- When
- 3 November 2026
- Where
- Derbyshire Dales District Council
- Party
- Green Party
- Source
- Derbyshire Times
Cllr Neil Buttle, leader of the four Green councillors on Derbyshire Dales District Council, spoke to the Derbyshire Times today after Labour's National Executive Committee ended the party's part in the council's progressive alliance, one of eleven such arrangements Labour has ended because the Green groups would not reject the "Zionism is Racism" motion.
What was reported
I know some councils are continuing because the Green members said 'yeah, we don't agree',
the councillor said. That is not our position. We have essentially said that none of us would have voted for it but that we are not going to go against Green policy, because we are absolutely against genocide. I think Labour are trying to make it look like we are split on this and I don't think we are really.
On the motion itself: It has never been raised with me when I am knocking on the doors. It is normally about bins and public toilets, and I agree with them, the public toilets situation needs tackling.
The paper's headline took the line as its title: Let's get back to tackling public toilets.
“It has never been raised with me when I am knocking on the doors. It is normally about bins and public toilets, and I agree with them, the public toilets situation needs tackling.”
Cllr Buttle said the council's committee system means every decision is ratified by members in proportion, so I am not quite sure what difference it will make
. Cllr Simon Ripton, Labour's group leader on the council, said he had not been told of the national decision, and that the alliance was not a coalition.
The Derbyshire Times also printed the Green group's October reply to Cllr Ripton: none of us would have supported the motion
, but we reject the suggestion that the motion, or the Green Party, is antisemitic
, and to assume that all Jews are Zionists is itself antisemitic
. The four Green councillors, Cllrs Buttle, Matt Buckler, Laura Mellstrom and Nick Whitehead, remain on this site's register with no position of their own: none has signed the pledge, taken the first step or written to the campaign.







