- When
- 2 November 2026
- Where
- Derbyshire County Council
- Party
- Reform UK
Cllr Lewis Whitbread, the Reform UK county councillor for Hasland and Rother on Derbyshire County Council, endorsed the campaign's statement that Zionism is not racism on the evening of 2 November, from a council address, and sent with it a letter setting out why.
What happened
I believe that England is for the English. I believe that Scotland is for the Scottish, Wales is for the Welsh and Ireland is for the Irish. If I believe such things, why cannot Israel be for the Jews?
The councillor asks how such a belief can be racist: Which race is the offending party? Which race is the aggrieved? There are Jewish peoples all around the globe, of all shades and creeds. Believing they are entitled to a homeland appears to be the only
crime here. The very same thing that Palestinians claim to be fighting for.
The councillor writes that the Israeli government is far from my idea of perfection
, but that when such a foolish, divisive and inciteful motion as this is passed by a political party that claims to represent the kindest and most empathetic of society, I feel obligated to say something
, and that with global and national tensions at an all-time high, such motions can only seek to put my fellow countrymen at risk
.
“I believe that England is for the English. I believe that Scotland is for the Scottish, Wales is for the Welsh and Ireland is for the Irish. If I believe such things, why cannot Israel be for the Jews?”
Cllr Whitbread is the fourth Reform UK councillor on Derbyshire County Council to endorse the campaign, after Cllr Joss Barnes, Cllr Alex Millward and the council's Leader, Cllr Alan Graves.
The letter is below in full, as written.
The letter in full
I am against the "Zionism is Racism" motion.
I believe that England is for the English. I believe that Scotland is for the Scottish, Wales is for the Welsh and Ireland is for the Irish.
If I believe such things, why cannot Israel be for the Jews? I take such a visceral grievance at the thought of such statements of common sense being considered racist.
A nation state does not exist to feed, accommodate, protect and serve the world. First and foremost must always be its own people.
Furthermore, how can such a belief be racist? Which race is the offending party? Which race is the aggrieved?
There are Jewish peoples all around the globe, of all shades and creeds.
Believing they are entitled to a homeland appears to be the only "crime" here. The very same thing that Palestinians claim to be fighting for.
I should ask anyone in support of the "free Palestine" movement, that is in favour of this motion, to take a long think about why you believe it is okay for one group of people to claim a land as their own and not another.
It strikes me as rather a sinister piece of cognitive dissonance.
I don't like to stray far from home in my political insights, I am here first and foremost to serve my residents in Chesterfield, Derbyshire.
The Israeli government is far from my idea of perfection. I could shake my fist at them almost as often as I do my own government.
Yet, when such a foolish, divisive and inciteful motion as this is passed by a political party that claims to represent the kindest and most empathetic of society, I feel obligated to say something.
With global and national tensions at an all-time high, such motions can only seek to put my fellow countrymen at risk.
I urge anyone in support of this motion to reconsider.
Yours,
Lewis Whitbread, County Councillor for Hasland & Rother, Derbyshire County Council




