- When
- 18 November 2026
- Where
- Sheffield City Council
- Party
- Green Party
- Source
- The Star (Local Democracy Reporting Service)
Cllr Angela Argenzio, leader of the Green group on Sheffield City Council, and Cllr Alexi Dimond told the Local Democracy Reporting Service (Rose Mason) that Labour's demands over the "Zionism is Racism" motion were "an attempt of national party to control what local parties do".
What was reported
Cllr Argenzio said the joint administration broke down before
the Jewish Chronicle's reports on Cllr Mustafa Ahmed's posts, so that's just a complete distraction
, and that Labour thought it could gain some kind of political points on this by taking a supposedly moral high ground on something that is irrelevant to most people in Sheffield i.e. a Green Party national policy position.
Cllr Dimond said the Greens were happy to clarify certain things, but we're not prepared to do their demand, which is to throw our national party and our decision making processes under the bus.
Of the JC's reports he said: These are historic comments they've been sitting on.
“could gain some kind of political points on this by taking a supposedly moral high ground on something that is irrelevant to most people in Sheffield i.e. a Green Party national policy position.”
Cllr Argenzio said the national party is investigating Cllr Ahmed, that there is huge support for Mustafa locally
, and that Cllr Belbin's statement that Sheffield's Jewish community felt there had been no real attempt
to listen to them was false
. Cllr Dimond: We will always speak truth to power. And that's a threat to the establishment parties.
Cllr Belbin told the LDRS that Labour's national party had been supportive
and had given us the time and space to negotiate with the Greens
.
What they said, and what the record shows
"A Green Party national policy position"
It is not only national. Cllr Dimond, Cllr Maroof Raouf and Cllr Ahmed are all on the open letter of Green councillors who "support the 'Zionism is Racism' motion". Cllr Raouf said in public: "Zionism is racism, that is Green Party policy as of now." Sheffield's Green councillors did not merely inherit the policy; three of them put their names to it.
"Throw our national party under the bus"
What Sheffield Labour asked on 2 November was two sentences: that not all Zionists are racist, and that self-determination is the right of the peoples of Palestine and Israel. Green groups in Solihull and Cherwell said more than that and stayed in their parties. The Sheffield Greens would not say either sentence in public.
"A complete distraction"
The posts the JC reported are not a distraction. One told Muslims who condemned the 7 October attack that they "will bear the shame of supporting the Jews!" Another, of destruction in Tel Aviv, carried a prayer against "the criminal Zionists" and "the aggressor Jews". Cllr Ahmed deleted the first, then reposted it on 12 November and called the reaction "manufactured outrage". Whenever the talks broke down, a councillor in the administration posting that is reason enough.
"Historic comments they've been sitting on"
The posts are from October 2023 and June 2025, and Cllr Ahmed was elected in May 2026. Their age does not change what they say. When they were published, the first was reposted, not withdrawn.
"Speak truth to power"
Opposing the war in Gaza, or the Israeli government, does not require calling Jews racist. Most British Jews who hold the belief the motion condemns have never voted in an Israeli election, and many oppose that government. The motion does not condemn a government. It condemns the belief that the Jewish people may have a homeland.
"Irrelevant to most people in Sheffield"
It is not irrelevant to Sheffield's Jewish residents, whom it calls racist for a belief nine in ten British Jews hold. On 25 October the Board of Deputies of British Jews, their elected representative body, voted by 118 to 1 that the Green Party had "become a racist party".
What the "Zionism is Racism" motion actually says
"An anti-Zionist party"
It declares the Green Party formally opposed to the core belief of most British Jews: that the Jewish people, like every other people, have the right to a homeland of their own.
"Treated as any other form of racism"
It orders the party's Anti-Racism Policy Working Group to treat Zionism as racism. Jewish members who believe Israel should exist are to be handled as racists, inside a party that says it treats every member equally.
The synagogue safeguard, voted down
An amendment said the motion should not be used to "pressure, proscribe or discipline members based on affiliations with Jewish community institutions". The Greens voted it down. At the party's own workshop, asked whether members of Jewish bodies that call themselves Zionist would be racist, the motion's side answered: "if what you believe falls in line with that, then perhaps you are."
"A single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine"
That means no Israel. It rejects the two-state solution backed by the UN, the UK, the EU, the Arab League and the Palestinian Authority, and affirms self-determination for one people while abolishing it for the other.
"By all available means"
It affirms Palestinian "struggle ... by all available means", and its own briefing paper spells that out as "including armed struggle".
Antisemitism a "misnomer"
Its briefing paper argues that the word "antisemitism" is a "misnomer" that should be dropped, and calls the definitions used by the UK Government and most councils "weaponry". It also calls for Palestine Action, proscribed by Parliament under the Terrorism Act 2000, to be taken off the list.
Why that is racism
No other people's right to a homeland is called racist. A policy that singles out the Jewish people's alone, brands most Jews racist for holding it, and refuses even a safeguard for those who pray in their own synagogues is not anti-racism. It is the double standard the campaign exists to name.










