- When
- 20 November 2026
- Where
- South Tyneside Council
- Party
- Green Party
- Source
- Cllr Matt Blair, writing to this campaign
Cllr Matt Blair, Green councillor for West Park on South Tyneside Council, answered this campaign's question on 20 November, from his council address: "yes, I support the motion and I would have voted for it."
What happened
He asked that the register be changed to say so, and it has been. He also asked not to be represented as saying that every understanding of Zionism, or every person who calls themselves a Zionist, is racist; this site does not say that he does. His email is below in full, with the email it answers.
The emails, in full
Why Cllr Matt Blair is wrong
The motion's definition is the problem
Cllr Blair says this campaign's definition of Zionism is not the motion's. It is not: the motion writes its own, "an ethnonationalist Jewish State ... to the exclusion and/or domination of the non-Jewish population", and declares that racism. But the people it lands on are those who call themselves Zionists, and they mean that the Jewish people, like every other people, may have a homeland of their own. A party cannot rewrite what a people believe and then condemn them for the rewritten version.
The motion makes none of his distinctions
He writes that he would not call racist someone who wants Israel to exist with equal rights for all. That describes most Zionists. The motion he supports draws no such line: it orders that Zionism be "treated as any other form of racism" inside the party, an amendment protecting members with ties to Jewish community institutions was voted down, and it calls for "a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine", which leaves no Israel at all.
A government is not a belief
Occupation, settlements and the conduct of an Israeli government can be opposed, and are, by many Zionists. None of that requires calling the belief in a Jewish homeland racism. British Jews do not answer for the Israeli government, as Cllr Blair himself says; what the Green Party says about the belief of most British Jews is the party's own doing.
What he gets right
He writes that antisemitism is "real and abhorrent" and that people should be judged on what they believe, not on a label. In this campaign's view that is an argument against the motion, which judges people by the label.





