffield residents and confidence in Sheffield Council, and undermine the democratic process.
The Sheffield Green Party has consistently called for an end to the genocide which Israel is inflicting on the people of Gaza, with the help of the Labour Government. At the Green Party autumn conference members voted for a motion calling for the establishment of a state where people of all faiths and ethnicities, including Jews, Muslims and Christians can live together in freedom, equality and peace.
We urge Councillor Mark Rusling to reflect on what he has said and withdraw his false comments, apologise for lying, and start delivering for Sheffield’s residents.
We urge Labour group leader Fran Belbin to consider what actions need to be taken to keep her Councillors honest on their public platforms. Is it lies like these that led to Cllr Belbin's council chaos decision? Let's hope, for the future of our council, that Labour have some more honest voices in their group.
A complaint has been lodged with the council’s Monitoring Officer as Cllr Rusling's statements clearly go against the Nolan Principle of honesty that all councillors should follow.
It’s also disappointing that The Star has chosen to uncritically print Cllr Rusling’s lies in today’s paper, and we hope they will issue a correction.
Now, we're getting back to the hard work we do every day to deliver for the people of Sheffield. We, like everyone in Sheffield, are tired of Labour's political games and just want to see our city move forward.









