- When
- 10 November 2026
- Where
- Devon County Council
- Party
- Liberal Democrat
- Source
- Midweek Herald (Lewis Clarke)
The Midweek Herald reported on 11 November on the Devon County Council Cabinet meeting of 10 November.
What was reported
Cllr Ed Hill (Independent, Pinhoe and Mincinglake) had put a written question to Cllr Julian Brazil (Liberal Democrat, Kingsbridge), the council's leader, citing the motion on racism, intolerance and hatred that the council adopted unanimously in September 2025 (We will not allow hate to become acceptable
), and the Green Party's motion of 4 October. Cllr Hill wrote that the Liberal Democrats have condemned the policy nationally, yet here in Devon they continue to share power with the Greens
, and asked whether the leader would require the Green Cabinet member to publicly reject the Green Party's policy and, if she refuses, remove her from the Cabinet
.
Cllr Brazil replied in writing that the council condemn[s] antisemitism, racism and hate crime in all forms
, that parties are responsible for their national policies, that the leader judges Cabinet members on their conduct and contribution to council services, and that I do not consider it appropriate to require an individual Cabinet Member to make a prescribed public statement about the policy of their national political party as a condition of remaining in the Cabinet.
“I do not consider it appropriate to require an individual Cabinet Member to make a prescribed public statement about the policy of their national political party as a condition of remaining in the Cabinet.”
Cllr Hill could not attend, and Cllr Brazil agreed to read out Cllr Hill's supplementary question: Do you believe Zionism is racism? If not, why will you not require your cabinet members to publicly reject that claim?
Cllr Brazil answered: Do I believe Zionism is racism? No.
Cllr Jacqi Hodgson (Green, Totnes and Dartington), the Cabinet member for climate change and biodiversity, then read a statement.
It supported the joint statement of senior Green Party figures after the conference vote, which says We know there is no conflict between supporting the rights of Palestinians and the rights of Jewish people.
Cllr Hodgson said the intention behind the motion concerning Gaza was one Cllr Hodgson agreed with, but not all its provisions: There are parts that I do not agree with. And as such, I would not have voted in favour of the motion.
Cllr Sue Davies (Reform UK, Hatherleigh and Chagford) asked whether the leader was comfortable keeping a Cabinet member who had not condemned the motion; Cllr Brazil said I think you are misconstruing that. I've got a hundred percent confidence in Jackie and her values and what she stands for
, and I don't agree with the Green Party on this particular issue, but I'm not going to chastise or punish Jackie because she's a member of the Green Party.
Cllr Hodgson added: I said in there I do not support the motion. I said it in my statement. I think perhaps that's clear enough.
No motion to remove Cllr Hodgson from the Cabinet was taken. Both Cllr Brazil and Cllr Hodgson are now on this site's record of those who have spoken against the motion.
On 13 November Cllr Hill told this campaign of a motion, Zionism Is Not Racism, submitted for Devon County Council's Full Council on 3 December 2026 and seconded by Cllr Angi Game, which rejects the Green Party conference resolution declaring that ‘Zionism is racism’ and affirms that Zionism is not racism
; Cllr Hill has asked for a roll-call vote, so that each councillor's position is publicly recorded.
Correction, 13 November: from 11 to 13 November Cllr Hodgson's page on this site wrongly showed the councillor as standing by the motion. That was this campaign's error, in how the councillor's words were filed, and not anything Cllr Hodgson said; the page now shows Cllr Hodgson as having spoken out against the motion.



