Zionism Is Not Racism
Act now

Liberal Democrat · Bath and North East Somerset

Cllr John Leach: "Political Zionism is and always has been racist", though the Green Party's motion goes too far

From Cllr John Leach, writing to this campaign

When
2 November 2026
Where
Bath and North East Somerset
Party
Liberal Democrat
Source
Cllr John Leach, writing to this campaign

Cllr John Leach, Liberal Democrat councillor for Walcot on Bath and North East Somerset Council, emailed this campaign on 2 November 2026: "Political Zionism is and always has been racist. It has been an apartheid political ideology from the past 100 years and has shown itself in the past few years to be a genocidal political ideology. Its nature cannot be spun to soften its inhumanity towards the Palestinian people and I condemn it absolutely."

What happened

Cllr Leach added: However, the Green Party motion equates all flavours of Zionism with Political Zionism and that I disagree with. IMHO, Zionism as a cultural attitude is not necessarily racist and I have no doubt there are many non-political Zionists who are not racist.

The email is below in full. The Liberal Democrats' leader, Sir Ed Davey, has called the Green Party's motion deeply offensive and antisemitic.

The emails, in order

  1. 2 Nov 2026

    "Political Zionism is and always has been racist"

    The emails between this campaign and Cllr John Leach

Why Cllr John Leach is wrong

Sent to the address for those against the motion, from a council address, and taken at its word: "Political Zionism is and always has been racist", an apartheid ideology for a hundred years, genocidal, condemned "absolutely". Political Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people should have a state of their own in their ancestral homeland. That is what the word has meant since 1897, and it is the belief that most British Jews hold. "Always has been" reaches back a century before the present Israeli government took office: the condemnation is of the idea of the state, not of any government's conduct.

Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, including many who are fierce critics of Israeli governments.

Israel's Declaration of Independence promises "complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex". Arab citizens are about a fifth of Israel's population; they vote, sit in its parliament and have sat on its Supreme Court. Criticise any Israeli government as hard as you like, as Zionists do every day in Israel's own press and parliament. A government's conduct is not the belief that the country should exist.

Anti-Zionism and antisemitism are two words, and this campaign has never said they are one. The question is what follows from the position as stated: that the belief in a Jewish state, held by most of the Jewish residents of Bath and of every other city, is racism and always was. Criticising the Israeli government's conduct is a view about a government, and Zionists in Israel's own parliament and press hold such views every day. Calling the belief in the state itself racist is a view about a people.

The email went on to say that anti-Zionism is not antisemitism, and to disagree with the motion for equating "all flavours of Zionism" with the political kind, allowing that "Zionism as a cultural attitude is not necessarily racist". In this campaign's view that instinct is right and the line is drawn in the wrong place. The motion's target is political Zionism too: it commits the party to "a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine", which is the end of the Jewish state. The world has been here before. In 1975 the United Nations General Assembly declared that "Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination". In 1991 it revoked that, by 111 votes to 25.

Cllr John Leach's page Bath and North East Somerset's councillors, and where they stand

The latest news

  1. Green Party · Solihull CouncilCllr Samantha Gethen, letter to Cllr Max McLoughlinSolihull Green councillor Alison Wilson shared a video calling Holocaust remembrance "pornography", Reform UK's group leader says, and asks the Greens to withdraw the whipCllr Samantha Gethen, Leader of the Opposition on Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council for Reform UK, wrote on 20 November to Cllr Max McLoughlin, leader of the council's Green group, asking him to withdraw the whip from Cllr...
  2. Reform UK · Sheffield City CouncilCllr Matt Smith, writing to this campaign"I stand full square with the Jewish community": Sheffield councillor Matt Smith puts his name to it, and is "ashamed" of the Sheffield councillors who backed the motionCllr Matt Smith, the Reform UK councillor for Park and Arbourthorne on Sheffield City Council, wrote to this campaign on 20 November to put his name to it: "Zionism is certainly NOT racism."
  3. Reform UK · Sheffield City CouncilCllr Jack Byrom, on Facebook"Sheffield first, not Israel-Palestine": Cllr Jack Byrom asks how much weight the council's ethical procurement policy will carry in its banking tenderCllr Jack Byrom, the Reform UK councillor for Richmond ward on Sheffield City Council, posted a clip from this week's Finance Committee, where the council's banking contract with Barclays was discussed again.
  4. Inside the Green PartySussex Express (SussexWorld)Wealden's Green leader, the party's deputy leader, objects to calling the motion "a racist or antisemitic policy"Cllr Rachel Millward, the Green leader of Wealden District Council and a deputy leader of the Green Party of England and Wales, told a council meeting on Wednesday 18 November that her group opposes the "Zionism is Racism"...

All the news