- When
- 30 April 2026
- Source
- Quoting Professor Haim Bresheeth
Their answer to the motion's critics after the spring conference.
From Quoting Professor Haim Bresheeth
Their answer to the motion's critics after the spring conference.
The full analysis, line by line
Line by line
What they said
Jews are not a nation … Those who will reject such a legal basis for citizenship, will have to find another state which welcomes self-declared racists as citizens. … The future state of Palestine … will have the right to prosecute all those who have partaken in the Apartheid and genocide which Israel has inflicted on the Palestinians.
Antisemitic
Their statement "Rebuttal: Zionism is and has always been Racism", 30 April 2026, quoting Professor Haim Bresheeth
What is wrong with it
Antisemitic. It says Jews are not a nation, and that those who object should "find another state".
The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."
Their own answer to "what happens to Israel's Jews" is in their own words: those who object leave, and those who "partook" are prosecuted, in a country where military service is compulsory for most Jewish citizens.
And "Jews are not a nation" denies the Jewish people the one thing every other people is granted: the right to call themselves a people. The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives as an example "denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination".
Green Party · Solihull CouncilCllr Samantha Gethen, letter to Cllr Max McLoughlinSolihull Green councillor Alison Wilson shared a video calling Holocaust remembrance "pornography", Reform UK's group leader says, and asks the Greens to withdraw the whipCllr Samantha Gethen, Leader of the Opposition on Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council for Reform UK, wrote on 20 November to Cllr Max McLoughlin, leader of the council's Green group, asking him to withdraw the whip from Cllr...
Liberal Democrats · Kingston upon ThamesThe Jewish ChronicleCllr Brian Austen apologises after calling Zionism "evil" and "genocidal", the Jewish Chronicle reportsCllr Brian Austen, the Liberal Democrat councillor for Coombe Vale on Kingston upon Thames Council, has apologised for what he wrote to this campaign, the Jewish Chronicle (Jane Prinsley) reported on 20 November.
Reform UK · Sheffield City CouncilCllr Matt Smith, writing to this campaign"I stand full square with the Jewish community": Sheffield councillor Matt Smith puts his name to it, and is "ashamed" of the Sheffield councillors who backed the motionCllr Matt Smith, the Reform UK councillor for Park and Arbourthorne on Sheffield City Council, wrote to this campaign on 20 November to put his name to it: "Zionism is certainly NOT racism."
Reform UK · Sheffield City CouncilCllr Jack Byrom, on Facebook"Sheffield first, not Israel-Palestine": Cllr Jack Byrom asks how much weight the council's ethical procurement policy will carry in its banking tenderCllr Jack Byrom, the Reform UK councillor for Richmond ward on Sheffield City Council, posted a clip from this week's Finance Committee, where the council's banking contract with Barclays was discussed again.