Zionism Is Not Racism
Act now
Cllr Fran Belbin, Labour councillor for Firth Park, Sheffield

Councillor

Cllr Fran Belbin

Labour & Co-operative

Fran Belbin is a Labour councillor for Firth Park ward on Sheffield City Council, in Yorkshire and the Humber. Cllr Fran Belbin has spoken out against the Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion, but has not yet put their name to the campaign that Zionism is not racism.

The council leader on video, 4 November 2026

Cllr Belbin tells full council the Greens have answered on "not all Zionists are racist". The Greens' statement does not mention Zionism

A clip of Cllr Fran Belbin, the Labour Leader of Sheffield City Council, explaining to the delayed full council meeting of 4 November why the meeting was late: talks with the Green group, and "a new statement coming out from the Greens last night in terms of the things that we have been asking for". Here it is in full, with a transcript, and what is wrong with it.

Sheffield City Council, full council, 4 November 2026, as shared on Facebook (1 min 39 s). Shown in full for reporting and comment.

What the council leader says, and what the record shows

  1. "A new statement coming out from the Greens last night"

    The statement Sheffield Green Party published on the night of 3 November is on this site in full. It says Labour's Cllr Mark Rusling is "plainly lying", that Labour has created "chaos", that a complaint has been lodged against him with the council's Monitoring Officer, and that at conference members voted for "a state where people of all faiths and ethnicities, including Jews, Muslims and Christians can live together". It does not contain the words "Zionist", "Zionism" or "self-determination". No other statement from the Sheffield Greens that night has been published. If one exists, this site will carry it in full.

  2. "Not all Zionists are racist"

    That was Sheffield Labour's bottom line on 2 November, the one sentence Cllr Belbin "would have settled for". The Green group has not said it in public. What Sheffield's Green councillors have said, and not withdrawn, is the opposite: Cllr Raouf, "Zionism is racism, that is Green Party policy as of now"; Cllrs Dimond, Raouf and Ahmed on the open letter supporting the motion. The motion itself declares the Green Party "an anti-Zionist party", and a council group's statement does not change party policy.

  3. "People have the right to self-determination"

    On 2 November the second point was precise: "self-determination is the right of the peoples of Palestine and Israel". "People have the right to self-determination" does not name Israel. The motion the Sheffield Greens have not rejected calls for "a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine", which leaves no Israel.

  4. "The constructive way that they have approached conversations"

    Two days earlier Cllr Belbin wrote: "Our trust in Sheffield Greens is completely broken." The night before this meeting the Greens called a Labour councillor a liar and lodged a complaint against him. The Liberal Democrat group leader, Cllr Martin Smith, said the same afternoon: "This is an extraordinary U-turn and a shameful abandonment of principle by Labour." In this campaign's view, the question Cllr Belbin put on 2 November was the right one, and it has not been answered: is Zionism racism, or not?

Read the transcript

An automatic transcript of the clip, with hesitations removed and nothing else changed. The clip starts mid-sentence and ends mid-speech. The times are approximate, and the video is above so you can check every word against it.

0:00 ... brought home, and you'll see forward so that our last people do get home at a reasonable hour. But I hope, and I want to just thank you very particularly. I know you're not very well today, and generally, thank you for presiding anyway.

0:17 The reason that we are late today, let us be clear about it, as people are well aware, is that we have been having discussions between ourselves, the Lib Dem group, and the Green Party over the course of today to see if we can get ourselves to a better place.

0:35 And those of you will all be aware of, because of the public statements that have been made over the last few weeks since the Greens passed their conference motion, Zionism is racism. That has brought about some very, very passionate feelings and announcements from different members of the public and from different political groups.

1:01 And as you will be aware, we have been trying on working with the Greens to try and come to a better place in the last couple of weeks. I'm really pleased that, what is very much the last minute, I appreciate that we did see a new statement coming out from the Greens last night in terms of the things that we have been asking for around the not all Zionists are racist and that people have the right to self-determination.

1:28 Now today, and I'm genuinely grateful to the Green group for the constructive way that they have approached conversations with us.

