- When
- 6 November 2026
- Where
- Sheffield City Council
- Party
- Green Party
- Source
- The Green Party, press release
The Green Party of England and Wales issued a press release on 6 November headed "Green Party responds to continuation of power-sharing in Sheffield".
What was reported
It says Cllr Fran Belbin wrote to Cllr Angela Argenzio on 16 October stating demands which councillor Argenzio rejected
, that the Labour Party declared on 2 November it would end the arrangement, and that at full council on 4 November Cllr Belbin announced a U-turn from her and her national party's previous declarations
. It notes Dame Angela Eagle's words that what happens in Sheffield will be a matter for both the party chair and the NEC to decide
, confirming that the NEC's position is unchanged
.
A spokesperson is quoted: In Sheffield, the Green Group have stood firmly by their principles, and are continuing to put residents above political point-scoring. The local Labour Party have also realised that smashing apart their administration at the whims of Labour HQ isn't in residents' interests. Andy Burnham's authoritarian diktat has angered councillors and residents across the country, including those in his own party. The Labour Party leadership's attempts to force local councillors to tear up agreements they've worked hard to maintain have resulted in their own councillors defying this overreach. The Labour Party leadership's support for Israel seems to have no limit, arming a genocide, locking up pensioners for holding up pieces of paper, and now attempting to disrupt successful local partnerships from delivering for residents.
“what happens in Sheffield will be a matter for both the party chair and the NEC to decide”
Three things stand out, set against the record.
First, the release does not contain the words Zionism, motion, Jewish or antisemitism: the policy that caused the dispute is not named.
Second, it says Labour's demands were rejected
: the demand was one sentence, that not all Zionists are racists, and the party's own account is that the Green group refused it. That is the opposite of what Cllr Belbin told the council on 4 November, that the Greens had confirmed
Zionism is not inherently racist.
Third, stood firmly by their principles
means, in the party's own telling, that the Sheffield Green group did not give ground on the motion.




