Zionism Is Not Racism
Act now

Liberal Democrat · Kingston upon Thames

Cllr Brian Austen, Liberal Democrat councillor for Coombe Vale, Kingston upon Thames

Cllr Brian Austen refuses to sign "Zionism is not racism", writes that Zionism is "not only evil, but genocidal"; three days later, that it "should not automatically be equated with racism"

From Cllr Brian Austen, in emails to this campaign

When
17 November 2026
Where
Kingston upon Thames
Party
Liberal Democrat
Source
Cllr Brian Austen, in emails to this campaign

Cllr Brian Austen is a Liberal Democrat councillor for Coombe Vale ward on the Royal Borough of Kingston upon Thames.

What happened

On 28 October 2026 the councillor replied to this campaign's request to put a name to one sentence, Zionism is not racism. I call on the Green Party to reverse its ‘Zionism is Racism’ motion: If the motion had been amended to read, 'Zionism as practised by the present Israeli government is Racism', I would have supported it. This campaign's system recorded that reply as an endorsement.

That was a mistake: a reply that says what would have been supported is not a signature.

“Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland”

On 10 November, at 13:51, in a reply to a councillor who had written at 13:08 to ask Did you mean to sign this pledge?, with a link to this campaign's page for Kingston upon Thames, Cllr Austen wrote: Zionism as practised by the present Israeli government is racism. Is all I signed up to. The email, signed with the first name Brian, was passed to this campaign the same afternoon, and is shown below with the recipient's name and details removed, set out as it would appear in a mail program.

Each of Cllr Austen's emails to this campaign, with this campaign's replies, is shown in full in the timeline below. The endorsement was removed the same day and the councillor was listed as having refused to sign.

On 12 November, from a personal address, and on 13 November, from a council address, Cllr Austen wrote to this campaign that I would not support the statement, and that the recent attacks of Israel on the only remaining hospital in Gaza has convinced me that Zionism is not only evil, but very antiSemitic (12 November) and not only evil, but genocidal (13 November).

On 16 November, from a council address, Cllr Austen sent this campaign a statement: My position is that Zionism, as a political ideology, should not automatically be equated with racism or antisemitism. However, I believe that the policies and actions of the present Israeli government, particularly towards Palestinians, demonstrate profound discrimination and a denial of their fundamental rights. I would therefore support a statement that explicitly condemns Zionism as practised by the present Israeli government, rather than making a blanket assertion about Zionism or those who identify with it. I oppose antisemitism unequivocally, just as I oppose racism and discrimination against Palestinians. These principles are entirely compatible and should be defended consistently.

This campaign replied the same evening that it is not about Israeli politics or any Israeli government but about one question, whether Zionism is racism, gave the definition, Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland, and asked whether Cllr Austen agrees with it.

This campaign does not count Cllr Austen as a supporter. This story was first published on 13 November and brought up to date on 17 November. The councillor's own written words, with their dates and where each came from, are on the councillor's page here and on zionismisracism.co.uk.

The photograph is the one on Kingston Council's own page for the councillor.

The emails, in order

  1. 28 October 2026

    This campaign asks where Cllr Austen stands, and Cllr Austen replies

    This campaign's email asked whether the councillor agrees with the Green Party's motion. Two hours later Cllr Austen replied: "If the motion had been amended to read, 'Zionism as practised by the present Israeli government is Racism', I would have supported it." The system recorded the reply as an endorsement, which was a mistake.

    This campaign's email of 28 October, and Cllr Austen's reply
  2. 10 November 2026

    "Is all I signed up to"

    Asked by a fellow councillor "Did you mean to sign this pledge?", Cllr Austen replied: "Zionism as practised by the present Israeli government is racism. Is all I signed up to." The email was passed to this campaign, and the endorsement was removed the same day.

    Cllr Austen's email of 10 November, with the other councillor's details removed
  3. 12 November 2026

    "Not only evil, but very antiSemitic"

    From a personal address, Cllr Austen wrote that "Zionism is not only evil, but very antiSemitic". This campaign asked for it to be sent from the council address.

    Cllr Austen's email of 12 November from a personal address, which is removed, and this campaign's reply
  4. 13 November 2026

    "Not only evil, but genocidal"

    From the council address, Cllr Austen wrote that Zionism is "not only evil, but genocidal". This story was first published that day.

