- When
- 13 November 2026
- Where
- Stratford-on-Avon District Council
- Party
- Liberal Democrat
- Source
- Conservative Councillors' Association, on Facebook
On 13 November the Conservative Councillors' Association published a graphic quoting a public Facebook comment by Cllr Roger Harding, Liberal Democrat councillor for Stratford Welcombe on Stratford-on-Avon District Council: "Zionism is a supremacist nationalist ideology. By definition, therefore, it is racist. Like apartheid or the KKK".
What happened
The Association's post says: A Lib Dem councillor on Stratford-on-Avon District Council has compared Zionism to apartheid and the KKK in a public Facebook comment. Conservatives won't stand by and let antisemitism go unchallenged in local government. Will the Lib Dems act?
Its graphic is headed The Lib Dems are just as bad as the Greens.
When this was first published this campaign had not seen the comment itself, and gave it as the Association published it, with the Association's graphic below. Later the same day Cllr Harding confirmed the words to the Local Democracy Reporting Service, and the Liberal Democrats suspended the councillor.
“I utterly condemn the policy, and I call on the Green Party to reverse it immediately.”
Cllr Harding is now on this campaign's record of councillors who say Zionism is racism, on zionismisracism.co.uk, and will be corrected if the councillor says the words are not Cllr Harding's. The Liberal Democrats' national position is the opposite of the comment.
Sir Ed Davey wrote on 19 October: I utterly condemn the policy, and I call on the Green Party to reverse it immediately.
More than a hundred Liberal Democrat councillors have put their names to this campaign's statement that Zionism is not racism, so the Association's headline speaks for one councillor, not the party.
Why Cllr Harding is wrong
Self-determination is not supremacy
Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. That is a claim to equality with every other people, not supremacy over anyone. One in five of Israel's citizens is Arab, votes, and sits in the Knesset and on the Supreme Court.
"Nationalist, therefore racist" condemns everyone
If a people's wish for a nation of its own were racist by definition, so would be Welsh, Scottish and Irish nationalism, and Palestinian nationalism too. Only the Jewish people are held to that rule.
Apartheid and the KKK are not comparisons, they are smears
The Ku Klux Klan is a terrorist movement that lynched Black Americans and attacked Jews. To set the belief held by most British Jews beside it is to call those Jews the equal of their persecutors.
Criticise a government, not a people
Anyone may criticise any Israeli government, as Israelis do. Calling Zionism itself racist is a different thing: it says Jews alone may not have a homeland.








