- When
- 29 October 2026
- Where
- City of Edinburgh Council
- Source
- Edinburgh Evening News
The City of Edinburgh Council voted on Thursday 29 October, by a majority of Conservative, Labour and Liberal Democrat councillors against the Scottish Greens and the SNP, to "condemn the divisive language of the [Green Party of England and Wales] conference motion, reaffirm its opposition to antisemitism and express its solidarity with Edinburgh's Jewish community", and for the council leader, Cllr Jane Meagher, to write to the Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, and the First Minister, John Swinney, "reaffirming Edinburgh's unequivocal opposition to antisemitism and its commitment to protecting Jewish communities".
What was reported
The Edinburgh Evening News reported that the proposer, Cllr Marie-Clair Munro (Conservative), told the council: I also recognise there are different interpretations of Zionism within the Jewish community. But describing Zionism simply as racism risks making young Jewish people feel their identity and beliefs are being judged.
Seconding, Cllr Tim Jones (Conservative) said: Jewish people in Edinburgh no longer feel safe. Never did I imagine that in my lifetime I would hear those words uttered from the Jewish community. Zionism is not racism. Every nation has the right to self-determination without exception.
For the Liberal Democrats, Cllr Euan Davidson said: Branding aspirations of the Jewish people, and only the Jewish people, to self-determination as racist is quite clearly antisemitic. Palestinian freedom and Jewish self-determination are not competing principals. We must defend both.
Against it, Cllr Alys Mumford (Scottish Greens) said: Our party has long held the view that modern day Zionism, that Jewish people have a superior right to the land of Palestine, is a racist ideology which creates apartheid
; Cllr Susan Rae (Scottish Greens) called the motion ridiculous
; Cllr Stuart Dobbin (SNP) said the proposer had chosen to politicise this in a manner that is unhelpful
.
“Jewish people in Edinburgh no longer feel safe. Never did I imagine that in my lifetime I would hear those words uttered from the Jewish community. Zionism is not racism. Every nation has the right to self-determination without exception.”
A deputation from Maurice Naftalin, of Progressive Jews for Justice in Israel/Palestine, said the motion identifies anti-Zionism as a contributor to antisemitism, implicitly accepting that all Jews are Zionists
.