    Cllr Austen's email of 13 November
  5. 16 November 2026

    "Should not automatically be equated with racism"

    Cllr Austen sent a statement: Zionism "should not automatically be equated with racism or antisemitism". This campaign replied that it is about one question, whether Zionism is racism, gave the definition and asked whether Cllr Austen agrees with it.

    Cllr Austen's statement of 16 November, and this campaign's reply

What Zionism means

Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland, where Jews have lived for thousands of years: the same right the English have in England, the Scots in Scotland and the Welsh in Wales.

It is a belief about a people, not about a government. Most British Jews hold it, and so do many people of other faiths and none. You can criticise any Israeli government, fiercely, as Israelis themselves do, and still be a Zionist, just as you can criticise a British government and still believe Britain should exist.

Racism is treating people worse because of their race or ethnicity, or holding one people to a standard applied to no one else. Believing that Jews, like every other people, may have a homeland is not that.

Why Cllr Austen is wrong

  1. A government is not a belief

    "Zionism as practised by the present Israeli government" describes what one government does. Governments change at elections; the belief that the Jewish people may have a homeland does not. Criticising a government's conduct is legitimate. It does not make a people's right to self-determination racist, any more than a British government's policies make Britain's existence racist.

  2. That is not the motion the Green Party passed

    Cllr Austen says a motion about the present government's conduct would have had support. The Green Party did not pass that motion. It declared Zionism itself racist, declared the party anti-Zionist, and committed it to "a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine": one state in place of Israel.

  3. "Evil" and "genocidal" describe people, not policy

    Whatever anyone thinks of the war, it does not change what Zionism is. To call the belief that Jews may have a homeland "evil" and "genocidal" is to say that of the British Jews who hold it, who are most British Jews.

  4. One rule for everyone

    No other people's right to a homeland is called racist because of what its government does. Holding the Jewish people alone to that rule is the double standard the campaign exists to name.

  5. "Should not automatically be equated with racism"

    On 16 November Cllr Austen wrote that Zionism "should not automatically be equated with racism or antisemitism", three days after calling it "not only evil, but genocidal". That is a step towards the truth, and a step away from the Green Party's motion, which equates the two automatically and without exception. But Zionism is not racism sometimes and not racism at other times. It is the belief that the Jewish people may have a homeland, and that belief is never racist, whatever any government does.

Cllr Brian Austen's page Cllr Brian Austen's page on zionismisracism.co.uk Kingston upon Thames's councillors, and where they stand Every council that has voted

The latest news

  1. Reform UK · Sheffield City CouncilCllr Matt Smith, writing to this campaign"I stand full square with the Jewish community": Sheffield councillor Matt Smith puts his name to it, and is "ashamed" of the Sheffield councillors who backed the motionCllr Matt Smith, the Reform UK councillor for Park and Arbourthorne on Sheffield City Council, wrote to this campaign on 20 November to put his name to it: "Zionism is certainly NOT racism."
  2. Reform UK · Sheffield City CouncilCllr Jack Byrom, on Facebook"Sheffield first, not Israel-Palestine": Cllr Jack Byrom asks how much weight the council's ethical procurement policy will carry in its banking tenderCllr Jack Byrom, the Reform UK councillor for Richmond ward on Sheffield City Council, posted a clip from this week's Finance Committee, where the council's banking contract with Barclays was discussed again.
  3. Inside the Green PartySussex Express (SussexWorld)Wealden's Green leader, the party's deputy leader, objects to calling the motion "a racist or antisemitic policy"Cllr Rachel Millward, the Green leader of Wealden District Council and a deputy leader of the Green Party of England and Wales, told a council meeting on Wednesday 18 November that her group opposes the "Zionism is Racism"...
  4. Green Party · Sheffield City CouncilThe Star (Local Democracy Reporting Service)Sheffield's Green leaders say Labour was "political point scoring" over "a Green Party national policy position". Here is what that policy saysCllr Angela Argenzio, leader of the Green group on Sheffield City Council, and Cllr Alexi Dimond told the Local Democracy Reporting Service (Rose Mason) that Labour's demands over the "Zionism is Racism" motion were "an attempt..."

All the news