Put this on your website

Paste this code into your website, blog or newsletter page. It stays up to date by itself and links back here. Add ?theme=light to the address for a white background.

In the news

21 news stories naming Cllr Fran Belbin

  1. Sheffield's Labour leader on why the administration ended: Cllr Ahmed's posts were "blatantly antisemitic", and "in any other party, he would have been suspended instantly"The Star (Rose Mason, Local Democracy Reporting Service)
  2. The Jewish Chronicle: Sheffield Green Cllr Mustafa Ahmed reposts the 2023 post, "poorly advised" to take it down, and a second post is reportedThe Jewish Chronicle (Jane Prinsley)
  3. Marie Tidball MP backs Sheffield Labour ending the joint administration: the Greens "have been unable to provide the reassurances our communities deserve"Marie Tidball MP, statement
  4. Sheffield Green Party answers Labour ending the joint administration: "decisions for Sheffield Labour are made in London", and says nothing of the motion or of Cllr AhmedSheffield Green Party, on Facebook
  5. Sheffield's Labour leader ends the joint administration with the Greens: "We cannot, in good faith, continue our partnership with a group where such blatant antisemitism is not adequately challenged"The Star (Joe Cawthorn), reporting Cllr Fran Belbin's statement on Facebook
  6. The JC: Sheffield Green councillor Mustafa Ahmed, a prominent backer of the motion, shared a post telling Muslims "You alone will bear the shame of supporting the Jews". The party says the post is deleted and regrettedThe Jewish Chronicle
  7. Cllr Fran Belbin, Sheffield's Labour leader: "I will not sign up to any agreement that targets an idea that is so central to the beliefs of many in our Jewish community". The Greens "are now listening"Cllr Fran Belbin, on Facebook
  8. The Green Party on Sheffield: the Greens "stood firmly by their principles", Labour's demands were "rejected", and Andy Burnham's "authoritarian diktat" has failed. The word Zionism does not appearThe Green Party, press release
  9. "A self-absorbed, self-indulgent psychodrama": Sheffield's Liberal Democrats move to strip Cllrs Dimond and Raouf of their committee chairs, and lose by 34 to 39. Cllr Clement-Jones: "a nasty policy by a nasty party"The Star
  10. Sheffield Labour "defies orders" to keep its deal with the Greens, The Jewish Chronicle reports. Dame Angela Eagle: Labour "cannot be in coalition with Green groups that don't repudiate the awful implications of the motion"The Jewish Chronicle
  11. Tell Sheffield Labour: a new campaign. One email to all 26 Labour councillors on Sheffield City Council, copied to the city's Labour MPs, its mayor and the Green Party: keep your wordZionism Is Not Racism
  12. Cllr Belbin: Sheffield Greens have confirmed "Zionism is not inherently racist", so Labour will carry on. The Greens' statement says Labour's councillor is "plainly lying", the motion stands, and nothing about ZionismCllr Fran Belbin, on Facebook
  13. Sheffield: Labour's U-turn. Two days after "our trust in Sheffield Greens is completely broken", the joint administration carries on. "An extraordinary U-turn and a shameful abandonment of principle," says the Liberal Democrat leader, Cllr Martin SmithBBC News
  14. "The trust is broken": Sheffield Labour publishes its full account of why it ended the joint administration with the Greens, naming Cllrs Dimond, Raouf and AhmedSheffield Labour
  15. Sheffield: Labour ends its power-sharing with the Greens. "Our trust in Sheffield Greens is completely broken"Jewish News
  16. Sheffield's Green councillors say the motion "has caused some concern"; their statement does not say whether they support itThe Star, Sheffield
  17. Ten days on, Sheffield's Green group has still not rejected the motion, and the city's Labour and Green administration hangs on itThe Star, Sheffield
  18. Sheffield's Green planning chair will not resign: "I will not let the yellow or red army bully me", and "Zionism is racism, that is Green Party policy as of now"The Star, Sheffield
  19. Sheffield's Green group refuses Labour's ultimatum: "If Labour chooses to destabilise Sheffield City Council over this, Labour owns the consequences"The Star, Sheffield
  20. Marie Tidball MP, on the day Sheffield Labour wrote to the Greens: the motion "is wrong and antisemitic", and the Greens must "publicly reject the motion if the joint administration with Labour is to continue"Marie Tidball MP, on Facebook
  21. Labour gives its local Green partners seven days to reject the motion, or the power-sharing deals endITV News

