Zionism Is Not Racism
Act now

Green Party · Sheffield City Council

The first of Sheffield Green Party's five slides, 12 November 2026

Sheffield Green Party answers Labour ending the joint administration: "decisions for Sheffield Labour are made in London", and says nothing of the motion or of Cllr Ahmed

From Sheffield Green Party, on Facebook

When
12 November 2026
Where
Sheffield City Council
Party
Green Party
Source
Sheffield Green Party, on Facebook

On 12 November Sheffield Green Party posted five slides on Facebook answering the end of the joint administration with Labour, with the imprint "Promoted by Eamonn Ward".

What happened

The slides say that Sheffield Labour leader Fran Belbin is now u-turning on her previous commitment to ensure a stable council for Sheffield; that a Joint Statement agreed by both local parties was pulled at the last minute by Labour bosses in London; that a new version was written by the Labour Party's National Executive Committee; that the national Labour Party vetoed the power-sharing arrangement; that Sheffield Greens refuse to submit to national Labour and will continue to speak out against violations of human rights and international law and the complicity of the Labour government; and that decisions for Sheffield Labour are made in London, and political games are prioritised over local needs.

The last slide says Sheffield deserves leadership with a backbone, not a permission slip from London, over a group photograph of Sheffield Green councillors in the council chamber. The full text is below. What is not in it matters more. The slides do not mention the Green Party's motion declaring Zionism to be racism, which Cllr Belbin's statement of 11 November says Labour objects to locally, regionally and nationally.

“Sheffield Greens refuse to submit to national Labour and will continue to speak out against violations of human rights and international law and the complicity of the Labour government”

They do not mention Cllr Mustafa Ahmed, whose Facebook posts after 7 October 2023, as reported by the Jewish Chronicle on 9 November, the same statement says eroded Labour's trust. They do not mention antisemitism at all. And they do not say what was in either version of the Joint Statement, so no reader can tell what shared principles the Greens say they are still working on.

Three claims are unsupported in what has been published.

First, that London vetoed the arrangement: Cllr Belbin's statement gives Sheffield Labour's own reasons, the motion and Cllr Ahmed, and the slides offer no document showing a veto.

Second, that this is a u-turn: Labour said on 4 November that it would continue because the Greens had confirmed that not all Zionists are racists, and on 9 November that the Greens were listening; the JC's report of Cllr Ahmed's posts came after both, and Cllr Belbin's statement says the Greens remain unable to disavow this damaging motion in full.

Third, that the dispute is about human rights and international law: the question put to Green groups, by Labour in Sheffield and on eleven councils, and by this campaign to councillors of every party, is only whether Zionism, the belief that the Jewish people have a homeland, is racism.

The five slides, in full

Slide 1. Sheffield Labour leader Fran Belbin is now u-turning on her previous commitment to ensure a stable council for Sheffield. Last week, Sheffield Labour Group and Green Group began constructive negotiations to continue the power-sharing arrangement in Sheffield. Talks conducted in good faith led to a Joint Statement agreed by both local parties, which was then pulled at the last minute by Labour bosses in London.

Slide 2. On Sunday, it became clear that the goalposts were being moved again, and on Monday, Cllr Belbin produced a new version of the Joint Statement, written by the Labour Party’s National Executive Committee. This was very disappointing as the new statement did not reflect the constructive and thoughtful discussions between local groups. Despite this, the Green Group agreed to continue working together on a form of words that would reflect shared principles.

Slide 3. It is now clear that the national Labour Party vetoed the power-sharing arrangement. Sheffield Greens refuse to submit to national Labour and will continue to speak out against violations of human rights and international law and the complicity of the Labour government.

Slide 4. We want to thank everyone in Sheffield who encouraged reconciliation and cooperation in the spirit of our hard-won committee system, and everyone who has sent messages of support over the last few weeks. We also want to thank all those who voted Green at the last local election, when we won more votes in Sheffield than any other party. Sheffield Greens remain committed to cooperation and local democracy. Unfortunately, it seems that decisions for Sheffield Labour are made in London, and political games are prioritised over local needs.

Slide 5. Sheffield deserves leadership with a backbone, not a permission slip from London. Sheffield Green Councillors, always standing up for local democracy. Promoted by Eamonn Ward.

Cllr Belbin's statement of 11 November, in full Cllr Belbin's statement of 4 November, and the five contradictions The Jewish Chronicle on Cllr Ahmed's posts, 9 November Sheffield's councillors

The latest news

  1. Green Party · Solihull CouncilCllr Samantha Gethen, letter to Cllr Max McLoughlinSolihull Green councillor Alison Wilson shared a video calling Holocaust remembrance "pornography", Reform UK's group leader says, and asks the Greens to withdraw the whipCllr Samantha Gethen, Leader of the Opposition on Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council for Reform UK, wrote on 20 November to Cllr Max McLoughlin, leader of the council's Green group, asking him to withdraw the whip from Cllr...
  2. Liberal Democrats · Kingston upon ThamesThe Jewish ChronicleCllr Brian Austen apologises after calling Zionism "evil" and "genocidal", the Jewish Chronicle reportsCllr Brian Austen, the Liberal Democrat councillor for Coombe Vale on Kingston upon Thames Council, has apologised for what he wrote to this campaign, the Jewish Chronicle (Jane Prinsley) reported on 20 November.
  3. Reform UK · Sheffield City CouncilCllr Matt Smith, writing to this campaign"I stand full square with the Jewish community": Sheffield councillor Matt Smith puts his name to it, and is "ashamed" of the Sheffield councillors who backed the motionCllr Matt Smith, the Reform UK councillor for Park and Arbourthorne on Sheffield City Council, wrote to this campaign on 20 November to put his name to it: "Zionism is certainly NOT racism."
  4. Reform UK · Sheffield City CouncilCllr Jack Byrom, on Facebook"Sheffield first, not Israel-Palestine": Cllr Jack Byrom asks how much weight the council's ethical procurement policy will carry in its banking tenderCllr Jack Byrom, the Reform UK councillor for Richmond ward on Sheffield City Council, posted a clip from this week's Finance Committee, where the council's banking contract with Barclays was discussed again.

All the news