"All Zionism is Racism: 'Cultural', 'non-Statist', 'Sense of Homeland', or Otherwise"
The statement in which the mask slips: not a policy or a government but "the basic idea" that Jews may call historical Palestine home is "a racist idea", even "subconscious" racism.
Even Martin Buber's plan for a shared, binational state is called racist
The full analysis: the quotation, and what is wrong with it
Zionism, as they define it
What they said
Just the basic idea that historical Palestine is "a place [that Jews from Europe, North America and elsewhere can] call home", as soon as it is given any intent to implement in practice, is a racist idea … Racism can of course be subconscious as well as intentional. But, no matter how painful this realisation may be, it is still racism.
Antisemitic
Their statement "All Zionism is Racism: "Cultural", "non-Statist", "Sense of Homeland", or Otherwise", 22 March 2026
What is wrong with it
Antisemitic. It calls the belief that Jews may call Israel home racist, even in someone who does not know they are racist. That is the belief of most Jews.
Why is this antisemitic?
The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."
Here the mask slips. Not a policy, not a government, not a settlement: the basic idea that Jews may call the Land of Israel home is, they say, racist, even when the person holding it does not know it.
That is the belief of most Jews in Britain. A party that adopts this view has declared most of its Jewish neighbours racists. The same statement goes on to call even Martin Buber's plan for a shared, binational state of Arabs and Jews racist too.