Spoke out against the motion

Cllr Fran Belbin, Labour leader of Sheffield City Council, called the Green Party's motion "shameful and antisemitic" on 15 October and told the council's Green group that their joint administration would end unless they "publicly reject" it. On 2 November Cllr Belbin published the account of why Labour ended the joint administration: "The Green Party have defined Zionism as support for the current Israeli government, but Zionism actually takes many forms, including secular, socialist and anti-racist, and the majority of our Jewish population are vehemently opposed to Israel's actions in Gaza." Labour's "bottom line" was "that not all Zionists are racists and that self-determination is the right of the peoples of Palestine and Israel"; Cllr Belbin "would have settled for the first". "Our trust in Sheffield Greens is completely broken."

Reported by Sheffield Labour, 2 November 2026.

On side against the motion is not the same as supporting this campaign: Cllr Fran Belbin has not put their name to its one sentence, "Zionism is not racism", and may not agree with everything on this site. They are asked to, like every MP and councillor.

Spoke out against the motion

Cllr Fran Belbin wrote to this campaign on 11 November 2026:

“It is exactly the reason why the Labour Party, locally, regionally and nationally, object to the Zionism is Racism motion in the first place, because at the very least, it fans the flames of antisemitism and makes Jewish people in our city feel afraid. Despite the very best efforts and intentions of the Sheffield Labour Party, it is clear that the joint administration with the Green Party in Sheffield must now come to an end.”

Has not yet put their name to it

Zionism is not racism. I call on the Green Party to reverse its "Zionism is Racism" motion.

Councillors and MPs of every party in England and Wales are being asked to put their names to this one sentence. Not having signed it does not mean someone supports the Green Party's motion: they may simply not have been asked yet.

Ask Cllr Fran Belbin to endorse it

Opens an email in your own email app, addressed to them, asking them to make their position clear, with the links to pledge. Nothing is sent until you press send, and we never see it. Live there? Ask all your councillors and your MP at once.

Are you Cllr Fran Belbin? Sign in with your council email address to add your name.

At a glance

Party
Labour & Co-operative
Council
Sheffield
Ward
Firth Park
County
South Yorkshire
Region
Yorkshire and the Humber
The campaign
Spoke out against the motion; not yet put their name to it
Official page
Sheffield website

Questions and answers

Who is Fran Belbin?

Fran Belbin is a Labour councillor for Firth Park ward on Sheffield City Council, in Yorkshire and the Humber. Listed as Labour & Co-operative.

Has Cllr Fran Belbin endorsed the campaign that Zionism is not racism?

Not yet. Councillors and MPs of every party in England and Wales are being asked to put their names to one sentence: "Zionism is not racism. I call on the Green Party to reverse its "Zionism is Racism" motion." Not having signed it does not mean someone supports the Green Party's motion: they may not have been asked yet.

What is the Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion?

On 4 October 2026 the Green Party of England and Wales passed a motion declaring that "Zionism is racism". It brands as racism the belief, held by most British Jews, that the Jewish people have the right to a homeland of their own, and binds the party to treat that belief "as any other form of racism". Councillors and MPs of every other party are being asked to say, in public, that Zionism is not racism.

Who are the other councillors for Firth Park?

Cllr Abdul Khayum (Labour) and Cllr Robert Hanson (Local / Residents party). Each has a page saying where they stand.

How can I ask Cllr Fran Belbin to endorse it?

Use the button on this page: it opens a short email to Cllr Fran Belbin in your own email app, with the link to sign. Nothing is sent until you press send.

Other councillors on Sheffield City Council

  • 9 endorsed
  • 28 spoke out against the motion
  • 2 Green, backed the motion
  • 1 say Zionism is racism
  • 19 Green councillors in all

All 84 councillors on Sheffield City Council

From the public record: the council's published details, and endorsements made on this site. Something wrong? Tell us.