- When
- 2 November 2026
- Where
- Sheffield City Council
- Party
- Labour
- Source
- Cllr Mark Rusling, on Facebook
Cllr Mark Rusling, Labour councillor for Shiregreen and Brightside and a leader of Sheffield's Labour group, posted on Facebook this morning a statement of "seven reasons" why Labour is right to end the joint administration with the Greens on Wednesday, in support of Cllr Belbin's account.
What was reported
The party voted for the elimination of Israel by violent means,
he writes of the Green conference. The Green Party now deems anybody who thinks that there should be a Jewish state to be racist,
making no distinction between Ben-Gvir and socialist Zionist Jews (including rabbis) who risk their own lives to protect Palestinian farmers in the West Bank
, and deeming British Jews who believe in a Jewish homeland and who profoundly reject the Netanyahu government (as most of our Sheffield Jewish residents do) to be just as racist as the most racist members of that government.
He names the parties he understands hold the same position: the Workers Revolutionary Party, two Communist parties, and the Green Party of England and Wales, as the National Front did in the 1970s and 1980s. He recalls the amendment to protect Jewish members who attend synagogues, rejected by 1,026 votes to 648, and the amendment on Palestinian self-determination, also rejected: For the Green Party, the future of Palestine should be decided in Ranmoor, not Ramallah.
“British Jews who believe in a Jewish homeland and who profoundly reject the Netanyahu government (as most of our Sheffield Jewish residents do) to be just as racist as the most racist members of that government.”
Of the Sheffield Green group he writes that it has chosen an approach which is far more extreme than their sister parties across the country
, and that its leader's line We believe that Jewish people should not be persecuted
was a truly incredible statement
. He is clear that this isn't about the current Israeli government: I agree that they are appalling and I hope that they are removed.
And: Being anti-racist isn't pick 'n' mix. You can't choose to stand with one community but abandon another.
The statement is reproduced in full below, its dashes set as punctuation; one Facebook account he names is left unnamed here.
The statement in full
On Wednesday, Sheffield Labour will be ending our joint council administration with the Sheffield Green Party. As Fran has explained: "Our trust in Sheffield Greens is completely broken". I agree. Here’s why:
1. The Green Party conference in October was deeply worrying: they seem gripped by an urge to create division.
The Green Party conference, held in Brighton at the start of October, showed how far the party has changed from the one we joined with just a few months ago.
The party voted for the elimination of Israel by violent means. A party that used to be pacifist now calls for the violent removal of a state that actually exists, with virtually nothing to say about the state that would replace it.
As part of that process, the Green Party now deems anybody who thinks that there should be a Jewish state to be racist. Clearly, Israeli Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir is a racist (and more) when he says that "there are people [in Gaza] who are not worthy of life... they’re not even people". But the Green Party now makes no distinction between Ben-Gvir and socialist Zionist Jews (including rabbis) who risk their own lives to protect Palestinian farmers in the West Bank. It says that Yair Golan, Leader of the Israeli Democrats, is just as racist as Ben-Gvir, even though Golan’s response to the recent Israeli election rightly was to say: "[Jews] have no future here if we don’t stop being afraid. And if we don’t put an end to racism. We can no longer accept Netanyahu’s racist distinction between Jewish and Arab votes". And the Green Party now deems British Jews who believe in a Jewish homeland and who profoundly reject the Netanyahu government (as most of our Sheffield Jewish residents do) to be just as racist as the most racist members of that government.
This is clearly wrong, and we know that many people in the Sheffield Green Party agree with us. Their new position stops them from seeing the people who really are racist. It is a more extreme position than the Palestinian Authority’s own approach, which calls for a two-state solution.
One British party in the 1970s and 1980s held the same position: the National Front. Of current British political parties, I understand that four hold this position: the Workers Revolutionary Party, the Communist Party of Great Britain (Provisional Central Committee), the Communist Party of Great Britain (Marxist-Leninist), and the Green Party of England and Wales.
This is the company that the Green Party have chosen to keep. We cannot continue to keep company with them while they choose this path.
2. The Greens had a chance to safeguard British Jews, and didn’t take it.
Although the Green Party is formally a pacifist, peaceful party, the person who presented the motion at their conference (and only joined the Green Party a few months ago) is not. She has said publicly that Zionists should be "hunted" in "every country" and that synagogues should be "confronted". Understandably, this has sent a shockwave of fear through the British Jewish community, including in our own city.
The Green Party had a chance to reject this fear. Before they voted on the main motion, Green members voted on a simple amendment, which would have protected Jewish members who attend mainstream synagogues, schools and community centres.
Green Party members strongly rejected that approach, by 648 votes to 1026. This led to the extraordinary scene in which a spokesperson for a British political party in 2026 had to issue a statement saying that: "It does not mean the Green Party is going to persecute Jewish members". When you have to say this out loud, it is, to put it mildly, a bad sign.
3. The Greens had a chance to make it clear that they believe in self-determination, and didn’t take it.
In Sheffield, we have consistently called for a Palestinian state, with Palestinians deciding their own future. I agree with that position. The vast majority of Brits agree that people should be in charge of their own countries. That majority now does not include the Green Party.
Again, before voting on the main motion, Green members had a chance to show their support for Palestinian self-determination, by voting on an amendment which stated that a Palestinian state "should be shaped and determined by Palestinians themselves based on the principle of Palestinian self-determination". They rejected this, again, by a large margin.
By doing this, they chose a policy which says that, not only do they reject Jewish self-determination, they also reject Palestinian self-determination! For the Green Party, the future of Palestine should be decided in Ranmoor, not Ramallah.
