- When
- 20 November 2026
- Where
- Solihull Council
- Party
- Green Party
- Source
- Cllr Samantha Gethen, letter to Cllr Max McLoughlin
Cllr Samantha Gethen, Leader of the Opposition on Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council for Reform UK, wrote on 20 November to Cllr Max McLoughlin, leader of the council's Green group, asking him to withdraw the whip from Cllr Alison Wilson, Green councillor for Shirley West, "today", and to refer her to the Green Party for expulsion.
What happened
The letter says that on 9 November Cllr Wilson shared on her public Facebook page, with no comment, no caveat and no context
, a video titled ISRAEL REPLACED GOD
: Holocaust Survivor EXPOSES The Zionist Myth, whose thumbnail sets the face of Israel's Prime Minister beside the words THEY REPLACED GOD
, and that at the time of writing it remained on her page. It quotes the video, with its times: The Holocaust industry is nothing but a propaganda arm of the Israeli [Hasbara]
; There's no business like [Shoah] business
; this Holocaust remembrance pornography that's perpetrated upon us
; in a lot of synagogues, there's Israeli flags. The star of David ... came from India somewhere. Interestingly, you know what else came from India? The swastika
; and, at the end, what's going to happen to those 7 million puffed up [Zionists] ... the hatred and the venom and the ... totally natural desire for revenge that they've sow[n] is going to come back and haunt them.
This is not criticism of the Israeli government,
Cllr Gethen writes. Seven million is close to the entire Jewish population of Israel. A video that calls Holocaust remembrance 'pornography', sets the Star of David beside the swastika and calls revenge on millions of people 'totally natural' is not political commentary. It is antisemitism.
“what's going to happen to those 7 million puffed up [Zionists] ... the hatred and the venom and the ... totally natural desire for revenge that they've sow[n] is going to come back and haunt them.”
She anticipates the defence that the speaker is a Holocaust survivor: Surviving the Holocaust does not give anyone licence to call its remembrance 'pornography', and it is no shield for the councillor who chose to share it.
She asks the Green group to withdraw the whip pending investigation, refer Cllr Wilson for expulsion, require her to remove the post and apologise publicly to Solihull's Jewish community, and say publicly whether the content is acceptable for a Green councillor to share. If they will not act, she will refer the matter to the Monitoring Officer.
Shirley West deserves councillors who represent all its residents. Right now, one of yours does not.
The quotations from the video are as Cllr Gethen's letter gives them; this site has not seen the post. Any reply from Cllr Wilson or Cllr McLoughlin will be published here in full.








