At Brent Council's full council meeting on 16 November, Emma Tait presented a deputation on behalf of the Brent Jewish Network defending the Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion and asking Brent's Labour, Conservative and Liberal Democrat groups to retract their statements against it. Here it is in full, as Brent & Harrow Palestine Solidarity Campaign posted it, with a transcript and what is wrong with each claim.
Read the transcript
An automatic transcript of the recording, checked against the captions shown in the video and corrected for names and spelling. The times are approximate. The video is above, so you can check every word against it.
0:00 We're here as non-Zionist Jewish residents of Brent, representing the Brent Jewish Network. We're disappointed that Brent Labour, Conservative and Lib Dem parties have all released strangely similar statements mischaracterising the "Zionism is Racism" motion that was adopted at the Green Party conference in October.
0:26 Your statements erase the voices of anti-Zionist Jews, not only the Brent Jewish Network and others, but also the Jewish co-presenter and proposer of the motion and Holocaust survivor Stephen Kapos. The statements also centre Jews throughout and mention Palestinians in passing. This is precisely the narrative that the "Zionism is Racism" motion sets out to challenge. Anti-Palestinian racism is defined as that which silences, excludes, erases, stereotypes, defames and dehumanises Palestinians or their narratives.
1:05 All three statements wrongly conflate Zionism with being Jewish. The Green Party motion makes clear it is aimed at the political ideology and practice of Zionism as defined, and not at the religious or ethnic background of those who may identify as Zionists. Not all Jews are Zionists and not all Zionists are Jews. Indeed, a large proportion of Zionists in the world are not Jewish.
1:33 As Green Party leader Zack Polanski, the only Jewish leader of a main political party, reiterated, being Jewish and being a Zionist are two different things. Judaism is thousands of years old; Zionism is barely 130. It is antisemitic to assign the same views to Jews as a group.
1:56 The Israeli government and pro-Zionist groups, like the Board of Deputies of British Jews, claim to speak for all Jews. They do not. And like so many other Jews, we say "not in our name" about Israel's ethnic cleansing and genocide in Palestine. An open letter by a coalition of Jewish groups states: "None of us see the motion as racist, antisemitic, or feel it is a threat to our safety as Jews."
2:26 We believe that the Board of Deputies has attacked the Green Party in order to hide its own racism against Palestinians and protect Israel from further censure. The practical application of Zionism includes countless laws which discriminate against Palestinians, going back to the formation of the State of Israel. Immigration to Israel is guaranteed to Jews across the world under the 1950 Law of Return, while Palestinians, driven from their homes since 1947, have no right to return and are made permanent refugees.
3:05 The Conservative statement recognises self-determination for Jews without recognising that an ethno-nationalist state on other people's land isn't possible without exclusion, expulsion, domination or eradication of those living there. The "Zionism is Racism" motion names the political ideology responsible for the ethnic cleansing and genocide in Palestine.
3:34 All the statements criticise the defeat of an amendment to the motion about praying in Zionist synagogues, despite it being not needed, as the main motion says nothing about this, and as an external policy, rather than a disciplinary motion, it cannot be used to exclude Jewish members. We do not feel threatened at all by this motion and contest the scaremongering about Jewish safety.
4:01 We also reiterate our wholehearted support for the Brent–Nablus twinning, which will strengthen community cohesion. Please note, anti-Zionism is recognised by the UK courts as a protected political belief. Westminster Council faces a legal warning and possible action for breaching its statutory public sector equality duty in passing its "Zionism is not racism" motion.
4:32 We urge Brent parties: first, recognise diversity and consult with us and the Palestinian, Muslim and Arab communities. Second, publicly retract your statements condemning the motion. Three, reject political pressure, merely a weaponisation of antisemitism designed to protect Israel. And finally, work together to end council complicity in Israel's occupation and genocide of Palestinians. Thank you.