4. The Sheffield Green Party are isolated and extreme, even within their own party.
I know that there are good people in the Sheffield Green Party who profoundly disagree with the new direction of their own party. They agree with the former Green Leader in Cornwall, who has just joined Labour, saying: "I didn’t leave the Green Party; the party left me."
As Fran has set out, we have spent much of the last month trying to engage with the Sheffield Green Party leadership and councillors. We have sought an honest dialogue (in public and private) which would keep the joint administration going. However, the local party have rejected that and have chosen an approach which is far more extreme than their sister parties across the country.
On 16th October, the Sheffield Greens’ Leader wrote to Cllr Belbin, saying: "You know that the Green Councillors are not antisemitic". We know that the vast majority are not. But we struggle to reconcile this with the aggressive approach of some in the Green Party who seem oblivious to the hurt they are causing. One councillor has accused us of "weaponising October 7th". Would he make the same accusation of any other mass murder? A Facebook account which appears to support the Sheffield Green Party posted about Fran: "her Zionist masters in the Labour party won’t allow her to [act] and she’s on a leash, similar to what a dog is like".
On 27th October, the Sheffield Greens’ Leader wrote again, acknowledging that their approach "has caused some concern", but without explaining what those concerns are, or how they propose to deal with them. Her letter continues with a truly incredible statement: "We believe that Jewish people should not be persecuted". As this echoes their party spokesman’s words at the party conference, I can only assume that ‘persecuted’ was deliberately chosen. Steve Cohen, author of a Jewish-Marxist analysis of left-wing antisemitism puts it brilliantly: "Are we supposed to be grateful that the Left has not got a conscious policy of genocide? Is it supposed to make us feel any better that its antisemitism often operates on a crass, unaware level?".
At no point have the Sheffield Green Party addressed our concerns: ensuring the safety of the Sheffield Jewish community, understanding that their approach fails to recognise the real racists and supporting self-determination. In this, they have adopted a position that is way outside the mainstream, even of their own Green Party.
The party’s former leaders, Adrian Ramsay and Caroline Lucas, have both rejected this approach. Four of the party’s five MPs have rejected it. The council run by the Green Party Deputy Leader has rejected it, alongside many other Green council groups, saying: "the motion presented one particular definition of Zionism, we acknowledge that this word can mean different things to different people. The policy also calls for a single state solution, but we believe that it is for Palestinians and Israelis to determine their own peaceful future."
Despite this, the Sheffield Green Party continues to cling to their own deeply damaging approach.
5. This isn’t about the current Israeli government: I agree that they are appalling and I hope that they are removed.
This is not about our views on Netanyahu or the Israeli government. It is about our support for British communities, and for the self-determination of all peoples in the Middle East.
For what it’s worth, it is clear to me that certain Israeli ministers’ language over Gaza shows genocidal intent. War crimes or worse may have been committed in Gaza. Illegal settlements and other policies in the West Bank are designed by some to make a Palestinian state non-viable. And in the last week, since the Israeli election, Netanyahu has clearly sought to delegitimise Israeli Arab votes and voters in ways that cannot be described as anything other than racist. Yair Golan was right to call this out.
We should do the same. But the Green Party’s current approach does not do that: it singles out a group of our fellow citizens and makes their lives in this country more constrained and fearful. We cannot support that approach.
6. We must fight intolerance, extremism and racism in all its forms.
In the last year in Sheffield, we have seen racist attacks on numerous communities. Black shirted thugs have marched through Darnall, supported by ‘Tommy Robinson’. The Wybourn Masjid and Islamic Centre has been attacked. My own Muslim colleagues have been subjected to vile racism just for playing a role in the life of our city. Our Sheffield synagogue has required police protection, just to allow our fellow citizens to pray.
We are seeing a concerted attempt to restrict the ways in which our fellow Brits and fellow Sheffielders can live full lives. Places of worship can open, but only behind security. Religious schools can teach, but only behind high walls. Community centres can operate, but only with grates on windows.
Being anti-racist isn’t pick ‘n’ mix. You can’t choose to stand with one community but abandon another. That is what the new Green Party have chosen to do, by demonising our fellow British citizens. This is fundamentally un-British and it is wrong.
7. Sheffield Labour will run the council in the best interests of all Sheffield citizens.
I know that good people across our city may disagree with this analysis. That’s all fine: we live in a democracy, thankfully. I’ve put my views in good faith.
We live in a dangerous moment, with the rise of the far right across the world echoing the darkest moments of the twentieth century. Extremists of the far right and far left are seeking to pit groups in society against each other. They are demonising our fellow Brits, making whole groups of people fearful for their place in the UK. We have to resist this.
We were elected to do what we can to improve the lives of all the people of Sheffield. I have sought to do that in my time on the council. I’m sure I’ve made mistakes, and I’m sure I’ll make more. But I have tried to concentrate on the things that people can see: sorting the pot holes, reducing litter, increasing recycling.
As a leader in Sheffield Labour, I’ll do my very best to ensure that the decisions we take at Full Council on Wednesday reflect our profound disagreement with the new Green Party, but do not impact on residents’ services. On Friday morning, I will be chairing my own committee, alongside colleagues from the other political parties. The show will go on.
In general, I believe that councils commenting continually on international affairs are councils that have forgotten their core tasks. However, this approach from the new Green Party impacts the people of Sheffield, so requires a response.
Unfortunately, whether by design or mistake, the Green Party has chosen to widen the divides in society, rather than heal them. And our local Greens have chosen the most extreme path within their party. We cannot walk this path with them.









