The accountability register · the racist motion

Cllr Neil Buttle Refused to oppose the motion
Tideswell ward, Derbyshire Dales
Asked by this campaign where they stand on the racist motion, wrote back refusing to oppose it (below). Has not signed the pledge against it.
Cllr Buttle: say where you stand with one email from your council address, no code. against@zionismisracism.co.uk if you are against the motion, for@zionismisracism.co.uk if you support it. Either is published here in your name, with a statement in your own words if you add one.
Refused to oppose the racist motion
In an email to this campaign on 3 November 2026, Cllr Neil Buttle wrote:
“We have essentially said that none of us would have voted for it but that we are not going to go against Green policy, because we are absolutely against genocide. I think Labour are trying to make it look like we are split on this and I don't think we are really. It has never been raised with me when I am knocking on the doors. It is normally about bins and public toilets, and I agree with them, the public toilets situation needs tackling.”
As leader of the Green group on Derbyshire Dales District Council, to the Derbyshire Times, after Labour ended the progressive alliance: the group will not reject the motion.
What Cllr Buttle said, and why it is wrong
Cllr Buttle says none of the group would have voted for the motion, and that the group will not say so. Those two things do not sit together. If nobody in the Derbyshire Dales Green group would have voted for it, rejecting it costs one sentence. The Green group on East Hertfordshire Council said exactly that, "The Green group at East Herts Council does not support the motion", and kept its administration. Derbyshire Dales would not, and lost its alliance.
"Because we are absolutely against genocide" answers a question nobody asked. The motion is not about a war. It declares that Zionism, the belief that the Jewish people have a homeland, is racism, to be "treated as any other form of racism". Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, including many who are fierce critics of Israeli governments.
That it is never raised on the doorstep is no answer either. Jewish residents are few in the Derbyshire Dales. Whether a party may call a small minority racists for a belief about their own people is not a question settled by how seldom they are met while canvassing about bins.
In the news · Derbyshire Dales Conservatives · 2 November 2026
Labour leaves the council's Progressive Alliance over the motion; the Conservatives call on the Liberal Democrats to end their deal with the Greens too
The council's Conservative group, led by Cllr Stuart Lees, welcomed "today's announcement that the Labour Party is withdrawing from its power-sharing arrangements with the Green Party on Derbyshire Dales District Council, following the Greens' refusal to distance themselves from their national party's deeply concerning policy declaring Zionism to be a form of racism".
"Labour has now made its position clear after the local Derbyshire Dales Greens refused to reject the motion. The question is why the Liberal Democrats have not done the same." The group called on the Liberal Democrats, who lead the council, "to follow Labour's example and end their power-sharing agreement with the Green Party". These are the Conservative group's words; this page records only what the councillor named on it has said.
The Derbyshire Times confirmed the same afternoon that Labour had pulled out of power-sharing with the Greens on eleven councils, Derbyshire Dales among them, quoting Labour's chair, Bridget Phillipson: "we cannot work with any party that supports it, at any level of government".
In the news · The Guardian · 15 October 2026
Labour tells its groups to end local agreements with Greens who do not reject the motion; this council is on the Guardian's list
The Guardian reported that Labour's chair, Bridget Phillipson, told Labour groups sharing power with the Greens to review their agreements and end them unless their Green partners reject the motion. Greens would be asked "to make clear that they reject this position and to call on their national leadership to reconsider"; where they cannot, "Labour will bring any such local arrangement to an end."
The Guardian listed this council among the 18 affected. A Green Party spokesperson answered that "trying to tell local parties what to do and who they can work with is undemocratic."
In the news
A news story naming Cllr Neil Buttle
On 4 October 2026 the Green Party of England and Wales declared that Zionism is racism, in its racist motion. Asked where they stand, Councillor Neil Buttle wrote back refusing to oppose it, in the words quoted above. They have not signed the councillors' pledge against it.
Zionism is not racism. It is the belief that Jews have a right to a homeland in their ancestral land, held by most British Jews. A councillor whose party has declared that belief racism owes the Jewish residents of Tideswell ward, Derbyshire Dales an answer: do they support the motion, will they call publicly for it to be reversed, and will they resign if the party keeps it?
Cllr Buttle, is this you? Put your position on the record in a minute: sign the pledge with your council email, and this page stops asking people to email you the same day.
Email Cllr Buttle
A ready-written email, worded differently every time, asking Cllr Buttle where they stand on the “Zionism is Racism” motion and to join the four MPs in speaking out: reverse it or resign. It goes straight to their council address, with Zack Polanski, the Green Party leader copied in. You see every word before you send it from your own email app.
Your email to Cllr Neil Buttle
No name added, so remember to replace "[Your name]" at the bottom of the message with your own name before you send.
- To
- CC
-
Zack Polanski, the Green Party leader, so the party sees it too.
- BCC
-
Our stats mailbox. It counts emails and discards them. How we handle this.
Nothing opening? Press "Copy everything" and paste it into a new email.
Share this page
The other Green councillors on Derbyshire Dales
Keep going
Every Green councillor's position Every Green councillor, by council Email more Green councillors These councillors say Zionism is racism
